Roy Glashan's Library
Non sibi sed omnibus
Go to Home Page
This work is out of copyright in countries with a copyright
period of 70 years or less, after the year of the author's death.
If it is under copyright in your country of residence,
do not download or redistribute this file.
Original content added by RGL (e.g., introductions, notes,
RGL covers) is proprietary and protected by copyright.
RGL e-Book Cover
Based on an image created with Microsoft Bing software
"The Tolliver Case," Hodder — Stoughton, London, 1934
"Prove It, Mr. Tolefree" William Morrow & Company, New York, 1934
They found Sir William Tolliver face down in a trout stream—his rod nearby—the pistol close at hand. Obviously it was suicide, but nobody could understand why. There was only one person who had serious doubts—a girl, his niece. And because she persisted, Tolefree, the detective, was summoned from London...
TOLLIVER died on the morning of the 3rd July. So far as any of us knew at the time, no one saw him die. He had apparently stood on the brink of the little river Tolgerth, not far from his own house, and shot himself. He had fallen into a stickle of the river, where his body was found with his revolver lying on the shingle-bed beside him.
But that was only the appearance behind which Philip Tolefree pushed to the incredible reality here recorded. Farrar, who has made the record, asked me to write an account of the circumstances that induced us to call in Tolefree. He says they are essential to the understanding of the case, and he also says that if I can get it on paper just as I told it to him and Tolefree, it will give what he calls "atmosphere" to his own narrative.
Thinking it over, I have resolved that I need do no more than set down quite shortly what happened at Polventor on the 7th July.
We had buried Tolliver that afternoon....
In the churchyard of Carnmenellis, it was. An exceedingly uncomfortable place for one's long last sleep, I always think, Carnmenellis churchyard right on the top of the cliff, where a tree won't grow and the artificial bouquets the villagers put on their relatives' graves blow away whenever there's a northwester off the Atlantic (which is just about half the year), collect against the stone hedge because they can't blow any farther, and look like an elongated garbage dump. But then, hard wind is the characteristic of this elevated country overlooking the sea, sloping away twenty miles from the serried backbone of the peninsula and fronting the Atlantic with granite bastions four hundred feet high, where the ocean has failed in a million years to batter any hole bigger than the tiny cove in which Carnmenellis village lies. A bare country, lifted up, wind-swept, stubborn—but nobly bare, and gloriously lifted up, and splendidly stubborn, like the people who live on it. It was like them to build that church with the square, squat tower like a fortress on the cliff instead of down in the cove...
Tolliver, for instance. The only feeble and uncharacteristic thing in Tolliver's life was the end of it...
Being only twenty-five, I knew nothing of Tolliver's early days. On the coffin, when I looked down upon it from the messy heap of soil and granite rubble beside his grave, was a brass plate:
WILLIAM TOLLIVER, KT.
of Polventor
Nascit XIV Jan., MDCCCLXXX
Obit. III Jul., MCMXXXII
So that Tolliver had passed his first youth when I was born, and before I came to maturity was a-figure to be reckoned with in the world. Fifty-two?—it was no great age in these times. Yet Tolliver had run his course, and what was left of him lay up there on the cliff under a heap of rubble, with just the stars looking down at the mess.
As I sat at his table that evening I couldn't get my mind off the cadaverous vision of Tolliver in Carnmenellis churchyard, though the talk ran, of course, on the Tolliver that had been, not on the Tolliver that was. Four of us in the big dining-room, round a little island of table in its immensity: Mrs. Carberry, his sister; on her right Guy Waverton, the dark eyes in his bearded face solemn and thoughtful; on her left little Ann; opposite her (by some fatality in Tolliver's own chair), I listened and let my thoughts wander out into the night.
It had been a trying day. First the long drive of six miles from Polventor to the sea—horsed carriages going at a walking pace, with a double string of tenants and servants trudging along beside the hearse. Two hours of that. Then the service in the church and an address from Dimott. Very good, Dimott, skating over all his ecclesiastical difficulties about this funeral as became a friend of Tolliver. And then the miserable business of lowering him into that messy hole, and the drive back to Polventor. It seemed an eternity.
Several of the people who had been at Polventor when Tolliver died were absent. Michael and Fearnside had gone back to London. Polpenna went home a little unwell. After the funeral, Andrew Baripper wished Mrs. Carberry good-bye and drove off to the railway station at Carnmenellis Road, and Menhennick went home to Treneglos. There were only five of us left to return over that long trail into the hills, and the fifth was Tolliver's lawyer, Briscoe, who had come down from London to see him buried. When Briscoe read the will, the late afternoon sun streamed into Tolliver's study and glinted on his bottles and test-tubes and all the paraphernalia he cherished where most men would have bestowed books and pictures.
The will revealed no eccentricity. It was made five years ago, and one codicil had been tacked on last year. Tolliver began by specifying some small bequests—the usual in memoriam things—to a number of friends. To me, for example: "To my friend Arnold Angwin, of Tresneven, any sporting piece he may select from the gun-room at Polventor." And "To my friend Guy Waverton, of Glensdorp, Johannesburg, all my trout-rods and fishing-gear, in remembrance of old days on the Tolgerth." And "To my friend Charles Dimott, M.A., vicar of Carnmenellis, any hundred books he may select from my library at Polventor." That sort of thing. He gave legacies to several institutions. He set aside a fund of £10,000 for his niece, Ann Carberry, to be administered by Briscoe till she was twenty-nine, and then to be at her own disposal. The residue of all his property, real and personal, was left to "my dear sister Louise Carberry, in token of my gratitude for her unfailing affection." The codicil of February 1932 bequeathed a thousand pounds "to Ada Lanherne, orphan daughter of my trusted colleague, the late Francis Lanherne, professor of chemistry in the University of London."
Tolliver's great business was a strange country to me, and I knew nothing whatever of Professor Lanherne and his daughter. But when Briscoe read this out, Mrs. Carberry said, "Poor Ada!" and then it appeared that Miss Lanherne, for whom Tolliver had made this provision on the death of her father, had herself died in a nursing home a month ago. Briscoe remarked that he heard the sad fact from Tolliver, who had told him in a letter that, when next in London, he would take steps to cancel the codicil and make some other slight alterations in his will. However... and Briscoe left that in the air.
The man of law desired to catch the night train for London, and as that involved a forty-five miles drive to Plymouth, he took a whisky and soda and a plate of sandwiches instead of tea, and did not stay for dinner.
I could not possibly give an adequate idea of the disaster Tolliver's death seemed to us, or of the horror and mystery that clouded Polventor. It had transformed even Ann Carberry. The last time I sat with her at that table, the evening before Tolliver died, she was at her most elfish, tantalizing sprightliest—shooting her audacities at everyone, challenging Dimott's theology, chaffing Waverton as The Bearded Pard, affecting to reveal grisly secrets in the financial life of Andrew Baripper, reserving her sharpest shafts for my bucolic dullness, while Tolliver, who adored her, sat munching walnuts and grinning his enjoyment. But now, Ann stared from one to the other of us with a set face, her vivid colour paled, a little line between her eyebrows, while we composed our spasmodic obituary sentences about Tolliver.
"If you two don't want to sit here drinking," said Mrs. Carberry, when the servants had left us, "come to my sitting-room. Ann has something to say to you."
Waverton and I rose and stood one on each side of the door while the beautiful Mrs. Carberry, looking lovelier than ever in her unaccustomed black, led Ann across the hall and up the stairs to her room. In the purely feminine graciousness of that place, I was for the moment less conscious of the ghost of Tolliver, never having seen there the tall, spare form and the iron-grey head and the quizzical brown eyes that haunted me in the room below. Waverton fussed over cushions for Mrs. Carberry in her chair facing the open window, looking to the west and the golden sky where the sun fired low clouds over the distant line of the sea. A glance from Ann warned that she would not stand for any fussing. She perched on a stool. Waverton and I settled down between them.
"Guy—and Arnold," said Mrs. Carberry, "this awful thing—we want you to be our friends. Ann and I are alone in the world. We have nobody——"
"You know, Louise——"
Waverton bent towards her in a protective gesture.
"Yes, Guy. I know all that. And Arnold too. If you had to skin yourselves to clothe us, you would. But it's not that. I'm a rich woman as things go these days, and now Bill's made me three times as rich. We have everything in the world—except Bill."
Both of us murmured: what could one say, except that Tolliver had passed so completely out of their reach that no friendship could restore him? And Mrs. Carberry was in no need of banalities.
"It's not that. We want your help—about Bill," she said; "your counsel—advice."
"Anything, Louise," said Waverton. "And you, Angwin?"
I nodded. "Anything."
"Well, I don't know. It's difficult. You'd better hear what Ann has to say."
We looked to the girl, crouched with elbows on knees and eyes on the distant scene where the square tower of Carnmenellis was a tiny black silhouette against the flame of sunset.
"I can say it in ten seconds," she began. "I don't believe Uncle Bill committed suicide. I believe he was murdered. I mean to find out who killed him."
"But—Ann!——"
If she had taken a pistol in each hand and pointed them at our heads instead of sitting there and saying it quietly with her gaze fixed upon the horizon, she could not have startled us more.
"But—Ann! The evidence—police—inquest——everything——"
Waverton's incoherence reflected my own astonishment.
"Evidence?" said Ann. "No one knows better than you that the evidence is—what d'you call it?—circumstantial. You were there. Police?—mutts, just mutts. Inquest?—the Coroner's a doddering old formalist. Everything?—there's nothing!"
She said all this in a level, unraised voice, with a coldness extraordinary in Ann.
"Perhaps——" Waverton said, and stopped.
"All right. I will. Let's see whether we can find any flaws in all this tomfool legal logic."
Ann got up from her stool, walked to the window and turned to face us.
"I was very fond of Uncle Bill. He was fond of me. We understood each other better than anyone else understood us. Yes, mother—I know! You're his sister and all that. But I'm sure I knew him better. We were pals—and intimate pals. And I just know that Uncle Bill did not do this, because he couldn't do it. He'd have scorned to do it. He was the bravest man in the world. If there'd been anything to face out, he'd have faced it out. He was the sanest man in the world. Even the fool Coroner wouldn't say he was temporarily insane! He was the kindest man in the world, and he's said to have done the unkindest thing a man can do. Do I know that if he'd been going to kill himself, he couldn't have said to me that morning, 'Cheerio, Ann: see you at lunch'? I do know it. He meant to see me at lunch. He would have seen me at lunch if someone hadn't shot him. He didn't shoot himself. I'll never believe it, and I'll never rest till I know who did."
Ann's ultimatum—so I thought of it afterwards. It left us gaping. But after the first shock of an utterly new and previously inconceivable idea, my mind got going on Ann's lines. True the fact that Tolliver had committed suicide seemed to have been established beyond doubt, and if there was no apparent motive for his self-murder—well, human beings do strange things. Yet, there was something in Ann's argument from intuition. People accept accomplished facts, or what appear to be accomplished facts, at their face value, and do not stop to consider whether they may have hidden faces. We should all have said before Tolliver died that it was impossible for him to commit suicide; but when he was dead and all the circumstances shrieked suicide, we had put away psychology and taken physical fact as an adequate explanation. To Ann the physical facts counted for nothing. She felt in her bones that Tolliver could not have killed himself; therefore he did not. But he was dead....
As I say, we were left gaping. These reflections shot through my mind as Waverton spoke:
"Ann—have you anything in the back of your head?"
"Anything? Haven't I just——"
"Yes—but I mean anything to go upon. Anything that we don't know and the police don't know? We'd all like to believe that your uncle didn't—but the facts——"
"Facts!" Ann snorted. "You men and your facts——"
"Now, don't go off the deep end, Ann. That won't help. Look the facts in the face. Tolliver was found killed by his own gun, and the gun was beside him, in unusually convincing circumstances. To all appearances no one but he could have fired the shot that killed him. Now, if you know anything different——"
Ann moved to her stool and sat down with a sigh.
"My dear Guy," said she, "you're as hopeless as Inspector Marrack! You simply will bleat on about facts and circumstances. The only fact I know is that Uncle Bill is dead. No one saw him shot dead, so it can't be said for a fact that he shot himself. I know you didn't see him, for you were looking at me when it happened. As to the circumstances, in my opinion no one has even considered the essential circumstances. Didn't you say no one else could have fired the shot that killed him? Why, I can tell you three people who could!"
"How on earth, Ann——"
"That fanatic Ridgway could. That lunatic Paul Penhaligon could. And so could Gannett. We don't know where either of them was that morning, and no one's thought of finding out. Mind you, I don't say they did. But they could. So your argument that no one could goes down the drain."
Waverton shrugged his shoulders and turned away from Ann to her mother.
"I know what you'd say," she went on. "You'd say that if they could they didn't, because Uncle Bill was found, and his gun was found, so-and-so. But that don't satisfy me, Guy. You admit there was no reason why he should commit suicide. I declare that he was incapable of suicide. Now, mother—it's up to you."
Waverton discharged a little grunt of relief, and turned again to Mrs. Carberry, sitting beside him.
"I know it seems strange and daring, Guy, after all the evidence and the police inquiries and inquest, and so on, but don't you think there's something in what Ann says? And you, Arnold?"
"About the mystery of it? Yes," said I. "We've all felt that."
"Quite so. But something more than the mystery. I mean—the feeling that Bill really couldn't have done this because it wasn't in him? That there must be something we haven't thought of?"
It occurred to me immediately that this cut both ways: there might be something in Tolliver's life of which we hadn't thought because we didn't know it. Mrs. Carberry's dark eyes seemed to divine that fleeting suggestion in my face.
"I don't mean," she went on, "that Bill himself was concealing anything. He was open as the day—had a sort of serene frankness that I've seen in few men. But mayn't there be something in the circumstances, something subtle, that wouldn't strike a man like Marrack, but might be seen by a different sort of man?"
For the moment I thought she meant that Waverton and I were to be the different sort of man and that this explained her appeal to us for help and counsel. A little alarming, that thought; for Marrack was a friend of mine, quite a good policeman, accustomed to weighing evidence, and in the circumstances it was highly improbable that either Waverton or I, or both of us, could discover anything he had failed to see. Waverton, however, was quicker to perceive her drift.
"Ah!" said he, "you mean calling in someone to track things down?"
"Well—what do you think?" asked Mrs. Carberry.
Waverton pulled the point of his beard, considering.
"Candidly, Louise, I can't think there's anything to discover. I hate to say it, Ann, but there 'tis. Still, what Angwin calls the mystery certainly remains—the feeling that there ought to be some other explanation. If a good man could be put on it—well, yes. Only, we should remember that the police won't like it—won't be helpful."
"Good for you, Guy!" said Ann, starting up again. "What about you, Arnold?"
"Depends on the man," I ventured. "If he was any good—that's the point. Private detectives—I never saw one, but they've got a smelly sort of reputation, haven't they? Still, if you could have a good man you might get over Waverton's objection by keeping him sub rosa. I mean—why should Marrack or Brimmell know anything about him?"
"There!" cried Ann. "It's an inspiration! Mother—tell them."
Whereupon it became obvious that the issue of this consultation had been settled by the Carberrys before it started. Mrs. Carberry went to her writing-desk, took some papers from a drawer.
"These," she said, "are two letters I found among Bill's private things. Ann and I think they sort of indicate the sort of man we want. Both are from Mr. Fearnside to Bill about business. In the first he says the best man he knows to get at the bottom of some roguery in the office is a Mr. Philip Tolefree, of Watling Street, in the City, and he asks Bill if he shall engage him. The next says that this Mr. Tolefree has uncloaked the whole thing in three days, and inquires of Bill what shall be done with the offender."
She looked up from the letters.
"Some private detective snooping around? All right in London, you know, Louise, but a haystack wouldn't hide him down here. It's a type, you know—sticks out."
Waverton echoed my own dismay at the idea of employing a person of this stamp.
"Ah, but listen to Mr. Fearnside. He says, 'Tolefree asks me to tell you he is particularly anxious that his connection with this inquiry should be known to no one. He camouflages this kind of work with a business in insurance, and privacy is most important to him. He's quite an unusual kind of private detective: bit of a scholar and all of a gentleman. So if you will oblige by keeping it dark——' Ann and I thought that might be the sort of man."
"Sounds good," said Waverton; "but I don't see how you could keep him dark down here. Ten minutes after such a man put up at the Carnmenellis Inn the place would be buzzing with him."
I suppose I was really responsible for bringing Tolefree into the Tolliver case, for I said on the spur of the moment:
"If he's a scholar and a gentleman, Mrs. Carberry, I should be very glad to have him at Tresneven as a guest. Do me a lot of good. It's near enough to make a good base for him. And the gossips——"
"Arnold!" cried Ann, grasping my arm. "Would you? It's a master-stroke!"
"That would make a difference, Angwin," said Waverton.
"Thank you, Arnold," said Mrs. Carberry. "I knew you'd both help."
THE Tolliver case, to which Philip Tolefree devoted a week of such unremitting labour, danger and excitement last summer, ran outside the common ruck of crime problems. It had passed through the hands of the police before he touched it. They had reached their conclusion. So far as the public knew, the Tolliver case was ended; and save for the unshakable conviction of an acute-minded girl, Tolefree would never have heard of it as a "case" in his sense of the word.
He began his investigation, therefore, with one advantage (which he exploited to the utmost), but also with a strong disadvantage from his peculiar point of view.
The advantage: That he could make his inquiries without reference to official favour or disfavour; i.e., he ran no risk of "butting in" upon the police authorities, since they had washed their hands of the business.
The disadvantage: That, owing to the lapse of time between Tolliver's death and Tolefree's arrival in Cornwall (though it was not much more than a week) the scent had cooled, and he missed the opportunity which he always sought of seeing the parties involved at the critical moment and watching their immediate reactions.
This latter point it was that differentiated the Tolliver case from the two previous matters of high criminal interest in which Tolefree played a part. At Midwood, where he succeeded in tracking down the murderer of Wellington Burnet, he was in the place when Burnet died; at Pitway House, where he was no less successful in uncloaking the murderer of Harley, he had arrived within a few minutes of the crime.
Both these solutions were deductions by means of psychological tests—a question-begging way of putting it, but I can think of no better. In both instances Tolefree fell by accident into the atmosphere of major crime, for he had been engaged on inquiries into the lesser matters that led up to it.
At Polventor, however, he was deliberately invited to solve the mystery of Tolliver's death, and, though he applied his own methods of silent trial to an apparently inextricable puzzle, and bored through to the truth, the conditions were quite different.
Of course I had known of Tolliver's death before Tolefree received the letter that took us into the far west. No one in the city of London could fail to have remarked upon its strangeness and sadness. Sir William Tolliver was a familiar name to millions who had never seen him: the head of a great chemical industry, himself a distinguished chemist, must necessarily be in our day a famous man. But famous men pass out, as lesser men do, and the world still turns on its axis. In another week, this event would have been for me like any other event in history but for the letter which Tolefree received that Saturday in July.
He had asked me to call in at his rooms for a pipe and a jaw, as I often did after I had given my nephews and nieces their afternoon airing in the country. I penetrated the Saturday silence of Cannon Street about ten o'clock to find Tolefree dispensing coffee and cigarettes to another guest.
"Hello, Farrar—have a good run with the kids? You know Pierce."
I shook hands with Detective Sergeant Pierce, of Scotland Yard, the sombre and somewhat sardonic officer I met in the Midwood case. It appeared that I broke into the middle of an ardent conversation.
"We were talking shop, Pierce and I," said Tolefree, when he had given me coffee and deposited me in a chair near the open window, looking out over the signal lights of the Southern Railway.
"Go on talking," said I.
"Well, I'd got Tolefree on to his psychological stuff," said Pierce. "We were discussing different sorts of evidence and the way to sort 'em out. I was saying it's dam' hard lines on us poor mutts at Scotland Yard to have these philosophical blokes competing with us—superior brains, you know, and not only that, but all kinds of brilliant short cuts—and, above all, no need to satisfy a police magistrate."
"Don't take any notice of him, Farrar." Tolefree smiled. "Just pretty Fanny's way. Pierce is as good a psychologist as the next man, and he's done some excellent deductions without much more to go on than the lift of an eyelid."
"Deductions!" The detective grunted. "Save 'em up for my halo when I'm dead, will you, Tolefree? Detecting's a dull affair—just plodding along and asking everyone what he knows about it. Deductions! Why, the leading feature of a clue to crime is that it puts you off your stroke ninety-nine times out of a hundred, and the other time, though it might convince anyone with the intelligence of a cockroach, it isn't good enough to pass muster as evidence. Ever been in a police court, Mr. Farrar?"
"Twice with Tolefree," said I, "and once as a defendant in a traffic case: twenty shillings or seven days, of course."
"Ah, well," Pierce sighed. "You'll have seen enough to know that it's only testimony that counts—what people say. And how the devil can you ever be sure what anybody will say?"
"Quite right," Tolefree chuckled. "You can't. And evidence—I mean the evidence of human testimony—which would convince any ordinary person—it's utterly unreliable—what shall I say, Pierce?—four times out of ten? There's some sententious old buffer I've read somewhere says that uncritical faith in human testimony's one of the most copious sources of human error. Which means that man's a credulous animal and his ears deceive him as often as his eyes—and that's almost always."
How prophetic that seemed afterwards, when we were in the thick of the Tolliver affair!
"Well—there you are," said Pierce. "If you can't bring home a case on clues that lead to circumstantial evidence, and if you've got a forty-per-cent. presumption against human eyes and ears—where are you?"
"Where? In the realm of psychology, of course," declared Tolefree. "Searching into character, motive, probability."
"And tush and tush!" Pierce drained his coffee-cup. "You can't convict a man of crime because he has the character of a criminal, or because he had a motive for the crime, or because of the probability that he did it. Take all that to Bow Street Police Court, Tolefree, and see what happens to you!"
"I know. But until we've bred the super-criminal who'll not only make no mistake and leave no trace, but face up to every shock without a quiver of his nerves—character, motive and probability should hand you your man."
Pierce vehemently protested that he'd known fifty cases where they didn't. Hidden characters, cloaked motives, improbabilities invented to look like truth.... Tolefree insisted that no man could hide his character or cloak his motives all the time: everyone had his unwary moments.
"Unwary!" cried Pierce. "What policeman can ever take a man unawares? Impossible, Tolefree! The policeman, whether it's the bobby round the corner or the big noise at Scotland Yard, is bound to advertise himself. He's got to whistle like an express train at a crossing to let you know he's coming. That's where you get the pull over us. No rules for you, you licensed freebooter! Any dodge you like. Any questions you like. No warning necessary to the witness or the suspect. It's so simple!"
"I prescribe another cigarette." Tolefree pushed a box to him. "All admitted, Pierce. On the other hand, think of the licensed freebooter's handicaps: no authority, no force of law behind him, no guarantee that won't be kicked out of anywhere! No—I think my chief pull over you is that I've generally got all the persons in a case in view before they know what I'm up to. You can never have that. You get a corpus delicti, or some fact, and work back to persons from that. I hand it to you, Pierce. If I had to depend on inferences from physical facts alone, I'd make a rotten job of it."
So went the shop talk, myself a silent listener, amused by Pierce's affected misanthropy and Tolefree's constitutional cheerfulness. They kept it up, hammer and tongs, on the comparative evidential value of things and persons. Tolefree would dart to a bookshelf and haul down some fat volume and turn up Mittermaier on the science of proof, or Jeremy Bentham on the distinction between moral probability and mathematical certainty. Pierce would say these old fogeys were all very well, but they hadn't got to secure committals at Bow Street or convictions at the Central Criminal Court....
Precisely how we came round to the Tolliver case I can't remember. But I suppose Tolefree had really been leading up to it all the time. Anyhow, he broke off suddenly, as Pierce was about to leave, with a "By the way——"
"By the way, I suppose both of you noticed the reports of the inquest on Sir William Tolliver?"
"Saw he'd committed suicide," said Pierce.
"I read them, Tolefree," I remarked. "Queer thing that Tolliver should want to kill himself. But great genius—akin to madness——"
I stopped reeling off platitudes as Tolefree turned to his writing-table and picked a paper out of the drawer.
"Yes," said he. "Strange that a man who had, or seemed to have, everything that most people demand from life should suddenly decide to quit. The fatigue of fame, the embarrassment of riches.... I read that in some footling leading article, Farrar. I'm not guying you." He grinned. "But listen to this."
Tolefree snapped on his table-light, put the paper under it, and read:
Polventor,
Carnmenellis,
Cornwall.
8th July, 1932.
"Dear Sir—
"I gather from his papers that some time last year you conducted an inquiry for my late brother, Sir William Tolliver, and that you are known to Mr. Fearnside, of his firm. I wish to know whether it would be possible for you to come here to endeavour to clear up a question which has been raised and in which his family are deeply concerned.
"I also understand that you do not advertise your profession and wish to remain unknown in this capacity. That exactly falls in with our views. We should desire that, if you did come, it should be as the private guest of Mr. Arnold Angwin, a friend and neighbour of ours at Tresneven.
"The matter is urgent, and if you agree to undertake this private inquiry, I shall be obliged if you will telegraph to me and say when you can arrive.
"Yours truly,
"Louise Carberry.
"P.S.—The question at issue is purely private and has nothing to do with Sir William's business."
Pierce held out his hand for the letter, re-read it quickly and said:
"What's all this? Polventor, Carnmenellis, Angwin, Tresneven—is it a foreign language?"
"The Celtic fringe. You don't know Cornwall? Your misfortune. Well—that's Tolliver's country. But what do you make of Mrs. Carberry's invitation?"
"Can't say. You know what women are. Cat's been stealing the silver or something, most likely. Or——"
"Or—yes?
"Well, what do you make of it yourself?"
"Tolliver."
"Probably," said Pierce.
"And you, Farrar?"
"Probably," I agreed. "What's she say?—family deeply concerned? Something inexplicable behind his suicide, of course. They want you to uncover the secrets of the charnel house, but discreetly, so that no unauthorized person will see 'em."
"Perhaps," said Tolefree. "Looked like that to me. So I sent the wire. I wanted to hear from Pierce whether he knew anything of the police in those parts. And from Farrar whether he'd like a spot of holiday in Cornwall: I believe it's lovely in July."
"Well, if I won't be damned!" Pierce exclaimed. "I thought I'd been hospitably invited for coffee and a smoke, to chew over psychology and reality with this merchant! And here I'm just a stalking horse for his own selfish ends."
It appeared that Pierce had no personal knowledge of the police in those parts, but could easily get it, and was quite willing to inform the nearest superintendent that Mr. Tolefree proposed to take a vacation on the Cornish coast and that any little attentions, etcetera, etcetera.
"But," I objected, "that don't quite fill the bill from the point of view of Mrs.—what's her name?—does it? Private inquiry—remain unknown, and all the rest of it?"
But Pierce, said Tolefree, must say nothing of an inquiry. He just wanted the cachet of an acquaintance with Scotland Yard in case the need arose for getting in touch with the police. Pierce had taken his leave before we settled whether I should share Tolefree's "holiday." It was high summer; fearfully hot in London; the prospect of the sea coast attractive—especially a sea coast unknown to me; no urgent reason for staying in Moorgate Street. On the other hand, it was a private visit; I could not very well plant myself on this Mr. Angwin without an invitation.
Tolefree, however, had foreseen all that. He had replied to Mrs. Carberry that he would probably arrive by car on Sunday evening and be accompanied by a friend.
"You have? What colossal cheek!" I exclaimed.
But how well Tolefree knew me!—the irresistible fascination of seeing him at work and lending a hand if he wanted it... a foregone conclusion, as he knew. Mrs. Carberry had replied: both he and his friend would be welcome as guests at Tresneven...
This was how, in a short hour, I plunged into a very minor rôle in that Tolliver case which illustrated so startlingly the theories of evidence Tolefree and Pierce had been discussing over the coffee when I burst in upon them.
THE Tolliver case soon took on an aspect totally dissimilar to that which it had worn in London. But the shortest way to state it will be to skip the speculations that occupied us on our journey and relate how it was stated to Tolefree.
I drove him down on the Sunday, along the whole length of the south of England. We passed under the shadow of the towering castle of Launceston between five and six, and were then in Cornwall. I hardly know how to describe the "differentness" of this country. We began at once to climb through cultivated land towards bare highlands, brown and stark in the summer blaze. As we approached the divide between Channel and Atlantic and the rugged shapes of the highest peaks came black against the sky, Tolefree ceased that outpouring of all manner of out-of-the-way knowledge with which he eased the monotony of long drives, and we both fell silent. It was new country to us, this granite upland, where deep-cut valleys known as "combes" sheltered a few farmsteads; and above them stretched wide spaces of moorland grown with bracken, furze and heather and crowned by fantastic cyclopean rocks called "tors."
It became lonelier and wilder as we rose, the combes shallower, the streams smaller.
We had learned in Launceston that the by-way to Tresneven and Polventor left the main road at the crest of a hill some thirty miles westward, and that a signpost would enlighten us. I drove up a steep incline and was considering the question of slipping into a low gear for the sharp descent that now became visible when, at a corner on the left, a finger-post pointing south appeared. Under it a tall young man stood. As I slowed down to decipher the half-defaced legend, he stepped forward. I stopped. He came to the window.
"Are you gentlemen looking for the road to Tresneven?"
"Yes," said Tolefree. "Is this it?"
"Are you, by any chance, from London?"
"Yes, and are you, by any chance, from Tresneven?"
"Mr. Tolefree?"
"Mr. Angwin?"
"Our old signpost doesn't stand the weather very well, so I thought——"
"Mighty good of you," said Tolefree. "This is Farrar; he's with me."
I don't know why I should have expected Angwin to be an elderly man: something in the association of ideas—Tolliver elderly, his sister probably elderly, therefore a friend of the family probably elderly. But Angwin wasn't more than six-and-twenty. A big fellow, swarthy, with olive tinted skin, warm underneath, well-marked features, black eyebrows, large dark eyes, a rich voice.
"If I might get into the back seat," he said, "I'd be able to guide you. The road tumbles down into our combe rather in a hurry."
"A severe country, Mr. Angwin," said Tolefree, when we were moving again across a piece of hedgeless moor with the granite sand crunching under the tyres. "Ought to grow strong men." He was looking over his shoulder twinkling at the young Hercules.
"Well—yes. It also grows queer characters and strong passions, as you'll find," said Angwin.
Few prophets can ever have been so speedily justified of their prophecies. We dipped into the little combe where, as Angwin told us, Tresneven lay among the trees, and found a gentler air. In pulling the car round a corner, I almost ran into a man who stood with his back to me in the middle of the narrow road, field-glass raised to his eyes, presumably inspecting the face of a house which had just come into view. Hauling on the hand-brake and stepping hard, I yelled out as we jerked to a stop, the radiator within a yard of his back.
The man, his grey hair sticking out in wisps around a skull-cap, scraggily bearded, dressed in a pull-over and skimpy flannel bags, with a camera hanging from straps over his shoulder, stepped on one side.
"Hello!" said I. "Nearly had you that time."
He made no answer, but waved me on, staring hard at Tolefree as the car passed him.
"Attempted suicide balked?" asked Tolefree. "Or one of the queer ones?"
"Queer enough," said Angwin. "Dare say you'll meet him."
"Don't want to. Don't like people who carry guns."
"Guns?" Angwin exclaimed, surprised. "That was a field-glass."
"Yes, I saw the glass, Mr. Angwin. But he carried a gun. In his hip-pocket. You noticed that he wears his trousers unfashionably tight?"
"No," said Angwin, "I didn't notice."
He seemed to shut the topic off. Tolefree did not pursue it. In another minute we were turning in at the gate at Tresneven...
I had an indescribable sensation from the moment we dropped down into this solitary valley of having left the broad highway of common sense and descended into a region of fantastic unreality. The contrast between its umbrageous beauty and the stark nakedness above counted for something, no doubt, though I have seen many such sharp contrasts in other places—they are common enough in Brittany, for example. But that was not all. The "differentness" was accentuated in many ways—by Angwin's unusual type, a something exotic about him, by the weirdness of the figure we had seen, by Tolefree's unquestionably startled exclamation about the gun, by the vagueness of our mission there.
Some of Angwin's turns of speech added to the impression. A plain house—so he apologized for the ordinary, comfortable-looking little mansion we now reached; "undistinguished," said he, "except as the casket that holds my mother." I thought it a pretty compliment to one's mother, but uncommonly put.
However, we found Mrs. Angwin worthy of all compliment. A fragile, gracious little lady, flutteringly devoted to her big son, very anxious to be cordial to his friends. It seemed that the injunction of Mrs. Carberry against any publicity for Tolefree held good even here: Mrs. Angwin faced the apparition of two guests of her son hitherto unseen and quite unexplained. But as between them, evidently, the word of each was for ever law without wrangling.
Tolefree was exquisite. He treated her with an almost antique courtesy, exerted himself to entertain her, fixed himself firmly in her regard before dinner was done. As Angwin rose to see her to her room, she spoke her delight at receiving "Arnold's friends" and hoped our stay at Tresneven would be pleasant.
Angwin took us after dinner to the room he called his "den"—a large room facing a lawn, with a background of thick woods, and one large beech tree at the end of it, whose branches grew right up to the wall of the house. We sat in a green twilight—smoking our pipes—and no doubt each of us trying to orientate himself. Angwin fished about for an opening, got back to the subject of the "queerness" of people, and from that to the influence of environment on character. It was upon this desultory stuff that the telephone bell broke in. Angwin went to the table where the telephone stood. We heard his answers.
"Who's that?... Yes, Ann.... He's here.... A bit late for you, isn't it?... Oh, very well."
He returned to us.
"Miss Carberry," he said. "She's coming over. Toot sweet, she says." His preoccupied look gave place to a smile.
And that switched us on to Tolliver.
"Miss Carberry?" said Tolefree.
"Yes—Ann."
"You must remember that we come without the least knowledge of anyone in the region," Tolefree reminded him. "And of course I don't know to what extent you're in Mrs. Carberry's confidence about me."
"All the way," he replied. "And as for Ann, you'd not have been here but for Ann."
He took an uneasy step or two back and fore.
"I'm rather in a difficulty, Mr. Tolefree," said he. "Mrs. Carberry wants me to tell you the whole thing. And I don't know where to begin."
"Won't you begin by saying how the question of calling me in came up, and why?"
"A long yarn."
"The longer the better. Tell it all. We shall get the atmosphere as well as the facts. But perhaps first you might like to say what it is that I'm to investigate. Is it some consequence of Tolliver's death, or something that happened before? Or is it Tolliver's death itself?"
"It's his death." Angwin paused. "We're not satisfied that we know all the facts about his death."
"Ah! Then I think I'd better tell you exactly how much I've learned from the newspapers, and you can correct me at any point where I go wrong."
"Good," said Angwin, with a note of relief.
I never heard Tolefree put a thing more clearly than this summary of the case which had caused the coroner's jury to return a verdict of suicide and doubtless had vindicated that verdict to the public.
"As I understand it, Mr. Angwin," said he, "Sir William Tolliver had spent last month, the month of June, at Polventor, according to his annual custom. I've looked up the available references to him and his family. I find that the Tollivers are an old Cornish clan who have inhabited this place, Polventor, for more than two centuries——"
"More than three," said Angwin. "The parish records of Carnmenellis go back to the sixteenth century, and Tollivers were already at Polventor then."
"An old house?"
"Patched—bits of Tudor, but mainly seventeenth century: that is, till Tolliver himself, when he got rich, made restorations and additions."
"Ah, yes—I read that the estate is small, and guessed that they were poor until the chemicals money came in."
"All estates are poor round here," Angwin grimaced.
"Well," said Tolefree, with that disarming smile of his, "poverty's a comparative term. You should run a small insurance business in London! Or be a shipbroker, eh, Farrar? However, we get William Tolliver surprisingly taking the modern side in his education, becoming an experimental chemist, joining a small concern, making it into a big one during the war, piling up a fortune, getting a knighthood and celebrity. He has one sister, Louise. She marries a wealthy Carberry, has a daughter, is widowed five years ago, and becomes chatelaine for her brother at Polventor. And that, so far as I discover, is all that's left of the Tolliver family?"
"Yes. In fact, there are no Tollivers now," said Angwin.
"Sir William likes June in the hills and invariably spends the long summer days down here. His recreation is trout-fishing, and he has two miles of water on the Tolgerth river."
"Excuse me for continually butting in," Angwin apologized. "But that might give you a wrong impression if you're a trout-fisherman yourself. The river's a mere moorland torrent; the trout are small and not many. Fishing's mostly a pretext for exercise, and also it was in Tolliver an occasion for lazing about with wild nature. The stream isn't really called Tolgerth river except for the convenience of giving it a name. It runs past Tolgerth. Very beautiful, especially in the little gorge that cuts through the Polventor land and the adjoining land of Rosneven... I only wanted you to have a just idea of Tolliver's fishing."
"Thanks. That gets me where the newspapers can't," Tolefree smiled. "However, Sir William is down for the fishing. He has a number of people at Polventor at the week-end which begins the month of July. Mr. Fearnside and Mr. Michael, members of his firm, are down from London—I dare say more for business than for sport?"
"Undoubtedly."
"A Mr. Polpenna and a Mr. Baripper and a Mr. Menhennick—who were they?"
"Rather colourless persons—except Baripper. Polpenna's an old gentleman from the west who was a friend of Tolliver's father. Menhennick's the tenant of Tolliver's summer house on the coast a few miles down: he wasn't staying at Polventor. Baripper—you probably know of him?"
"Do I? Is it Andrew Baripper, in Capel Court?"
"The same eminent financier. I don't suppose Tolliver wanted him to finance anything. He probably asked him down to help amuse the house."
"I've heard that Mr. Baripper's a bit of a humourist," said Tolefree. "Then there were Mr. Guy Waverton and yourself. What's Mr. Waverton?"
"Old friend of Tolliver and Mrs. Carberry. Been many years in South Africa, gold mining like so many other Cornishmen. He and I were consulted by Mrs. Carberry as to whether she should ask you to look into this."
"Well, those are all the names I can get from the newspaper reports. Pretty mixed bag; but no doubt we shall sort it out. They were all at Polventor on the Sunday evening, the 2nd, I believe."
"Yes," said Angwin. "There was a supper-party, quite late. We'd all been to Carnmenellis church to hear Dimott preach. By the way, the vicar was one of the party you've omitted."
"I didn't find him in the papers."
"Well, he was there that night. Menhennick had his car at Carnmenellis, and Tolliver asked him to come out and bring the parson to have a bite and see the sunset, and take him home. The rest were staying over till Monday."
"I see. Then, as I read it, the occasion was quite ordinary, Sir William in his usual good spirits, and no hint of pending tragedy."
"Least tragic thing in the world. Tolliver was as happy as a sandboy. We sat out the light there on the terrace. Menhennick drove Dimott home about half-past ten, and I left just after. The only thing said about Monday was that Fearnside and Michael were going off to catch the morning train and return to London. Baripper meant to go by the afternoon train. Waverton too—though he wasn't a mere week-end guest like the rest. You see, Waverton's rather in the family—he and Mrs. Carberry are engaged. But he'd had a sudden call to London. He just stayed over till the afternoon to go fishing with Tolliver in the morning. They'd fixed up the night before what reaches they would fish."
"You were there in the morning too—fishing?"
"No. That's too slow for me. I went over to see Mrs. Carberry and her daughter. I often do."
"I see," said Tolefree, with preternatural gravity. His effort to seem oblivious to the obvious made Angwin laugh.
"There's no secret about it," he said. "I have hopes."
"Hope is natural to youth. May it be justified, if that's not impertinent. Anyhow, we have things taped off for the morning this way: Mr. Fearnside and Mr. Michael go to the station after an early breakfast. Of the men in the house the night before there are only Mr. Baripper, Mr. Waverton and old Mr. Polpenna. I suppose he has his breakfast in bed. Anyhow, he doesn't leave the house. Sir William and Mr. Waverton take their fishing-gear and walk to the river. How far?"
"A quarter of a mile. You must see the place. I could describe it; but not to give you the real thing. The stream runs down from the moor south-east to north-west, through a narrow gorge. The approach to it from the house is through a sort of reef, or rim, of rocks—the outcrop of the granite at the top of the gulch. The sort of place we call a cleave and the Americans a canyon. There's a bit of a pass, where you get through to a fairly easy path leading down to the water."
"Yes—and that's where Sir William and Mr. Waverton separated?"
"Exactly. Waverton was to fish upstream, to the south-east, and Tolliver downstream to the north-west."
"I read that Mr. Waverton went to the right after reaching the water and Sir William to the left. That's the position? They started from the house at a quarter past ten. Suppose they took ten minutes to get to the river——"
"More, with their gear and the climb down into the combe."
"Well—a quarter of an hour. That would be half-past ten. The next thing I read is that you and Miss Carberry at eleven o'clock are walking within sight of the rocks."
"Yes—we were going to tramp up to Polventor and back before lunch—the hill I mean: the house is named after it. We'd just started."
"And as you came in sight of the rocks you saw Mr. Waverton coming through and he waved his hand to you."
"He waved his rod and shouted, 'Hello! whither away?' You must understand that he'd been down to the river, found he'd dropped his fly-book, and came back looking for it."
"And it was then you heard the sound of a shot. Immediately?"
"Almost. Waverton had just caught sight of the fly-book on the path, and he was stooping to pick it up when the shot seemed to jerk him upright."
"What did you think?"
"Didn't think much about it. Somebody shooting a rabbit."
"Mr. Waverton, however, didn't think that?"
"No but he was nearer, right over the gorge and heard more distinctly."
"He says he recognized, or suspected, a revolver shot, and turned to look down towards the river. Didn't see Sir William, and climbed along the rocks till he could get a look past a bend."
"Yes. The stream takes a sharp turn not far from the bottom of the path."
"And when he looked down from the new point he saw a body lying in the water and recognized Sir William's clothes. Then he shouted to you, and you ran, and Miss Carberry after you; got to the head of the path just as Mr. Waverton reached it, and you all went down together, and followed the stream until you came to the place where Sir William lay, face downwards in the water which was very shallow——"
"A mere trickle over a sandy place," said Angwin.
"You described at the inquest in great detail what you saw. Sir William's rod was mounted and the reel fixed, but no cast had been attached to the line, and the rod stood upright against a sapling on the bank. On a flat rock close by lay his fly-book, closed, and his pocket flask. He himself had apparently fallen forward from a small rock on the edge of the stream, as you say, into a few inches of water. Close to him, on the sandy bed under water, was a revolver which afterwards proved to be his own. You were all horror-stricken, especially Miss Carberry——"
"Yes. Poor Ann!—she and her uncle were great chums. We thought we were going to have her on our hands too, Mr. Tolefree, but she's well plucked. After the first shock she stood up to it."
"Must have been bad for her," murmured Tolefree. "And then you and Mr. Waverton got him out of the water and laid him on the ground, and saw that he'd been shot through the forehead, and was quite dead. You sent Miss Carberry home to telephone for the police and the doctor. Waverton went with her. You stayed by the body."
"Yes—the longest hour of my life," Angwin shuddered.
"The police came—Inspector Marrack, I think, and Constable Brimmell—with a doctor. Up to that time you had not touched the revolver. Brimmell got it out of the water, found that one shot out of seven had been fired. The doctor had difficulty in saying how long Sir William had been dead, owing to the fact that the body had lain in the water; but it was more than an hour. They took it to the house. At the inquest next day, the evidence, in addition to yours and Mr. Waverton's, was that of the police, the doctor, and Sir William's manservant, one Toms. The police confirmed the state of things you found at the riverside. The doctor stated that Sir William had died by a bullet wound, which might have been and probably was inflicted by the bullet discharged from the revolver, and had died before he fell into the water. Toms identified the revolver as Sir William's own property, having often seen it in the drawer of a table in his dressing-room. Both you and Mr. Waverton declared that you had noticed nothing strange in Sir William's manner. Mr. Waverton, who was probably the last man to speak to him, said he left him at the foot of the path down the gully having talked fishing all the way from the house, that they wished each other good sport, and Sir William went off downstream while he went up. Having found the pool he proposed to fish first, Mr. Waverton discovered that his fly-book was missing. He knew it was bulging his side pocket when he left the house, so he must have dropped it on the road. He retraced his steps, looking for the book, but did not find it till he had reached the rocks at the top of the gully. He must have shaken it out in scrambling through the opening, and he had just seen you and Miss Carberry and waved to you when he found it. No one knew that Sir William had taken his revolver and no one could guess why. The circumstances of the suicide were most mysterious; but the jury had no doubt it was a suicide; the Coroner agreed with them. Verdict accordingly, the Coroner remarking that he could find no evidence of insanity, even temporary, except the act itself—and that was not enough to justify a rider to the verdict. That, I think, Mr. Angwin, is what I know about the matter."
Tolefree pulled out a pipe and pouch.
"I think it covers all the points that have come out," said Angwin. "It's just as if you'd been there."
"Thank the newspapers for accurate reports, then. They're my only source of knowledge."
He lit his pipe and lay back in his chair.
"And what d'you make of it?" Angwin asked him.
"Of that narrative? I never can make anything of a narrative that records only visible facts and legal interpretations. There's no psychological background, and that's everything."
"Good Lord, Mr. Tolefree!" Angwin exclaimed. "You might be Ann talking—if you'd use a spot of slang. 'Tomfool legal logic'—that's Ann on our respected Coroner."
"So? Indeed I shall be delighted to meet Miss Carberry. Seems a kindred soul. But she'll not ask me for conclusions before I begin, will she?"
"No," said he; "Ann's a corker—but you'll see. But for Ann, I suppose, we should all have accepted the facts and their legal bearings. But Ann's got a gorgeous contempt for facts, and she's contaminated her mother and me. Already I begin to despise a fact on sight. I merely wondered how it looked to you—on the face of it."
Tolefree took a pencil from his pocket and pressed down the tobacco in his pipe. He shook his head.
"Impossible to answer, Mr. Angwin. How can I look at the face of it? The very circumstance that you're not satisfied, want inquiry, starts me looking behind the face of it. You see? Now you've set me suspecting that the official inquiry did not perhaps cover all that was relevant, or at least did not get the right stress on what was relevant. Before that, if I'd been asked to pronounce on the published evidence, I should probably have come to the same determination as the jury. You set me guessing that some relevant thing is being hidden, and I'll ask you at once if you know what it is."
"Not the faintest," he declared.
"Well, I won't ask if you think Miss Carberry knows. I'll ask her myself."
"Ann? I'm pretty sure Ann knows nothing. She's got a hunch, that's all. I told you she and Tolliver were great pals—far more than niece and uncle. Ann believes she knew him through and through—won't listen to the possibility of his suicide. And I'm bound to say, the way she puts it, the suicide theory looks very thin—until you come up against the facts."
"And so," said Tolefree, "we work round in a circle—like a dog trying to eat his tail. I see you've a fine set of Henry James. May I?" He got up to look at the bookshelves. "But apparently none of Brother William——"
Which was Tolefree's polite way of shunting a discussion becoming aimless. We looked at the backs of books till the maid opened the door to announce:
"Miss Carberry, sir."
Ann Carberry came in with a "Hello, Arnold—is this Mr. Tolefree? How d'e do? Couldn't rest till I'd seen you. Should never have slept a wink...."
Always afterwards I thought of her as "Little Ann"—her small inches, her slight figure, her brisk movements made her seem a wiry, swarthy child. But Ann Carberry at twenty displayed perfectly adult intellect. Tolefree's reaction to her was exquisite. But not in the same old-fashioned way that charmed Mrs. Angwin. He treated Ann as a wise and knowing contemporary, listened to her attentively, made her feel important. In that long hour's sitting he got from her the full impression of her disbelief in the possibility that Tolliver could have killed himself. To my surprise, he asked no question to bring her back to the known facts, but put many suggestions as to other potential facts. Did she ever notice word or tone to hint at any hidden thing in her uncle's life? Any grief? Any woman? Any personal animosities? Any enemies? Any hostility whatever that ran under the apparently smooth surface of his life?
For the moment, it must be admitted, Ann rather side-stepped the essence of these questions. She did not think Tolliver ever gave a sentimental thought to a woman except his sister and herself. He was a desperately obstinate bachelor in his domestic life, and in business simply the hen-pecked husband of the chemical industry. If he'd ever kissed anything it was probably a test-tube, and his warmest relations were with an electric furnace! As to enemies, Ann could not, of course, say whether he had enemies in business: she had never heard of any. And personal enemies—well, the personal enemies of a man like Tolliver could only be either comic or contemptible.
"Yes," said Tolefree, "who are they?"
"Hasn't Arnold told you? I recited a list to him and Guy the other day—Mr. Ridgway, Paul Penhaligon, Gannett——"
"Help!" cried Tolefree. "I can't memorize half the population of England. Who's Ridgway?"
"He's a mad inventor. Arnold knows more about him than I do."
Tolefree looked to Angwin.
"Ridgway? That's the fellow we met at the head of the combe," said Angwin.
"Whew!" said Tolefree.
THE first of the potential murderers of Tolliver—if Tolliver had been murdered—Thomas Ridgway, a "photographic artist," as the legend over a little shop on the quay at Carnmenellis told the world...
Angwin gave Tolefree a lively character-sketch of Thomas Ridgway, and Tolefree looked curiously at him the while; no wonder, seeing how he'd stalled off Tolefree's inquisitiveness about Ridgway a couple of hours before.
"I've got to warn you," he began, "that I'm not responsible for including Ridgway in the catalogue of Tolliver's enemies. That's Ann."
"All right, Arnold," said Ann. "Don't get peeved. We know you're rather fond of him. All I say is he's a madman and in the habit of quarrelling with Uncle Bill."
Ann didn't then know about Ridgway's hip-pocket. Nor, indeed, had Angwin, ever before this. Ridgway was a harmless crank—so he told Tolefree—and likeable. Perhaps he cherished the old racial feeling about people who weren't quite all there—that they had a certain sanctity. Anyhow, they'd always been friends, ever since he could remember anything of Ridgway's solemn bearded face and his quaint shop on the quay, and the wonders of his photographic studio, which he was always eager to explain and demonstrate to a curious boy. As Ridgway got older and more eccentric, people got shyer of his studio, and in late years his business had become almost moribund. But the fewer his sitters the greater his leisure to work on a marvellous chemical discovery he thought he had made while developing and doctoring the counterfeit presentments of fishermen and bridal couples and stray summer visitors. He often tried to explain it to Angwin, with a great wealth of incomprehensible symbols, but all his young friend could make of it was that it had something to do with alchemy!
Alchemy! Poor Ridgway!...
The villagers of Carnmenellis treated him with perfect courtesy; but he could never get more sophisticated people to attend to him—or if they did, they laughed at his theories and schemes, rudely or politely according to their natures.
And that was the cause of what Ann called his "quarrel" with Tolliver. Angwin knew all about it, because he was there, and he said quarrel was a misnomer for what happened. Tolliver did not quarrel with people—least of all with people of Ridgeway's type. He had too sound a notion of his own dignity and too strong a sense of humour. But there was a little thing which, since Ann raised the spectre of murder that evening in her mother's boudoir, had grown into a big thing in Angwin's mind, as poisonous ideas will.
"Hateful to think it, Ann," said he, "but I do believe that something secret had happened in your uncle's life, something serious, which made him unhappy. It happened recently, since he came to Polventor at the beginning of June, and the burden of it grew on him to the end. I don't think either Waverton or your mother noticed it. They're very much wrapped up in each other. But I saw the cloud that gathered over him a week after he came. It darkened till the very eve of his death. Then it lifted suddenly—that Sunday evening. I concluded that he'd taken some sudden resolution, or shaken himself free of whatever trouble there was: he forced himself to be the liveliest member of the party. You remember, Ann?"
"Yes," said Ann, "but—it might have been business."
"Possibly. But it hadn't the air of business to me. And I must say, Mr. Tolefree, that next day, when I spent that eternity of an hour beside Tolliver's body on the river-bank, I formed a theory: that this lifting of a cloud on the Sunday was the sudden mental emancipation of a strong man who'd determined on a desperate way out."
"Naturally," said Tolefree. "You were looking for a motive for suicide. But where does Ridgway come in? How could the character or doings of an eccentric photographer in a seaside village affect the life of the eminent Sir William Tolliver?"
"I don't know. But—listen to the so-called quarrel."
During the decline of his business, Angwin explained, Ridgway had taken to walking on the high moor most mornings. He often met him there, his long, thin legs striding over the hill, his thin rim of hair poking out like a frill under the black skull-cap, and his camera slung on his back.
"If you could keep him off the topic of chemicals, he would talk intelligently enough, in rapid jerks, about scenery and light and shade and the composition of pictures. He's a literally passionate photographer, Ridgway. He believes in photography as a real art. Always the camera—everywhere, anyhow. He tracks down subjects like a big-game hunter. Been in hot water with Penhaligon more than once for trespassing in Rosneven woods after pictures. So on these walks, if you could get him nailed down to art, his blue eyes would sparkle and go tender by turns, and never a hint of madness in his talk. Those eyes of his always prevent me from thinking really ill of Ridgway. Deep, wistful..."
Angwin had picked him up crossing the moor about three miles from Tresneven one morning about a week before Tolliver's death, as he was going to Polventor. Ridgway strode along beside him, and they talked of casual, indifferent things—the unusual dryness of the moor after a spell of hot weather, the prospects of the wortleberry harvest. And then, nearing the gorge of the Tolgerth stream, they came upon Tolliver and Waverton returning towards the house. Tolliver waved a hand and said:
"Hello, Arnold—coming in to lunch? Good morning, Mr. Ridgway."
A mere acknowledgment of their vicinity. Tolliver obviously did not want to talk alchemy with old Ridgway, to be pestered for scientific advice on the transmutation of metals, and for liberty to search for the philosopher's stone in Tolliver's laboratories in Essex. He rather pointedly hurried away, in close confabulation with Waverton. But the sight of Tolliver was always a Pisgah-sight to Ridgway.
"Excuse me, Mr. Angwin," said he, "there's something I must say to Sir William."
He stalked after them, hung on at Tolliver's side and began to hold forth. Lagging twenty paces in the rear, Angwin did not hear the conversation till they raised their voices. Then he saw Tolliver shake his shoulders impatiently, and heard him say:
"No, Mr. Ridgway—impossible. You must pardon me. I'm in a hurry."
And Ridgway: "A mere minute, Sir William, I beg you. A mere word in your private ear."
And Tolliver: "You really must forgive me today, Mr. Ridgway. Come along, Waverton."
He increased his pace. Ridgway stood off, and shouted after him:
"Very well, Sir William Tolliver! Mark my words—you'll regret it. You'll regret it as long as you live!"
And that was the sum-total of the "quarrel." Ridgway switched off across the moor without a word. Angwin did not see him again till Tolliver was dead.
Ann thought of it as a quarrel, no doubt, because when at lunch Angwin mentioned the encounter, Tolliver was petulant about it and—unusually for him—called Ridgway "a dam' nuisance," and immediately apologized to his sister for the epithet.
This was the substance of the account of Ridgway which Angwin gave Tolefree. He listened silently. Then he showed that the suggestion of some preoccupation in Tolliver's mind, coming upon him unexpectedly and lasting up to the eve of his death, interested him far more than Ridgway's eccentricity. He turned to Ann.
"This cloud, as Mr. Angwin calls it—visible to you, Miss Carberry? You said you noticed nothing to indicate any secret in your uncle's life."
"And I didn't in that sense," Ann declared. "But what Arnold's described was visible, certainly. Couldn't you put a preoccupation like that down to business troubles?"
"Of course, if there were any," said Tolefree. And he made a long pause, looking straight at Ann, who looked straight at him. Then he broke the silence with an "I see."
"Let's tuck the alchemist away for future reference," he said, "and go on with the list of potential enemies, comic or otherwise. Who was the next?—some queer name——"
"Penhaligon," said Ann.
Paul Penhaligon, J.P., D.L., of Rosneven, the next place down the river from Tolliver's. If Penhaligon had been a village photographer instead of a big landowner, an alchemist instead of a magistrate, and impassioned himself about the philosopher's stone instead of the rights of a riparian owner, he would have been accounted as mad as Ridgway. But Penhaligon was not mad. He was, Angwin said, a survival from the era of the Cornish clans, sheer egotist, autocrat living in a world that didn't tolerate autocracy, tribal chieftain without a tolerate autocracy, tribal chieftain without a tribe who brought to a flame an age-old vendetta between the families of Tolliver and Penhaligon which had slumbered for centuries.
"Only Ann can do justice to Paul Penhaligon," said he.
"Carry on, Ann."
"Shall I? Well, then—meet the world's worst imbecile, Mr. Tolefree," said she. "Hasn't a bean, but thinks himself the prince of the earth. Hasn't a single brain to his name, but believes he's a heaven-born genius. Bullies his servants, bullies his wife, bullies the tradesmen and the parson and his brother beaks and the school children, and once he tried to bully me!"
"Probably with lamentable consequences to himself," said Tolefree.
"Well, I told him a few home-truths, I admit," said Ann. "Most unladylike scene. Pass it by. The point about Penhaligon is that he hates the name of Tolliver. Some Tolliver about a million years ago did the world a good turn by cutting off the head of a Penhaligon. The notion of a clan war in the twentieth century always tickled Uncle Bill to death. But Penhaligon got across him on a tender spot—his fishing. The Rosneven land runs on the right bank of the river for a few hundred yards opposite ours—just at the bottom of the gorge, near where Uncle Bill was killed. That old fool Penhaligon hasn't enough sense to throw a fly, so he never fishes; but will he let anyone else fish a yard over his water? Not on your life! Just where his rights begin and ours end, there's the fishiest pool on the river."
"Of course," said Tolefree.
"Naturally, as he never disturbs 'em, the trout get there. He's made many a formal complaint to Uncle Bill about trespassing. When that unladylike scene occurred I was down there having a pop at a big one when he came and stormed at me from the opposite bank. He's got the woods on his side sown with spring-guns and man-traps. He walks about with a gun loaded with buckshot, and swears he'll drop any poacher he finds."
"Medieval person, Penhaligon," said Tolefree.
"Most. And I wouldn't put it past him to shoot Uncle Bill or anyone else if he thought he could get away with it. But not else. That's Mr. Penhaligon."
"A life-like sketch, Miss Carberry," said Tolefree. "Let's tuck the Corsican brother away for reference too. There was another name——"
"Gannett—I mentioned him."
"That rabbit, Ann——" Angwin began.
"Rabbit! He's a weasel," cried Ann. "You can't deny that he was an enemy of Uncle Bill."
Angwin admitted that he couldn't, because Gannett was an enemy of all decent people, and he had a special grouch against Tolliver. A mean little tyke, Lawrie Gannett, a dirty, drunken sneak-thief notorious in Carnmenellis. Tolliver had given him a job out of pity for his wife and the two little dark-headed, brown-eyed girls: "Children always appealed to some soft spot in Tolliver." So Gannett went to Polventor as a man-of-all-work, about the gardens and the woods. He was caught more than once picking and stealing odd things. Tolliver rated him and forgave him. But when he took some money belonging to a servant maid, and Mrs. Carberry wrote to Tolliver in London about it, Tolliver insisted that she should call in the police. Gannett got a month in jail.
"Ever since, he'd been breathing vengeance on Tolliver. Probably out of sheer anti-Tolliverism Penhaligon gave him a job at Rosneven on his discharge from prison: he's been there a month."
That was all about Gannett. And Tolefree having put Gannett away for reference, we all fell silent.
Now that Angwin had told him what he knew of the circumstances of Tolliver's death, and Ann had made her jail delivery of possible suspects, what did it all amount to? Tolefree offering his cigarette-case to Ann; Tolefree refilling his own pipe; Tolefree saying nothing—what could he make it amount to? Measuring it all up, it was a mass of trivialities. A local crank with an alchemical bee in his bonnet; an eccentric, fire-eating neighbour; an indelicate servant—people and circumstances you could probably find in every parish. And to set against it, that apparition of Tolliver lying in the water with a hole in his forehead and his own revolver beside him. Tolliver with a cloud over his head for a month: Tolliver taking his own route away from the oppression. To counter the theory of suicide, only little Ann's affectionate conviction that the Uncle Bill she knew couldn't possibly have done it.
Wouldn't it seem to Tolefree, applying the match to his pipe, that he had been called on a fool's errand? But having got his pipe started, Tolefree said to Ann:
"You don't think your uncle killed himself, Miss Carberry, and you wouldn't believe it even if someone said they'd seen him holding the pistol to his head?"
"Certainly not," said Ann, "unless they also said they saw him fire it, and even then I'd require corroboration."
"And that, so to speak, is that."
"It is. And you—what do you think?"
"A bit early—isn't it?—for me to be thinking, in your sense of the word. I'll say that if Sir William wasn't a suicide it's a twister. But already some ideas occur to me. I perceive they've already occurred to you."
"To me? What ideas?"
Tolefree shook his head.
"I'm sure you wouldn't thank me for dragging them into the light, even before Mr. Angwin. Would you, now?"
Ann looked at Angwin and shrank away from Tolefree.
"No danger, Miss Carberry," he said pleasantly. "Your secret thoughts are perfectly safe in your own head; and if you'll let me say so, they ought to remain there—because they may be wrong."
Eliptical talk. Tolefree might have seemed to be posing to anyone who didn't know his remarkable power of discerning the symptoms of a secret withheld. It disconcerted the girl.
"No danger, Miss Carberry," he was repeating. "I know how it works. Little notions come creeping into our minds like pussyfoot burglars in a bedroom. They grow bigger and begin to make a noise. But, you see——"
Tolefree shrugged.
"You mean, one may wake up and find—just dreams?"
"Exactly, Miss Carberry. So if you had more than a conviction about your uncle—if you had what they call a hunch—let it rest at that. If I can guess at your hunch, I shan't work on it. I must have theories based on fact which can be trotted out before judge and jury—and stronger fact than the river Tolgerth and the revolver, which up to now are the strongest facts I've heard. True, apparently formidable facts like that are often audacious liars. But if the river and the revolver lied, the truth will give 'em the lie sooner or later...."
Tolefree looked across to Angwin.
"You're not so long down from the University, Mr. Angwin. What's that bit of Terence—nil tam difficile—nothing so difficult that it can't be found out by research?"
"By Jove!" said he, "a jolly good motto for Scotland Yard!"
"Wouldn't it be? But let's adopt it at Tresneven and start now. First object of research: Mr. Ridgway's field-glass. What was he expecting to focus into the circle this afternoon?"
"Oh, Ridgway? He's quite irresponsible. Heaven knows."
"I should judge he was focussing up the front of your house."
"Perhaps. Why? Does it mean anything to you?"
"Possibly—and possibly not. I understood that no one except you, Miss Carberry, Mr. Waverton and Mrs. Carberry knew of my visit, and that I was to be here quite incognito. I wondered whether by some accident the news had got out and Mr. Ridgway desired to inspect me if I chanced to be view."
"Impossible!" said Ann and Angwin together.
"What put the idea into your head?" Angwin asked.
"Mr. Ridgway himself. His notably blue eyes. They were simply eating me as the car went by."
The recollection of Ridgway's stare when he stepped aside to let us pass came back to me, but I could put nothing on it. It seemed that no action of Ridgway's could be guaranteed to have a rational cause.
"Never mind," said Tolefree. "We shall discover, I think, Miss Carberry, don't you? It would be easier if no one knew the identity of a fellow called Tolefree; but if anyone does, we shall soon hear from him, I guess."
But how startlingly soon Tolefree could not have guessed.
We fixed up a programme for the morning: Tolefree wished to look over the scene of Tolliver's death and then to make the acquaintance of the local police inspector.
Angwin wanted Ann to get across the hill to Polventor before the light failed. It was ten o'clock when we all went out on the little drive by the front door. Tolefree wished the girl good night and strolled round the corner of the house. I was for following suit, but she kept me a moment.
"Mr. Farrar," said she, "I like your friend. He'll do it! See you in the morning. Arnold, bring them along early to mother."
"All right, Ann; I will.... Good God!"
Ann let out a little squeal.
As he spoke there'd been a sharp explosion and a crash of something falling. Immediately Tolefree came running round the corner.
"What the devil——!" I cried.
He dashed into the doorway.
"Question number one," said he, grinning. "Does anyone in Cornwall know about a fellow named Tolefree? Answer: he does."
"Oh, Mr. Tolefree!" Ann was out of the car. "What—you? Was it——?"
"Rotten bad shot," Tolefree said. "About two yards high: the light, no doubt. Made a mess of one of your cornices, I think, Angwin. But don't go round there now. He might mistake you for me."
TOLEFREE had imperturbable sang-froid. All through the days of growing menace that followed this first of four attempts to "get him" he was cool as a cucumber.
Not foolhardy: he was no such ass as to make light of a pot-shot at him, even though it did come six feet off the target. For instance, he declined to go outside the house that night.
Angwin wondered whether it was safe for Ann to go home with an irresponsible lunatic in the offing armed with a pistol; but Tolefree said it would be perfectly safe.
"Our friend the marksman don't want Miss Ann. He wants me!" He urged Angwin to go along with her, but on no account to breathe a hint to anyone of what had happened. "It's a gift from the gods," he said, "the second to-day. I believe in nursing my luck."
In the upshot Angwin went back to Polventor with Miss Carberry and borrowed her car to come home. Tolefree and I waited for him in his study.
"Someone's spilt the news, Farrar," he said.
"Amazing!" I replied.
"Yes. But—is it? Servants? There may have been eavesdropping. Pierce no, he wouldn't have wired, and there's no delivery of letters on Sunday. This means precautions, or some other fellow will have to solve the Tolliver mystery."
"I should jolly well think so! But it shows at any rate——"
"Yes?"
What I thought it showed beyond doubt was that we needn't worry about the suicide theory. Tolefree, however, would not come as far as that. He said it showed that someone was rather anxious not to have the Tolliver case reopened.
"I want to make a few notes. We can go over them afterwards. Amuse yourself for half an hour, Farrar."
I amused myself by relaxing in a long chair. Two hundred and fifty miles of driving, and then this—I felt heavy-eyed. Between half-closed lids, I saw him with head bent over his writing. I had a dim idea that he came and took a look at me, and went away towards the book-case...
When I woke up, Tolefree sat sound asleep opposite me with "The Sense of the Past" on his knee and his right hand hanging down almost to the floor, grasping a cold pipe.
It was thus Angwin found us.
Next morning, two startling things happened.
First, old Mrs. Angwin, over the breakfast table, said quietly:
"Oh, Arnold—I forgot to tell you that Mr. Baripper called yesterday while you were out."
"Baripper, mother?" Angwin exclaimed.
"Andrew Baripper?" said Tolefree, with a piece of toast poised half-way to his mouth.
"Yes. He asked where you were. I said you'd gone to meet some friends coming from London."
Tolefree dropped the toast on his plate.
"Did Baripper leave any message? Say why he wanted me?"
"No message. He wanted to know whether you'd seen anything of Guy Waverton."
"Extraordinary thing to ask," said Angwin. "Why didn't he look for Waverton at Polventor?"
"Well, I wondered myself. But I didn't like to ask: Mr. Baripper is such a—such an overwhelming person."
Tolefree smiled.
"Capital, Mrs. Angwin! I must remember that against the great Andrew. You'd no idea he was down here, Mr. Angwin?"
"No. He left on Thursday after the funeral to go to London. And Waverton—I believe he's home at Penzance."
Tolefree had plainly been taken off his guard by the sudden apparition of one of the Polventor party who was supposed to be two hundred miles away; the topic died for the moment. Only to be revived half an hour later. I was in the study writing a letter to my manager; Angwin and Tolefree had strolled out on to the little lawn and then into the woods. The telephone bell rang. Looking through the window I could not see Angwin. I took up the receiver.
"Hold on for a trunk-call from London," said the Exchange.
It came through directly—a call for Tolefree: his youth Allen ringing through from Watling Street. He recognized my voice. Allen wanted to tell Tolefree of a message he had received from Mrs. Stoker, the daily help at Tolefree's rooms. While about her usual chores on Sunday morning after we left, she took a telephone call: it was from a Mr. Baripper, who seemed greatly put out when he learned that Tolefree had left London and was likely to be away some days.
"What made you ring up now, Allen?" I asked, knowing that Tolefree had certainly had no communication with the boy since Saturday night.
"Well, sir, Mr. Tolefree left his address for anything important to be sent on."
"Why did you think this important, Allen?"
"Anything may be important, Mr. Farrar," said he in his high young voice—reproving my inexperience. And he added, as a clincher, "newspapers, you know, sir."
Even Tolefree's office-boy was puting two and two together and making it Baripper. When Tolefree came back, and I gave him Allen's message, he said, "Yes—obviously. But keep it to yourself, Farrar. This gets more delicate, doesn't it? High game to fly at."
Thus Andrew Baripper plunged over our horizon into the Tolliver case almost before the inquiry had begun.
Tolefree and Angwin had already scouted round the narrow grounds of Tresneven for possible traces of the marksman of the night before. We went out again. As Angwin had said, in these parts any combe which may shelter a house will also shelter trees, and Tresneven lies in a little dell of woods. Its gardens are necessarily small, and on the side of the house where Tolefree had strolled while I wished Ann good night, the trees, mostly ash, small oak and beeches, come thickly up to a wire fence. A little shrubbery there edges the lawn where in her young days, Mrs. Angwin told us, she had played croquet—a bit of turf not more than forty feet across, with the great beech at one end of it.
The perquisition yielded nothing: an unusually dry July made all spoors invisible. What Tolefree did divine was that the shot must have been fired from the neighbourhood of the wire fence through one of the many openings among the shrubs. Farther back in the wood no shot could have been sighted. But we got evidence of his coolness when he showed us what he called his "sign and mark"—a scuffled place in the middle of the lawn.
"I will now," said he, "replace the divots."
"Were you," I exclaimed, "walking here?"
"Walking? Yes, fortunately. The worst pistol shot in the world could hardly miss a standing target at twelve yards. He pulled a bit late, and it went up behind my head."
That was Tolefree. The shot had hit the cornice of a tall window and dislodged a cluster of plaster, which lay on the ground below. Poking about in it, he found the bullet, splayed at the point, where it had struck the wall.
"Exhibit number one." He smiled.
"No joke, that," said Angwin. "Dodging bullets was hardly in your contract, was it?"
"As the self-expression of a humourist," he answered, weighing the missile on his palm, "a dozen grams of lead with a nickel point coming from a barrel at a hundred feet per second—well, it does somehow seem to lack geniality."
"A humourist!"
"Yes. How can you attribute it to a serious-minded person with a sense of responsibility?"
Angwin did not quite know how to take Tolefree in this mood. Even at that early point the idea that he had been light-heartedly dragged into a danger for which he certainly could not have bargained disturbed him. I raised the question again whether Tolefree might in the dusk have been mistaken for some other person. He himself had no doubt.
"No—I was the billet all right," said he. "But don't worry. It's a useful warning, and a valuable tip as well. Shows the type of man we're to look for."
"How's that?"
"Well—see: we're at our wits' ends to discover whether Sir William Tolliver did or didn't commit suicide. We send to London for a man who may help us to the discovery. He's no sooner on the spot than a lump of lead whistles past his head and whispers in passing, 'What a fool question! Obviously Sir William Tolliver did not commit suicide.' The puzzle that interests me this lovely morning is how the humourist got to know that anyone doubted the suicide theory. Nous verrons, dit l'aveugle!... Now, I'm all agog to make the acquaintance of Mrs. Carberry and Polventor."
Angwin took us over in Miss Carberry's car. About three or four miles—into the bottom of the Tresneven valley, over its little stream by a hump backed bridge, up through the woods on the other side, across a great moor, down to a bridge across the Tolgerth river above the gorge, and so to Polventor west of it.
There was no lodge at the gate by which we entered the grounds. Tolefree had opened the door to get out of the car and let us through when a man appeared, saluted, and swung the gate back.
"Good morning, Toms," said Angwin.
"Good morning, Mr. Arnold. If I might ride up on your footboard, sir? Mr. Waverton's just arrived, and I want to see about his things."
"Jump on," said Angwin.
"Thus Toms, the clean-shaven, keen-faced, dark-eyed servant, who proved to be butler, footman, chauffeur and valet at Polventor, rode cheek by jowl with Tolefree until we reached the house, and pleasantly answered his questions about the heights of hills and the effect of wind upon the trees (most of the taller ones had a permanent list and their tops cut flat by the gales), and the other indifferent topics that occurred to Tolefree when he wished to weigh people up. I was conscious that Toms, perhaps an essential witness in the Tolliver case, was undergoing this process. But it did not last long: we were soon at the house, where a car stood, and Toms jumped off to busy himself about the unstrapping of baggage.
We were shown into a morning-room, welcomed by Miss Carberry, introduced to her mother and Mr. Waverton.
Mrs. Carberry, a touch fairer than her daughter, was far more beautiful. A warmly coloured, graceful, slim woman, probably not far into the forties, self-possessed, quiet of manner, twenty years less modern, daring, downright than Ann. Waverton did not realize the ideal of the bearded pard. He was a tall man of handsome features, his dark complexion deepened by African suns, trimly bearded, with alert black eyes which fastened on Tolefree with manifest curiosity: I recalled Angwin's allusion to his scepticism about private detectives.
But Tolefree had soon established himself in a social equality with all of them. He was, indeed, admirable in this first round-table discussion of the mystery of Tolliver's death. Having found that no other guests than Waverton were in the house, he seemed to make up his mind at once to a complete confidence.
"I understand, Mrs. Carberry, from your daughter and Mr. Angwin," he said, "that it was after a four-handed consultation that you wrote to me? Yes—and the four conspirators, so to speak, are now present. We are all the people who knew I was to be the guest of Mr. Angwin?"
"Absolutely," said Mrs. Carberry. "We thought that as the police had—well, you see——"
"Quite so, and an excellent plan. But—has anything happened to change it?"
She looked puzzled.
"Nothing. Why?"
"No one has mentioned me or my business?"
"Certainly not I—nor Ann. And Guy—you've been home ever since——"
"Yes," said Waverton. "You don't mean to say there's been a leak, Mr. Tolefree?"
"I should imagine it impossible. But there's a thing I can't understand. At least one person is aware of me already."
"Gosh! Already? How—?"
Waverton stared his surprise at Tolefree, and looked in turn at the two women.
"Guy!" said Ann. "Don't for heaven's sake say no woman can ever keep a secret. You look exactly as if you're going to."
"I can trust your mother, Ann," he replied. "And unless you talk in your sleep——"
"Clearly"—Tolefree smiled—"there's been no leak. But it's also clear that the secret's not a secret. Something's happened—very suggestive. Mr. Angwin and Miss Carberry already know it. I asked them not to mention it. But as we're close-tiled here, I think you'd better be told. You wanted me to discover whether the police theory of suicide was true or false. Well, it's false. Or perhaps I'd rather say the odds are ten to one it's false."
Mrs. Carberry uttered a little cry. Waverton said:
"That's quick work. How d'you get at it?"
"You shall judge. It seems convincing to me," said Tolefree. And he told the story of our meeting with Ridgway in the valley and the shot across the lawn at Tresneven. Waverton and Mrs. Carberry were even more concerned than I had felt.
"Louise," said Waverton, when Tolefree's tale was done, "this is too serious. We've no right to bring Mr. Tolefree into danger. Suppose there's another attempt and his luck is out next time? This is a police job. I'm going to ring up Marrack."
Mrs. Carberry eagerly agreed. I thought it was sense, and said so. Ann—I looked to her. She had her eyes on Tolefree.
"What do you say?" she asked him.
"I'm entirely in Mrs. Carberry's hands. If she wishes to withdraw the commission——"
A chorus of protests. "Oh, no, certainly not, Mr. Tolefree. Nothing of that kind. Only, your own safety. It's most extraordinary!..."
"I could look after my own safety," said Tolefree. "Don't let that weigh with you."
"Not good enough," Waverton declared. "Too great a responsibility for us. Where should we be if anything went wrong. Louise—you agree with me?"
"I think I do," said Mrs. Carberry.
Then Ann took the floor.
"Look here, mother—and everybody," she began, "I want to ask Mr. Tolefree a question. Do you think Uncle Bill killed himself, Mr. Tolefree?"
"You mean—do I believe he killed himself, don't you?" Tolefree shook his head. "I know too little. I can't say. But I do believe we could discover some remarkable things if we tried hard."
"There!" cried Ann. "That's the answer. Marrack's no good for this, Guy. He's had one go already."
"But," Waverton protested, "Marrack doesn't know what happened last night at Tresneven, and that would make a difference. Louise—this is a warning. We're making ourselves responsible for Mr. Tolefree's life. Can't you see it, Ann?"
"Yes, I can," said Ann doggedly. "But Mr. Tolefree says he can take care of himself, and I think he will. I know that if I were Mr. Tolefree, I'd simply hate to get out just because some lunatic fired at me."
Ann's face flushed and her eyes sparkled. Somehow she had introduced a new factor into the dispute. We all had in our minds a vision of Tolefree running away from a poor stick in a skull-cap; and we found it incongruous. Tolefree himself broke the short silence that followed her outburst.
"Perhaps I might tell you what I had proposed to do to-day, Mrs. Carberry—that is, of course, unless you withdrew the commission——"
"Oh, I assure you——" she murmured.
"I was going to have a look this morning at the place where Sir William's body was found. This afternoon I intended to go and talk with the police inspector, and perhaps pay a visit to Mr. Ridgway."
"You mean to see Marrack?" cried Waverton.
"Certainly. I never do anything without an understanding with the police."
"Oh, well, then I withdraw everything. So long as they know——"
"All the same," said Tolefree, "I should have to be allowed to tell them my own way. For instance, if I decided to say nothing about last night, I should wish that no one else told them. To be quite candid, I imagine the Inspector's already made up his mind once and for all about the death of Sir William Tolliver. It's chose jugée. But I can also imagine circumstances where he'd be most useful."
"There you are, Guy," Ann said. "Doesn't that meet your point?"
"All right," he replied. "I'm satisfied if the police are in it. Go ahead. But——"
Waverton paused, looking towards Mrs. Carberry.
"Louise—you mustn't mind my saying it. Better to know exactly how we stand, eh?"
"How, Guy?"
"Mr. Tolefree ought to know I didn't think there was much chance of getting over the evidence they had at the inquest, though of course I quite agreed that Ann's idea should be considered. And I'm still of the same mind. I know what you're going to say, Ann"—as she opened her lips—"about the queer business last night. But I don't put much on it. We all know Ridgway. The only thing is, Mr. Tolefree, that he may try it again. You never know what obscure notions may make such a fellow do amazing things."
"You don't," said Tolefree. "But as soon as I've seen the Inspector, I hope to make the acquaintance of Mr. Ridgway and find means of persuading him to practise on inanimate subjects in future."
Tolefree's grin rather cleared the air. Waverton said:
"Well, you're a sportsman who likes going over the top, anyhow! But I'll tell you I'm mighty glad you're getting the force of authority at your back—even if it's only old Marrack. I've seen a lot of rough-house work where there wasn't any authority so you'd notice. And I appreciate the value of a good old English policeman."
"He's a real solid comfort," said Tolefree. "I'm going to like Mr. Marrack, I feel sure. I'm going to enjoy the acquaintance of Mr. Ridgway. I'm really curious about Mr. Penhaligon. I want to study Mr. Gannett. And heaven knows what other friendships I may start——"
The powwow in Mrs. Carberry's morning-room, so much more critical than any of us guessed, came to an end. Nothing more was said of "withdrawing the commission," as Tolefree had put it. Before we set out to visit the river, he asked that Toms might be sent for.
"Toms," he said, "Mrs. Carberry has given me permission to see the late Sir William Tolliver's room. Will you take me up?"
Mrs. Carberry looked surprised, but nodded to Toms, who said:
"This way, sir."
They left us and were away perhaps five minutes.
"What a nice man!"
Mrs. Carberry's apostrophe of Tolefree was not, it appeared, an ironical commentary on his truthfulness. She had been agreeably impressed; and when he smilingly explained, on his reappearance, that he had wished to have a look at Tolliver's revolver and to confirm Toms' knowledge of Sir William's habits, she assured him that everything and everybody in the house were at his disposal.
"Including Toms?" asked Tolefree. "I hope so, for I've already asked him if he can go to Bodmin this afternoon for me."
"Bodmin? Certainly."
Mrs. Carberry did not ask why Bodmin (a town a dozen miles away), but Tolefree revealed the reason of the errand. The cartridges in Tolliver's revolver were supplied by a Bodmin gunsmith: he wanted to know when he bought them.
"Ah, yes—of course," said Waverton. "If recently——"
"Well," said Tolefree, "it might have a bearing, mightn't it?"
The cultivated grounds of Polventor did not extend far from the house in any direction. To the east, a footpath left the drive before it reached the lodge on the Carnmenellis side, and ascended to the top of the combe in a few hundred yards. A small gate in a dry stone wall gave access to the open moor, and straight in front of us on the other side of the Carnmenellis road stretched the rim of fantastically shaped granite rocks marking the edge of the cleave through which the stream ran. A little to the left of their centre was the V-shaped opening at the head of the path leading down to the water. Tolefree stopped near the gate to take in this lie of the land.
"Did you two come this way?" he asked.
Angwin said they did. It was their exact route for that walk to Polventor which failed to come off. Almost immediately after they had passed the gate, they saw Waverton appear in the opening, looking from side to side, and hailed him with a "Coo-ee!" He waved his rod to them and shouted back, stooped down again, looking for his fly-book, and straightened up at the sound of the shot.
"The time?" said Tolefree. "Could you fix the time exactly?"
But he couldn't more exactly than he had done. It was about eleven o'clock. He had driven over and collected Ann just before eleven and they started at once.
"Could you say at any rate that it wasn't before eleven when you heard the shot?" asked Tolefree.
Yes, he thought it was probably rather after than before eleven.
"And you didn't either of you put anything on the shot till Mr. Waverton scrambled among the rocks to look down at the river—there, to the left?" Tolefree pointed.
Angwin nodded. He had seen Waverton's tall figure standing on a peak and bending to peer down into the gorge, and heard him shout out Tolliver's name in a cry of alarm.
They led us across the springy moorland turf to the little pass. The rim of rocks cropping out along the line of the valley was quite narrow. Within twenty feet from the entrance the ground fell away steeply to the water, and the path zigzagged down to it sixty or seventy feet below. On the other bank thickly grown woods—willow and ash, mostly—occupied a few level yards, and the land rose steeply beyond them. The valley lay green-shaded, and silent but for tinkling of the water rushing among its boulders round the bend to the left.
Tolefree stood contemplating the scene for several minutes. His look slowly travelled along the zigzag and to the limits of the stream's visibility in each direction. He walked back to the entrance of the pass and returned. He climbed out of it and along the clutter of rocks to stand on the peak from which Waverton had looked down to discover Tolliver's body in the water. Then when all four of us began the descent to the river, he timed our departure by his watch. At the bottom, he said:
"Mr. Angwin—walk to the right as far as the pool Mr. Waverton proposed to fish, and return here, will you?"
He had watch in hand. It took Angwin exactly three minutes. Then we all went downstream, along the ledges under the wall of rock and around the corner to the pool where Polventor and Rosneven met. That took five minutes. Tolefree recorded the times in a note-book. Then he stood examining the surroundings.
We were in a deep slit in the land—a miniature canyon. On the Polventor side the rock wall rose almost sheer above a little coppice of ash in a niche of broken ground fringing the stream. Above and below it, only a casual sapling here and there. On the other side, which Angwin said was Rosneven property, a dense growth of trees, now in their deepest foliage, and the rugged hill rising beyond. Between, the shoal water where Tolliver had lain, running down into a black, fishy pool, surface as smooth as glass, broken only by the rings where trout were marking. At this point, not more than fifty yards of the river were in view either way.
Tolefree stood on the rock from which Angwin said Tolliver had fallen into the stream, and gazed his fill. He wandered back among the trees of the tiny coppice, stumbling over the rocks. He gazed from there. He returned to us.
"It's a queer world where tragic death chooses loveliness like this to soil," said he.
But that was the only generalization he allowed himself. Immediately he caused Angwin and the girl to describe in detail their own movements and sensations, to point out the exact position in which Tolliver had lain on the sandy shoal, the sapling against which his rod had rested, the flat boulder where his gear was laid out. And, this done, he invited us to sit on a moss-grown stone and offered his pouch to Angwin and me.
"Miss Carberry," he said, "I want you to think back for me. Every fact the police could find points to suicide. It'll be hard to get over those facts. Now, when you got here with Mr. Angwin and saw—what you did see, was it suicide or murder that first occurred to you?"
"Suicide," said Ann.
"Because——?"
"Well, because it looked like that—just as it looked to everyone else."
"And you too, Mr. Angwin?"
"Undoubtedly."
"And Mr. Waverton also? But there's no need to ask. He still thinks so. Consequently, no one who was here within five minutes of the death of Sir William Tolliver thought of looking around to see whether there might possibly be another explanation. That makes the time factor so important. If Sir William did not kill himself, but was shot by another person—look around. Is it likely that the person in question was this side of the river?"
It seemed not only unlikely, but almost impossible. A few yards below the place where we sat, the rough ledge ended and the rock wall descended sheer into the pool. Any person who had shot Tolliver must have gone back along the way Ann and Angwin rushed down.
"It took us five minutes to get here from the bottom of the zigzag," said Tolefree. "Someone in a great hurry might have reached the zigzag from here in three. But I suppose when you started running after the shot you got to the top of the path up there in less than three minutes?"
"Much less," said Angwin, "and, of course, Waverton was down before us."
"If somebody was lying up for Tolliver before he got here, I think we can rule him out from this side—unless he got across the river after?"
"Anywhere about here he would have had to swim at least a part of the way. A possibility, of course."
"We'll allow for the possibility," said Tolefree; "but it's a manifest improbability. Wouldn't anyone who knew Sir William Tolliver would fish here that morning, and wanted to shoot him, be on the other side of the river to begin with? Excellent cover: a sure way of escape——"
"Except for Penhaligon's man-traps and spring-guns," said Angwin.
"Which would not trouble him if he happened to know where they were," said Tolefree.
"Ah!" I exclaimed, "then you think——"
"Of Mr. Penhaligon himself? Of the Gannett man? Even of our friend Ridgway—I suppose he's familiar with the country?"
"No one more so," said Angwin.
"Yes—I think of them all," said Tolefree, very softly. "But we're jumping short. Let's leave out the question of identity and suppose X shot Sir William. Where was X when he did it? Obviously he might have been on the other side of the river where—but please don't look or express any surprise, either of you—where there's a man at the present moment profoundly interested in our presence and trying to get close enough to hear what we say. Show no alarm. I don't think there'll be any shooting this morning."
My reaction to this startling announcement was to stare hard at Angwin, who in turn stared hard at me. Tolefree went on, still speaking in a murmur.
"If Sir William did not shoot himself and had no intention of shooting himself, why did he come out fishing with a revolver on him? He wasn't in the habit of going armed."
"No," said Ann. "I asked Toms. He said the thing was always in Uncle Bill's drawer, and seemed never to be touched from one month's end to another."
"So Toms tells me. Then, always disregarding suicide, we get the practical certainty that on this particular morning, Sir William came fishing with the idea that he might have to do a little shooting as well. In other words, he knew that an attack might be made on him. Now, if while he made ready to fish for trout, he saw someone on the other side of the river, where Paul Pry has now wormed his way very close to the bank, he may actually have done a little shooting——"
I could not repress a jerk of the nerves as Tolefree's idea burst on me.
"Not impossible, is it? If two shots came very close together, I guess the noise would raise so many echoes in a place like this that anyone at a distance would be positively unable to say whether they were two or one."
Tolefree had it! I glanced at Ann. She stared open-mouthed at him.
"You've been certain there were two shots, Miss Carberry, I think?"
"Yes," said Ann.
"Since when?"
"Oh, ever since I thought it over and saw how absurd it was to believe Uncle Bill committed suicide."
"Two shots, then," said Tolefree. "Let's glue our minds on two shots, and never forget them."
It cleared up wonderfully then, except for one little point of doubt. If Tolliver had been shot from across the river almost in the act of pulling his own trigger, that would account for his falling into the shoal water and his gun beside him with one shell discharged.
The little devil doubt came in with the doctor's evidence that the bullet which killed Tolliver was probably fired from his own revolver. I insinuated him into the discussion.
"It's a snag," said Tolefree. "But not impassable. The .2 bullet's common enough. Here's one, for instance."
He pulled from his pocket the flattened projectile he had fished out of the heap of plaster at Tresneven, and dandled it in his hand.
"Then," said Ann, "if we can find the second bullet—there we are!"
"I'm afraid not," said Tolefree. "Here's the second bullet, and it's not a 2. Much larger."
He opened his hand and showed a large slug.
"Good heavens!" Angwin exclaimed.
"Sh—sh! Keep your voice down, will you? In the bole of one of those ash trees behind us. I won't show you just now. But unless Tolliver killed himself, we now want not two shots but three, because a bullet that went into an ash tree obviously wasn't the bullet that killed him."
Tolefree fell silent, poked about with his toe among the shingle at our feet, picked up a flat stone and did ducks and drakes with it across the water. Idly took others and sent them farther, till one skated right across to the opposite shore. Finally had a misfire with a large one which seemed to slip from his fingers and do a parabola into the thicket. At once there was an oath and a scutter among the branches; then silence.
"Shall we be moving back?" said Tolefree, with his broadest grin.
THREE shots!...
The growth of the single shot that Angwin and Ann had heard into two and then into three, like some primal marine creature budding off, was astonishing. It puzzled Angwin beyond measure: he felt sure he had heard only one shot. But Tolefree said the reverberations of three shots, if they were fired close together in a place like this, might very well be indistinguishable from those of one.
Ann Carberry stood silent and pensive, looking across into the woods of Rosneven.
I was never much of a believer in clairvoyance and all that stuff, but I could not very well miss the fact that already some kind of occult understanding existed between Ann and Tolefree. They had not so far exchanged a word alone. Angwin and I had been present all the time. Not a sentence passed which could not be accounted for on the surface. Yet Ann seemed to divine some sub-intention in all Tolefree said, and to flash some hidden meaning to him with every word.
Had Ann any knowledge concealed from the rest of us—some certainty which explained her persistence on the day of the funeral and her passionate anxiety that the inquiry should not be pushed out of Tolefree's hands into Marrack's? And if so, how had she communicated it to Tolefree?
On leaving the river to return to Polventor, we had met Waverton and Mrs. Carberry coming across the moor to look for us. Her arm was in his when we saw them. They parted at once. I saw Tolefree's smile at this display of middle-aged self-consciousness, but Angwin and the girl were apparently quite accustomed to it.
The two turned to walk back with us. Tolefree, between them, told of his speculations on the possibility of two shots, and left them aghast at his half-facetious account of the apparition in the wood and the way he laid it.
Cried Waverton, "It's all very well to make light of a thing like that—but if the fellow had meant mischief? I won't have an easy moment till you've got the police at your back. Of course you couldn't get a look at him?"
But though Tolefree had watched carefully, he said, only the stealthy movement of the man amid the undergrowth betrayed him: he never showed a feather.
In half an hour after lunch, Tolefree had the police at his back, or as fully as he wanted them. Angwin borrowed Ann's car again and drove us on our first visit to Carnmenellis. The road curled first away from the valley of the Tolgerth and then sharply towards it, rising by a stiff ascent to the cliffs that fringed it where the stream broadened into a tidal estuary, and then dropping down into the cove.
We left Tolefree in front of a house which bore the legend "Cornwall County Constabulary." He declined Angwin's offer to introduce him to Inspector Marrack.
"Leave me to tell him as much and as little of myself as I want to, Mr. Angwin. We shall soon click. Marrack has probably heard of me by this time. If you'll give me an hour——?"
So Angwin drove on, left the car in the yard of the Carnmenellis Arms, and we climbed together up to the churchyard. They had put some turves on Tolliver's grave. The ugly, messy heap of rubble Angwin described was now a green mound. He looked down on it and probably thought of Tolliver below: then it wouldn't bear thinking about, so we went away and sat on the churchyard wall looking out over the Atlantic, sleepy, indifferent giant stretching away to the west, with only its vast body between us and the American continent.
"Old Tolliver would often speak of that when he looked down through the combe from the terrace at Polventor," said Angwin. "It gave him a triangular chunk of blue sea at the end of the vista. Tolliver had a reputation and many friends among the engineers and chemists in America."
We sat there a while, then descended, and were waiting for Tolefree when he came out from Marrack's house. The Inspector stood in the porch for a moment talking earnestly to him; saw Angwin and saluted; shook hands with Tolefree.
"Good hunting?" Angwin asked.
"Fine. I'll tell you by and by. Nice chap, Marrack—but, as I thought, you can't budge him. Poor Sir William committed suicide, and though it's quite natural for his relatives to prefer to have had him murdered, facts are facts... That sort of thing."
"Did you tell him about last night—and this morning?"
"Not a word."
"Why not, Mr. Tolefree?"
"Won't you drop the Mister?—do. Why? Because I'd just as soon wipe out a valuable fingerprint with an oil-rag. Same thing."
We were walking down the narrow village street towards the boat harbour. People passing or standing in their doorways greeted Angwin and looked curiously at us: it was rather early for summer visitors at Carnmenellis. We came out on the quay. Half a dozen steps and the inn filled up the space between the steep hillside and the channel where the Tolgerth river tore down to meet the tide. Over one of the shops a painted sign announced the establishment of "Ridgway: Photographic Artist."
Tolefree's first meeting with this eccentric curiosity turned out to be what he called one of the "high spots" of his experience in the Tolliver case, but Angwin brought it about with some discomfort to himself.
"If Ridgway was the man behind the wire fence last night, Tolefree——" he objected.
"Even if he was and your character sketch of him is sound," Tolefree replied, "we shall have an interesting afternoon. Anyhow, it's the first necessity for me. I'll see him alone, if you like. Or Farrar can come."
Of course Angwin did not like.
Ridgway had the usual seaside village photographer's shop—awake for a couple of months in the year, asleep for the rest. His window was backed by a dusty velvet curtain, once black but now green, against which a number of photographs slowly faded in the sun. His door had a bell on a flat spring, which jangled when we entered. On a small counter was a rickety revolving stand of picture postcards. On the walls hung bromide portrait enlargements—yellowing paper and greying tints. Only one picture seemed fresh and noticeable—a carbon print of a girl's head, which stood on a flimsy easel in the corner behind the counter. On this, whether copy or original it was impossible to say, Ridgway had evidently lavished what he knew of his art. We were looking at it when we heard him first stumping about overhead and then down the stairs in answer to the jangling bell. Just as he had appeared in the road when I nearly killed him—under the black skull-cap the wisps of hair stuck out, the ridiculous little pull-over covered his thin chest below the straggly beard, and his long legs were encased in his ridiculously narrow trousers: Ridgway as we had seen him with the spy-glass at his eye in the woods of Tresneven.
"Good afternoon, Mr. Angwin," said he, stretching out a scraggy hand, the fingers stained yellow and brown by his chemicals. "Sorry to keep you waiting.... Dark room... you understand."
He jerked it out, his look focussed first on Tolefree and then on me.
"That's all right, Mr. Ridgway," Angwin told him. "My friends, Mr. Tolefree and Mr. Farrar, of London——"
"How d'e do, Mr. Tolefree? And Mr. Farrar?"
Tolefree and I shook the yellow, bony fingers in turn.
"Strangers to this country," said Angwin, "and charmed with it. Would like some views."
"Postcards.... twopence." Ridgway waved a long arm towards the rickety stand.
"Oh," said Tolefree, smiling, "hardly that sort of view. I thought you might perhaps have some negatives of the choicer bits round about. I'd love to have a real good print or two."
"Ah.... print or two.... Yes... What of?
"If you could show me——"
"Come up.... studio... Have a look... I'll lock up... Shan't be disturbed."
He took two strides to the shop-door and shot a bolt. Glancing at Tolefree and feeling a little disturbed, I saw in his eyes nothing but a keen amusement. Ridgway was already at a door in the back wall which gave on a flight of stairs.
"Up here," said he, and took the stairs two at a time.
"Follow my lead," Tolefree whispered, and went after him.
All photographers' studios I've ever seen are much of a muchness. Dreary places with comic bits of scenery and untidy, dusty screens of calico stretched about and gaunt camera stands with clumsy-looking cranks and wormscrews. Ridgway's resembled the in rest. All the front of the room was a glass window, and a skylight washed blue added to the bleak glare.
When we had landed in it, Ridgway stepped behind us and locked the door.
"Scenery!" He made a cackle of that, looking at us with a queer, distorted grin. "Want scenery, eh?"
He stood with his back to the door.
"Mr. Ridgway," said Tolefree quietly, "I am a long-suffering man, but I do not suffer myself to be locked in against my own wish. Unlock, if you please, and throw the key here. Farrar, go over there by the dark-room door. Angwin, stand clear. Now, Mr. Ridgway, at once, if you please. I mean it."
I had not observed his motion, but as I turned to go down the length of the room I saw a revolver in Tolefree's hand and Ridgway unlocking the door. I heard the key flung on the floor.
"Now, Mr. Ridgway," Tolefree went on, "you have a gun in your hip-pocket. Turn round, please, and put your hands against the wall. Thank you."
Ridgway, hypnotized, had obeyed mechanically. Tolefree relieved him of the pistol he carried, and dropped it in his coat-pocket.
"That'll be all, thank you. Now sit down. There—in the patient's chair. Turn your head a little this way. Hold it so. Have you a permit to carry fire-arms? I thought not. This one will be confiscated. Outrageous thing to do to a man on his own premises? You see—I read your thoughts. It is, Mr. Ridgway. But—believe me, it's better so."
Tolefree put away his own weapon.
"You know all about us, don't you? We've met before. You saw us arrive at Mr. Angwin's yesterday. Now—will you answer a few questions in a friendly way?
Ridgway had not spoken a word since that cackling allusion to "scenery." Tolefree seemed to have fixed him like a basilisk.
"Why have you been walking about with that gun in your pocket? You had it yesterday at Tresneven... Well, never mind. Perhaps I can guess. But you've got to tell me where you were and what you were doing at a quarter to ten last night."
"Got to tell?... No compulsion, is there?... Wouldn't interest you."
Mild as milk, Ridgway! I could hardly believe my ears.
"It would interest me more than anything in life," said Tolefree. "You wouldn't credit what an interest I take in it."
Ridgway leaned forward in his chair.
"That true?... You do?... I'll tell you... I was in there." He pointed past me. "Experiments.... great experiments... nearly got it... just escapes me... Not enough appliances... If Tolliver——"
At the mention of Tolliver's name he suddenly pulled up: it was as though he had a rictus.
"Quite so," said Tolefree. "If Sir William had lived—a great chemist, Sir William—and you could have interested him, who knows? So that's where you were last night? That's very good for you, Mr. Ridgway, because if you'd been at Tresneven at a quarter to ten——"
Tolefree shrugged his shoulders.
"I'll be glad to meet you again, Mr. Ridgway, some other time—see your experiments, have a grand talk about the experimenters from Raymond Lully to William Ramsay, if you like—fascinating subject—but not now. You know why I'm here?"
Ridgway had leaned back in his chair. He nodded dully.
Nothing that afternoon was stranger than the sudden blazing up and dying down of his excitement over his experiments. It was the only symptom of madness he showed, unless the eccentricity of the door-locking could be accounted madness. Now he listened calmly to Tolefree's explosive questions, and made spasmodic answers.
"You know why I'm here. So—can you tell me who killed Sir William Tolliver?"
"Sir William Tolliver... So Marrack says."
"Yes, but you know he didn't."
"Know... nothing," said Ridgway.
"Where were you when he was killed?"
"Minding my own business."
Tolefree hesitated on the brink of another question, opened his mouth, shut it with a snap, stared at Ridgway.
"I see," he said at last. "Did you carry a camera as well as a gun that morning?"
"Always do... camera."
Tolefree held out a finger of warning to Ridgway, and called to me.
"Farrar—just a moment."
I went to him. He took his revolver from his pocket and handed it to me.
"Cover Mr. Ridgway," he said. "I'm going to commit another outrage. I'm going to have a look at your dark room, Mr. Ridgway."
Ridgway's eyes narrowed.
"Dirty intrusion," he said. "Might have asked... Put that dam' thing up... Don't want to quarrel."
Tolefree took the pistol from me and pocketed it.
"Very well," said he. "May I have a look at your dark room?"
"All right... Show you anything.... Why not?"
He rose from the chair, towering over us all. Four strides took him to the door of the dark room. He threw it open, switched on a light, waited for us to pass in. A large room, fitted with benches, shelves, troughs. As elaborately business-like a place as the studio and the shop were otherwise. One side of it was devoted to pursuits which appeared to have nothing to do with photography. Tolefree cast a glance along the bench of strangely twisted glass and porcelain vessels, a retort, a blowpipe, other things foreign to my intelligence. Then he turned to the dark-room bench, with its shallow dishes and plate-racks. A hypo bath stood at the side of the big trough. In the trough itself was a dish of plates with the water streaming over them from a rubber tube attached to the tap. At the distant end of the bench, an enlarging lantern attracted Tolefree's attention. On the board in front of it appeared a vague image. He stepped up to examine it.
"Switch off the light a moment, Farrar," said he.
I reached for the switch at the door. Immediately the image on the board sprang into sharp vision—the head of a man, with a black face and white hair, a negative image—but unquestionably the image of Tolefree himself!
"Jolly good!" said Tolefree. "Switch on again, Farrar. Haven't made a print yet, Mr. Ridgway, I guess?"
"No... You interrupted me... Dam' smart... Suppose you saw me?"
"Yes, and I'm glad I didn't smash your camera. But why, man? Why?"
"Why?... I don't have to tell you."
"No?" Tolefree was fidgeting with the lantern. "Here—come and take out this plate. Still wet, I reckon."
The plate, when the long yellow fingers had dexterously extracted it from the carrier of the lantern, was handed to Tolefree. He held it to the light. We all peered through it. Three figures against a background of rock with a foreground of water. Ann Carberry and Angwin and I sat on a moss-grown stone and Tolefree stood holding out his tobacco-pouch to me. His face was in vigorous profile.
He passed the negative back to Ridgway, who placed it in a rack. He took three other plates from the water: in each of them were our three figures against the same background in different stages of our conversation.
"If walls have ears the woods have eyes," said Tolefree. "This suggests to me, Mr. Ridgway, that you might now care to tell us who killed Sir William Tolliver."
Ridgway took a long look at him—I hardly know how to describe it—an intense, questing look. He was a strange sight, his tall, gaunt figure leaning against the door-post, arms crossed over the absurd jumper on his narrow chest, blue eyes reflecting the glow of the electric lamp. He seemed to have no sense of being under inquisition himself: he looked like some fantastic augur determining the fate of three inconsiderable mortals.
"You don't believe Marrack?" he said after a pause. "Sorry... can't tell you... don't know... tell you if I did."
It was Tolefree's turn to stare speculatively for several seconds. Then he turned away without pursuing the question. His eyes wandered over the shelves above the benches. One of them bore a large number of plate-boxes, neatly piled, each ticketed with a set of figures.
"About the views, Mr. Ridgway," said Tolefree surprisingly; "I'd like to have prints from these negatives"—and he pointed a finger at a box with the legend "3.7.32."
That was a daring shot: the 3rd July was the day of Tolliver's death.
Ridgway stepped over to the bench and pulled out the box. He looked at the date. A queer smile twisted the face he turned to Tolefree.
"Private pictures... not for sale," said he.
"So I imagined. Well—you see?"
"See nothing... see—nothing... nothing that you imagine... D'you think that if... No, you can't... you're too clever."
Ridgway replaced the box.
"Come out here," he said, taking an abrupt stride to the door. "Prints—I'll show you."
We followed him into the studio. He unlocked a table-drawer and extracted a packet of prints.
"There they are."
He spread them on the table: four highly finished enlargements. As I gazed at them, a catch took my breath. All four were pictures taken in the Tolgerth valley from about the same point where Ridgway had been concealed that morning. Each negative had been marked in the left-hand bottom corner with a time and a date which printed up in white. In order they were:
"10.40 a.m. 3.7.32." A dark background of trees, with a glint of the river showing. In the foreground, a man's figure with his back to the camera, peeping round the bole of a young oak. There had not been much light on this subject.
"Who's that?" said Tolefree.
Ridgway shrugged his shoulders.
"No good to beg the question, Ridgway," said Angwin. "Can't see his face, but I know the figure. It's Gannett."
"Is it?" Tolefree looked up to Ridgway's face.
"Gannett... yes," said he.
Tolefree took up the next print.
"10.42 a.m. 3.7.32." A little nearer the river. An opening between thick foliage in the foreground revealing the face of the cliff opposite at the very point where we had stood in the morning, but the view was closed down at the top by the branch of a densely clothed beech. It showed only the legs of a man standing beside the flat boulder.
"Sir William Tolliver?"
Ridgway nodded.
"10.43 a.m. 3.7.32." A slight change of position. The sapling with Tolliver's rod leaning against it had been squeezed into the picture, and Tolliver himself had his back to the camera and was leaning over the boulder.
"10.45 a.m. 3.7.32." The photographer had changed position yet again to get a clearer view across the river. He had dodged the low-hanging branch of the beech, but its trunk made a black mass filling the right-hand side of the picture. However, there was a full-length portrait of Tolliver. He stood looking fixedly across the river with his left hand spread out above his eyes to shade them from the light, and in his right hand a revolver.
Tolefree inspected the prints minutely, peering into every corner of them, looking up at Ridgway, peering again. How he controlled his emotions so perfectly mystified me. Perhaps he had no emotions. But the exhibition was amazing.
If only one man in the world knew what had happened that July morning, it was Ridgway. If two men knew, Ridgway was one of them. He had produced to us a chain of evidence which proved that he was not out of hearing and probably not out of sight when Tolliver died, and fifteen minutes before his death had photographed him.
Yet Ridgway remained as unconcerned as though he were showing Tolefree a photograph of Carnmenellis church, and Tolefree acted as though he were at a tea-party, looking through a girl's album. He slowly packed the prints together and handed them to Ridgway.
"Thanks," he said; "you're a wonderful photographer if you'll let me say so. Jolly hard to get pictures under trees. Extraordinary results under such difficulties."
Ridgway took much the same tone in his own queer fashion.
"Oh, don't know about that... Fine lenses.... Very rapid plates nowadays."
"And you don't care to tell me who shot him?"
"I've said... don't know... would if I could."
Tolefree, as if in a fit of brown study, pulled out of his pocket the revolver he had taken from Ridgway, put it back, took it out, fingered it, looked at the magazine.
"Anyhow, you must have heard the shot," said he.
"Yes... I heard it... Shan't answer any more questions."
Tolefree passed the revolver to him.
"Very well, Mr. Ridgway," he said. "Here's your gun. Much obliged to you. See you again, no doubt, and compare notes on Lully and Ramsay. By the way, what a lovely portrait this is, Farrar!"
Tolefree drew my attention to a tall desk against the wall over which hung a reproduction of the beautiful face we had seen in the shop below. Standing beside him, I noticed a signature spread across the bottom of the print: "Ada to the Artist. August, 1931." As we drew back, Ridgway was looking through the long window to the quay and the little harbour. He turned and presented to us a face distorted with rage and suffering. He held out the skinny hand and we took our leave.
"SO—no impenetrable mystery after all," said Tolefree as we came out into the sunshine on the quay. "At least two people know all about it. Secret de Polichinelle, I guess. As to your friend Tolliver—have I got him right, Angwin? Was he really the admirable Crichton of all chemists and sportsmen?"
"What d'you mean? Are you suggesting—suggesting——"
"Nothing in the world. Leave it. We'll talk this out after. Something more important for the moment—Marrack. I've got to see him again right away. Are you coming?"
"Of course, if you want me."
"Don't get hipped," he smiled. "I've nothing on your friend Tolliver. Just a fleeting idea. I'd like you to come to Marrack's. A policeman after my own heart. Thoroughly sound chap. Willing to help the good work along."
"I know Marrack's good all through," said Angwin. "He's a firm friend of mine. But Marrack's quite made up his mind that Tolliver committed suicide. You can't change him."
"Perhaps not. But before I left London I got an acquaintance at Scotland Yard—ever hear of Pierce? Well, hardly likely, but Marrack would know of him—I induced Pierce to write and get me in good with Marrack, as they'd say across the water. Expressive phrase, that! Well, you know, canis caninum—dog doesn't eat dog. I never antagonize the police. And Marrack, though he sticks to his own opinion, is quite ready to rake things over again, or rather let me do it while he keeps the ring. Perhaps a bit more than that. However, you'll see."
Marrack's office was the front room of his little house, combining domesticity and constabulary.
When we entered the first thing I saw, as Marrack shook hands with Angwin and was made aware of me, was a dark, down-looking fellow, sitting in a corner of the room with a face like a thunder-cloud.
"Ah," said Tolefree, "is this Mr. Gannett? Much obliged to you for inviting him, Mr. Marrack. Much obliged to you for coming, Mr. Gannett."
But it must be confessed that Gannett did not look the least bit obliged either to Marrack or Tolefree. And the Inspector made no motion of throwing bouquets.
A sad case, Gannett, it seemed. The conventional bad lad of the village, a scandal to his neighbours and a nuisance to the police.
"Here he is, Mr. Tolefree," said Marrack, in his loud bass. "I've told him nothing, except that you wanted to ask him a few questions and he'd better answer 'em straight."
"Naturally Mr. Gannett knows he's not legally bound to answer questions," Tolefree remarked mildly. "Just a friendly talk, eh?"
"Oh, you bet Gannett knows all that, Mr. Tolefree. He's a very experienced man, Gannett."
The man scowled at Marrack's heavy pleasantry.
"If Mr. Gannett will come forward so that we can see each other——" Tolefree placed a chair where the face of his victim would get the full light from the window: a lowering face, heavy, a little cunning but not very intelligent. Gannett was a man between forty and fifty. He wore a thick moustache; but otherwise his features had a certain brutal grace—no doubt what twenty years before had made him tolerable to the unhappy woman who now lived in one of the courts of Carnmenellis.
"I want to impress this on you, Gannett," Tolefree was saying; "by the way, have a cigarette?" He passed over his case, waited while Gannett fumbled one out, lit it for him. "I want to impress this on you—that there's no obligation to say anything. If you sit there and keep your mouth shut—well, I shall be sorry, but I shan't have any grouch. You understand?"
Gannett allowed Tolefree to be sorry. He sat there with his mouth shut and his dark eyes smouldering.
"I'm staying with Mr. Angwin at Tresneven," said Tolefree. "Arrived there last evening."
Even this piece of social intelligence did not stir Gannett more than it would have stirred the Sphinx. But somehow I pitied the man under the relentless searching of Tolefree's gaze.
"Would you like to tell me, Gannett, where you were at ten o'clock last night?"
No answer.
"Well, that's a rather personal question, perhaps. I'll put it another way. Were you anywhere near Tresneven at ten o'clock last night?"
Silence.
"Do you know of anyone else who was near Tresneven at ten o'clock last night?"
The flicker of the eyelid might have been in my imagination. If not it was a mere split-second thing. Gannett did not speak.
"Thank you, Gannett," said Tolefree. "I perceive that you were not at Tresneven last night, but that you do know who was. Will you tell me his name?"
The smoulder of resentment in Gannett's eyes changed to a look of fear. It was an astonishing, instantaneous transformation, but in the eyes alone: he made no movement and said no word.
"What's your opinion, Gannett, about the death of Sir William Tolliver? Mr. Marrack thinks he committed suicide. Do you?"
Gannett had started at the sudden change of topic, but he expressed no opinion about the death of Tolliver.
"You're in the service of Mr. Penhaligon, I believe?"
Gannett allowed Tolefree to believe it or not.
"Well, you are. Now, was Mr. Penhaligon with you or near you?"
"Where?"
It was the first word Gannett had said.
"In Rosneven woods, near the river."
"When?"
"At the time when Sir William Tolliver died," said Tolefree.
"It's a dam' lie!"
Gannett rapped it out, rose from his chair.
"Sit down, Gannett," said Tolefree. "No need for excitement. Mr. Penhaligon was not there? I'll check up on that. So you were alone?"
"It's a dam' lie!"
"What? You weren't there either? Where were you?"
"That's my business."
"Exactly, but you've got a partner and it's me," said Tolefree ungrammatically but devastatingly.
I saw the blood run out of Gannett's face under his dark skin.
"Glad you've decided to cut out the strong, silent man stuff, Gannett; but though, as I point out to you again, you're not compelled to answer my questions it would be just as well, if you do answer, to tell the truth. As a matter of fact, Gannett, I know the truth. I beg you to get hold of that. If you tell me any lies I shall instantly detect them, and we know what happens to liars when there's a serious matter afoot, don't we, Mr. Marrack?"
"So does Gannett," said the Inspector; "he's an experienced man, as I said before."
Gannett cast a look of extreme dislike at Marrack. Tolefree shook his head.
"Sad that all his experience has taught him nothing. D'you know, Mr. Marrack, he just told me a lie?"
"Shouldn't wonder," said Marrack.
"Yes: he said he wasn't in Rosneven woods by the river the morning Sir William died. But you were, Gannett. You were there slinking behind the trees and watching him not many minutes before his death."
"What!" cried Marrack.
"Yes. Hasn't Gannett told you about it all this time? Dear me!"
Tolefree got up and lounged against Marrack's table, looking down on the wretched man.
"You know, Mr. Marrack, this fellow's got an uncommon genius for not saying anything. Quite a splendid characteristic. But if there's a time to be silent, there's a time to talk. This is it, Gannett, believe me. Now, was Mr. Penhaligon anywhere near by that morning?"
Gannett rose too.
"Mr. Marrack," said he, "I haven't got to say anything, have I?"
"Not a word, Gannett. If you've anything on your conscience, up to you whether you get it off now or have it torn off later on. There's the door if you want to leave."
Tolefree walked to the door, threw it open, and stood back. Gannett looked from Tolefree's enigmatical, smiling face to the rugged, bearded countenance of the Inspector. He looked exactly like a trapped animal—afraid to stay, afraid to move. He sat down again. Sweat oozed out of his forehead. Tolefree closed the door and returned to his place.
"Now, was Mr. Penhaligon near by that morning?"
He resumed the catechism as though nothing had happened.
"Yes," said Gannett, "but not then. He'd gone."
"Why were you there?"
"My job to be there."
"How—job?"
"To see Sir William didn't fish in Rosneven water."
"Ah! Mr. Penhaligon's instructions?"
"Yes."
"For that special day?"
"Every day when Sir William was fishing."
"Well," said Tolefree, "that's a reasonable explanation. Why make a mystery of it? Why say it was a dam' lie?"
"How'd I know what you were getting at?"
"If it comes to that, how d'you know now?"
Gannett had no answer to that.
"You remember," said Tolefree, "I asked you just now whether you agreed with Mr. Marrack's opinion that Sir William committed suicide. Do you?"
"How'd I know——" he began.
"I see you don't."
"I never said it——"
"No, but I see it. Perhaps you'd like to tell us exactly what did happen."
"I don't know what happened."
"Oh, but think, Gannett—just think. You were there to see that Sir William didn't fish in Rosneven water. Your job, you know. But he hadn't begun to fish before he died. Hadn't even put a cast on his line."
"Don't know anything about it," said Gannett doggedly.
"I say you do, Gannett. I know you do. Look here, Gannett—it was you that scared him, you know. Remember how he leaned his rod up against a tree and took out his gun, and shaded his eyes to look across the water where you were hidden?"
I could hardly say which of the two was more dumbfounded, Marrack or Gannett. The Inspector gasped. Gannett shrank down on his chair and stared at Tolefree in terror.
"See?" said Tolefree. "You remember that! Now—did he fire?"
"I swear to God——"
"Swear not at all—not now. Just tell me that: did he fire? You're no fool, Gannett. You realize what it means. I ask you again: did he fire?"
"I swear to God I don't know!" Gannett was abject, all his truculence gone. "I thought he might. I got out."
Tolefree eyed the sweating man for ten seconds.
"Gannett," he said, "you're lying to me. If you didn't see the shot, you heard it."
"Not then—not then!" he cried. "I'm telling the truth. He did look as if he might fire, but then he turned round and put his gun down on the rock."
"But you said you got out——"
"Afterwards—I did, and pretty dam' quick."
Once more Tolefree's eye held him fast. Gannett's face was writhing. Tolefree resumed.
"You're lying. Or you're not telling all the truth. You heard the firing. How many shots?"
"One shot."
"Where were you?"
"Back in the woods by that time."
"And then, Gannett—what then?"
"How d'you mean—then?"
"What did you do when you heard the shot?"
"Went on down the river."
"Didn't stop or go back to see whether anyone was killed?"
"No."
"Didn't carry on with the job—to prevent Sir William from fishing in Rosneven water?"
"No."
"You're a most unconvincing liar, Gannett. Not a bit artistic. You hated Sir William Tolliver, didn't you?"
"Got no reason to love him."
"Well, I've heard otherwise. But never mind that. You hated him. Now, see this, Gannett. Sir William Tolliver either shot himself or somebody else shot him. You know whether he committed suicide, and if he didn't you either shot him yourself or you know who did shoot him."
"How could I kill him? I'd only got a shotgun."
"Then—who did?"
"I know nothing about it."
"You aren't coming across, I can see. But I shall do without your help, Gannett. You know what that means—no one better. If Mr. Marrack doesn't want you any more, good afternoon."
Tolefree opened the door and stood aside while the man picked himself up and walked out.
"That's a nasty creature, Marrack," said Tolefree. "Hope you don't breed many like it in Carnmenellis."
"No, thank God! Sneaking little weasel. Fine, the way you put it across him. He's been getting a bit above himself these days."
"But you don't think——"
"No, Mr. Tolefree. Evidence for suicide's too strong. I dare say he was scared stiff when he saw Tolliver's gun, and made himself as thin as he could."
"Still, he hadn't given you any of this stuff?"
"No—but I hadn't asked him."
"I wonder if you'd do me a favour—just get somebody to keep tab on Gannett's movements and find out where he goes and the people he talks to?"
"I can do that. Our matey friend Brimmell will tail him up. But as to a secret watch I'm afraid that ain't possible in Carnmenellis. We all know each other too well," said Marrack with a short, dry laugh.
"That don't matter. I only want to find out his reactions to our polite conversation this afternoon. And—many thanks. I'll keep in touch with you. About that little souvenir——"
Marrack lifted the cover of a desk and took from it a tiny cardboard box.
"Don't trouble to open it, Marrack. Here's the gun. If you could pack them both and register them off this afternoon——? You have the note I wrote? And here's the address: Joseph Pierce, C.I.D., New Scotland Yard, S.W.1."
On the way back to Polventor, Angwin and I, naturally bursting with speculation, poured questions on an unresponsive Tolefree. He would say nothing on the revelations of the afternoon: time for chewing and digesting he demanded, and the sole right of reporting on our adventures—for he feared raising in Mrs. Carberry's mind false hopes of a quick solution. He sank back into his seat, fixed his eyes straight ahead, and became silent as Gannett.
At the house we found Waverton and the two women, with the tea-cups under an awning on the terrace, and joined them. In ten minutes Tolefree suggested that Angwin should take me for a stroll round the gardens while he told his tale. He said he'd got it straight now, and didn't want us butting in with comments and enlargements. We took the hint... When we returned it was to an earnest discussion on the danger Tolefree might be running of further attempts to put him out of the hunt.
Waverton was pointing out the folly of cocksureness; anyway, Polventor didn't want another corpse on its hands.
Tolefree laughed it away—said something about wearing chain-mail under his waistcoat and being bullet-proof. He wouldn't listen to the idea that he might change quarters by staying at Polventor for a night or two.
"I told you I've already got three suspects. I'm prepared for 'em all, jointly and severally. Don't worry about me, Mrs. Carberry. Three or four days and I'll be back in dingy Watling Street sighing for tea on the terrace at Polventor. Now I'm going to make Farrar and Mr. Angwin walk back to Tresneven. We all want exercise. And I'll promise not to show my nose outside the house after we get in. Ring up if you like, to be assured I'm alive at bedtime."
So lightly he passed it off.
The walk across the moors that gorgeous evening was tonic.
"Still chewing?" Angwin asked him.
"Cud stage now. Let's talk of something else. Tell me the names of the hills, heights in feet, geology, fauna, flora—anything. What air! How high are we here? I feel as lively as a jackrabbit..."
At dinner he charmed Mrs. Angwin again. He excused himself while he got a telephone call to London, leaving us to amuse her in the drawing-room. When she had retired we sat in Angwin's study till dark, discussing the day's experiences.
Then we went to bed. Tolefree came into my room for a final jaw.
These were the bare facts of our first full day on the Tolliver case.
Before I approach the weird affair of the second attack on Tolefree, I want to set down a few impressions of my own and contrast them with what I could make out to be the state of Tolefree's mind when we said good night.
As to myself, I ought to have known better, no doubt, than to call down Tolefree's wrathful scorn upon me (as I did) by trying to play Tolefree myself—to be a psychologist and draw conclusions from vague, intangible things. I had been a more or less passive spectator of the day's work. It had brought into full view two of Ann Carberry's potential suspects—and presently one of them was to take the limelight more fully. Others stood in the half shadows of the background. The preposterous Penhaligon was one. Andrew Baripper was another, though at that point I was blind to his significance. I thought there was a fifth, and nervously blurted out the idea to Tolefree.
"That fellow Waverton," I said, "I don't like him, Tolefree."
"No? He's not what you'd call sympathetic, is he to Mrs. Carberry. Tastes differ. I don't know that he wildly impassions me, either. A bit too contemptuous of our shining abilities. Is that what's hurting you?"
"Not that exactly." I hesitated. At close quarters it seemed impertinent to suggest to Tolefree what was in my mind. "I don't like him in himself," said I.
It was true. Certain types are antipathetic to certain others. Waverton's was the type of confident egotism which always gets my goat. I shrank from his bold, rather gross handsomeness and his cocksureness. But now that it came to the point I could not get it across to Tolefree. I cut it down.
"I wouldn't put it past him," said I, "to shoot a man. Would you?"
To say that this startled Tolefree is inadequate. He gazed at me for several seconds. Then he exclaimed:
"Good heavens, Farrar! Have you gone dippy? You're thinking... but no!—it's too mad."
"What am I thinking?" said I. "I just asked you a question."
"Would I put it past Waverton to shoot a man? Well—it depends. I wouldn't put it past you, Farrar, if it comes to that. But that's not what you're after. Are you suggesting that Waverton shot Tolliver? If so, in the name of sanity keep the great idea to yourself. My dear chap, this is grotesque! How on earth could Waverton——"
"But steady, Tolefree! You're putting words into my mouth."
"I'll be hanged if I am. You're putting 'em into mine. If there's no such notion in your mind, why on earth——?"
I had put my foot in it by yielding to a mere instinctive prejudice; there may also have been a little foolish emulation of Tolefree's own method of approach to a hidden thing. But that was the last of it. He jumped on it hard. He was mightily disturbed by the fear that I might in some involuntary way betray my animosity towards Waverton.
"If you feel like that, Farrar," said he, "for God's sake don't let anyone else see it. Think of the absurdity in face of the facts. We shall want all the help we can get from Waverton and the Polventor people. It's dangerous to let personal likes and dislikes butt in."
"All right," I told him.
And thus my poor little psychological hunch went west.
So much for me.
Now for my impressions of Tolefree's state of mind. Although I confess that some of them may have been deepened by later events, as far as possible I confine them to the points that had emerged up to that evening. I do it with certain provisos—that Tolefree was necessarily secretive (I shall have to tell farther on of his apologetic reasons for this), and that he purposely ignored whatever significance there was in Baripper's presence and his pretext for visiting Tresneven on Sunday afternoon. He had three groups of ideas:
He had come to a provisional conclusion that Tolliver did not commit suicide, but safeguarded himself with reservations. The physical facts which appeared on the surface suggested suicide (posture of the body and the gun), and though there were other facts only now coming to the surface (presence of Ridgway and Gannett on the scene, possibly Penhaligon also, and the evidence of the photographs), they did not absolutely rule out the theory of suicide.
Against that theory was the apparent absence of motive, and the character of Tolliver himself. Tolefree put a great deal on Ann's acute understanding of Tolliver.
Yet nothing was more difficult than to discover all the motives that might lie concealed in a man's mind or the secrets in his life. Motive and secret might both come surging to the surface. There was Tolliver's strange unease in the weeks preceding his death. And there was one other thing (still in effect hidden from me) which had struck Tolefree's imagination—Ridgway's rejected appeal to Tolliver for a private interview, and his warning that if it were not given Tolliver would "regret it to the end of his days." I had assumed that this was another foolish attempt of Ridgway to pester Tolliver with his fantastic scientific stuff. Tolefree was not so sure. Ridgway, he thought, might be a little eccentric about chemical experiments. Lonely and studious men were often touched on a single point. But Tolefree judged that Ridgway had a good, capable mind and a great fund of tenderness. He asked me, for example, if I had noticed the violent reaction upon Ridgway of his allusion to the portrait of the beautiful girl in his studio. "A tortured soul looked out of Ridgway's eyes"—that was his way of putting it.
Then he said a strange, prophetic sort of thing. "If Ridgway ever committed a murder, it would be on that side of him, Farrar."
He joined up a certain three observations: Ridgway's reaction to the portrait produced in him the intensest emotion of which he was capable; Ridgway had been indecently urgent in his claim on Tolliver's attention and that urgency was inspired by some powerful motive; Tolliver on this occasion had been strangely and uncharacteristically brusque with Ridgway. A sequence of disturbing ideas to be "tucked away" with the rest for reference.
On this line of thought, supposing that Tolliver had made some mistake in rejecting Ridgway's appeal for a confidence, a real personal secret in Tolliver's life could not be dismissed as impossible, despite Ann Carberry's belief, and such a secret might provide the motive for suicide. Tolefree wanted to know whether Ridgway had a daughter. But Ridgway had never, to Angwin's knowledge, been married.
Tolefree, however, had more powerful reasons for a provisional conclusion that Tolliver was murdered. They fell into two classes.
(a) Psychological reasons, and among them Ann's conviction, out of a deep knowledge of her uncle's character, that he was not a man who under any circumstances would kill himself. Ann might be wrong. But her judgment was borne out by the conception Tolefree had been able to form of Tolliver, and particularly by his reading of Tolliver's conduct immediately before his death. Whatever the nature of the cloud that had fallen on him in those weeks, it had lifted by the Sunday, and the Tolliver Angwin described, in his own house rejoicing with his friends, did not seem to him to be a man on the brink of suicide.
(b) Physical reasons, which were at the present moment even stronger than the psychological. The facts that determined the Coroner and the police in their theory of suicide were chiefly two: that Tolliver was alone in the gorge when he died; that his own revolver with one empty shell in it was found in the river by his side. Now it had been proved that Tolliver was not alone but that at least two people were within a few yards of him. And it was possible that Tolliver fired his gun not at himself but at some other person.
(At this point Tolefree revealed a little of his confidences with Marrack: he had secured from Marrack the bullet which killed Tolliver. He had also obtained Tolliver's revolver from Toms, and both were now on their way to Scotland Yard, where the experts would discover whether the one was actually fired from the other.)
The remaining pointer to a murder was the extraordinary behaviour of the two men on the opposite bank of the river—not so much at the time as afterwards. Ridgway and his photographs needed more explanation than his reputation for eccentricity provided.
(And at this point Tolefree revealed a little of his private observations at Ridgway's: the gun which Ridgway carried contained six shells, and one of them had been exploded.)
Gannett's postures, both in the wood and at Marrack's office, were even more suspicious than Ridgway's, and he made no secret (useless for him to try) of his hatred of Tolliver.
Both Ridgway and Gannett, he concluded, were on the spot when Tolliver died. If neither of them killed him, and if neither of them actually saw him fall, both heard the shot, or shots, and both probably knew who fired. But they had said nothing to the police or to anyone else of all this.
This pointed to one of two things: either sheer lunacy, or a desperate resolve to prevent the discovery of something which a close inquiry into the Tolliver affair would reveal. The theory of an unsuspected leakage from Polventor to account for it was now unnecessary. Baripper knew that Tolefree was coming to Cornwall, and if Baripper doubtless other people.
As I have hinted, the matter probably did not stand as concisely as this in my mind when the three of us said good night: I dare say some of it is an echo of the conference we had at Polventor next morning.
I went to bed and to sleep...
Tresneven is not a large house. Eight bedrooms occupy the first floor, three on each side of a corridor and one at each end. I had been given the room at the western end of the corridor, its windows facing west, and Tolefree the next, looking out over the lawn on the north side. Mrs. Angwin was somewhere in the middle of the corridor and Angwin himself at the other end. The two maids who were all Mrs. Angwin's indoor staff slept in attics above; her gardener and jack-of-all-trades lived in a cottage at the bottom of the combe. Angwin looked after his own car and attended to the little electric light plant. The isolation of the house in the woods has already been made clear; at night it is very quiet.
That night happened to be particularly still—a warm summer night. On the Sunday there had been a stir of breeze among the leaves of the great beech on the lawn. But now the silence was deadly, and as I looked out, after dousing the light, through my wide-open window at the outline of the woods against the sky, I noticed the absence of motion as well as of sound. It was so silent that a leaf falling would have been heard. Such a night comes perhaps no more than once or twice in a summer.
To that absolute stillness no doubt was due the fact that what must have been a minute sound awoke me in the middle of the night. Suddenly I was fully awake and alert—listening, but hardly conscious of an effort to listen. I glanced at the luminous dial of the little clock on my bed-table. It was half-past two.
Then I heard the sound—a rustle and a creak. I was out of bed on the instant, peering through the window down into the blackness of the garden, straining my ears.
It came again, clear now against the silence. I realized it in a flash—the beech tree!
It was not in my line of vision, but I knew its branches stretched out almost touching the window of Tolefree's room.
Tolefree—there asleep!—Waverton's warning—Mrs. Carberry's fears...
In the same flash I was out of my room, and in the corridor, listened for a moment at Tolefree's door: a sound as of deep, regular breathing. Tolefree slept.
Then, even through the panel of the closed door, I heard that rustle and creak for the third time. I turned the door handle, praying that Tolefree had not locked himself in, cried, "Tolefree, look out!" and pushed.
The door opened upon a black room, darker than mine because of the thick-clad tree outside. Before I could pick out any object or say another word, the noise outside was repeated, loudly, continuously, lasting two or three seconds. Then silence again.
"That's torn it!" said a voice in my ear. "For God's sake don't switch on the light, Farrar!"
Tolefree was beside me.
"Stand where you are," he said.
I had a sense of a shadow crossing the room, of a head showing dim against the window.
"Got away with it," said Tolefree; "he won't try again now. Switch on."
When the lights blazed up:
"Good heavens!" I exclaimed.
Tolefree stood away from the window, fully dressed, holding in his left hand an electric torch and in the other a business-like automatic pistol. He grinned at my astonishment.
"My guardian angel!" he remarked. "Intensely grateful for your admirable intentions, but—oh, what poisonous luck! Why the devil didn't you sleep through it? I'd have had him stone cold!"
I flopped on the side of Tolefree's bed.
"Oh damn!" I groaned.
Tolefree was splendid. His good humour never failed.
"Don't take it to heart, Farrar. I'd have done as much for you."
"All the same—damn!" said I. "You never saw him, of course?"
"No—too dark. I wanted him in the room. And he'd have been here in another half a tick. Whenever he stopped to listen, I encouraged him with a few hearty snores. I was enjoying it in anticipation like this: he'll drop over the sill, grope for the bed. A hundred candle-power will suddenly hit him in the eye, and a nasty voice will hit him in the ear—'Put 'em up!' He will put 'em up. And, hey presto! we shall have the fellow that murdered Sir William Tolliver. He will take a ride in Farrar's car, with the muzzle of this thing grinding against his ribs, and at half-past three Inspector Marrack will have charge of him. Such was my idle dream."
"Oh, Tolefree!"
"Don't sigh. My dear fellow, it was simply great of you. But you must be a mighty light sleeper."
"No good to get after him, I suppose?"
"Not a chance—now. But there'll be another one, I guess. Persistent devil, isn't he?"
Tolefree came and sat on the bed beside me; opened the table drawer and put away torch and pistol.
"You've not been to bed——"
"No. It was so obvious. Angwin's ancestors must have foreseen this and planted that tree on purpose. Not but what he'd have found a ladder if there'd been no tree."
I shuddered.
"Get back to bed," said Tolefree. "I have myself a powerful exposition of sleep upon me. We'll ponder it at breakfast."
THE Angwins slept through it, which was surprising. I suppose my cry to Tolefree had sounded abnormally loud to me. Naturally we said nothing about it in the presence of the old lady; but we had to tell Angwin, and he was alarmed.
"Entertaining you at Tresneven's a nerve-racking business, Tolefree," he said; "we never know when you'll turn into a second corpse on us."
Tolefree himself seemed literally to enjoy it; at any rate, made a joke of it—said he felt as proverbial as Sancho Panza: a bird in the hand was worth two in the beech tree; murder would out; if we gave the tree-climber enough rope he'd infallibly hang himself; a miss was as good as a mile. And so on...
Miss Carberry rang at eight, before we sat down to breakfast. She was apparently anxious.
I heard Angwin assure her that he was all right; then, "Half a moment. I'll ask Tolefree whether he's dead."
Tolefree was on the lawn, basking in the morning sun. Angwin called through the window.
"Ann wants to know if anything happened. Shall I tell her to wait till we go over?"
Tolefree strolled into the room.
"We can't go over very soon. I must stay here till I get a call from London—about ten. Too severe a trial of feminine patience. But I wonder whether Miss Carberry would like to come along here after breakfast?"
The little car roared up the drive before nine as we sat in three of four deck-chairs on the lawn. Ann went to pay a duty call on Mrs. Angwin in her room before she joined us.
Her trim little figure walking across the turf, her wave of the hand...
"Lovely!" Tolefree murmured.
"Well, you look Arcadians all!" she said gaily, as we got up to meet her. "Good morning, Mr. Tolefree. Any wounds to-day? I've got a first-aid certificate."
"No," said Tolefree. "Sorry I can't oblige. Why? Did you expect blood for breakfast?"
Ann took the fourth chair and looked narrowly at him.
"Yes. To tell the honest-to-goodness truth, I rather did. You're a fearful responsibility. When people take a distaste for you they dislike you so violently."
"Well, perhaps they're right. Anyhow, I feel no symptoms at present of increasing popularity. If it hadn't been for Farrar——"
"Now, look here, Tolefree," said I, "no garbling. Better let me tell it."
"Then—something did happen!" cried Ann. "I knew it."
"The news can hardly have been broadcast already, I think," said Tolefree. "How did you know it? By inner light or external information?"
"Both," Ann replied. "But what was it?"
I told her, with sundry light-minded interruptions from Tolefree. She sat listening, motionless, her red lips half open. When the tale was done she rose and walked to the end of the lawn, looking up at the beech tree and the open window, and down on the grass where a few leaves and twigs were the only token of his visit that the marauder had left. Tolefree and I had already searched for tracks—sought them everywhere on the premises, and found none. The lawn was baked as hard as a board. She came back to us.
"What a sell!" was her comment. "Mr. Farrar!—misplaced heroism is worse than crime. Only think—if Mr. Tolefree had been able to say 'Put 'em up!'—like that! All the same, I admit you never know. I'm rather glad, on the whole."
"He'll do better next time, Miss Carberry," Tolefree laughed.
"Next time! You think there'll be a next time?"
"I wish I was as sure of a million," Tolefree declared. "But tell us—about your intuition and your extraction, won't you?"
Ann perched on the edge of her chair, elbows on knees, chin cupped in her hands, and stared at Tolefree a few moments.
"What time did you say? Half-past two?"
"Near as nothing," I answered.
"Well—as for intuition, I seriously think, Mr. Tolefree, you'd better throw it up and go back to London. Isn't it plain that so long as you adorn these landscapes you're in constant danger? Won't you pass it all over to Mr. Marrack and let 'em climb in at his window instead?"
"Nothing doing," said Tolefree.
"I thought not. Well, as for information—listen to this. Guy Waverton, after you went last evening, was like a grasshopper on a hot plate; he worked mother and me up into a horrid state of nerves. He felt certain we ought not to have let you come over here to be potted at. Talked about the lovely ambushes in these woods, and—so mother got the squitches——"
"Help!" cried Tolefree. "Got what?"
"Squitches—Cornish for fidgets. And I began to feel uneasy. Then Guy went out for a ten minutes' walk after dinner and found that man Gannett prowling around. Told him to make himself scarce, but had to listen to a yarn about persecution and the third degree—a lurid report of your meeting with him at Marrack's. Gannett's grievance was that the people at Polventor must have got this 'ere detective down to nose about and make honest men's lives not worth living—and what had the people at Polventor got against him now, seeing as how he'd done time for those odd bits of things that sort of grouch. Guy said it was no business of his, but anyhow if Gannett didn't keep away from Polventor, he'd see about making him. And that finished that. Except one thing, Mr. Tolefree——"
"Which was, I presume, this: was the detective bloke staying at Polventor last night and could Mr. Gannett have a word with him?"
"Exactly," said Ann, jumping up. "You weren't by any chance hiding behind a bush, were you?"
"Certainly not. But it's quite obvious. You'll agree with me if you think it over, Miss Carberry."
Ann thought it over, and the effort made a bewitching little crease over the top of her nose.
"Yes—I suppose so. But Guy wouldn't tell him anything—of course. So that's what must have caused the shemozzle in the small hours of the morning."
"Shemozzle——?" cried Tolefree.
"Where—at your place?" cried I.
"Precisely—shemozzle at our place at 1 a.m."
It was our turn to stare open-mouthed at Ann telling us what had happened at Polventor.
"Very still night last night," she said, "and very hot. I couldn't get off sound asleep for thinking what I should wear at Mr. Tolefree's funeral——"
Tolefree bowed as gracefully as his semirecumbent position in a deck-chair would permit.
"So I heard the clock in the hall say twelve, and half-past. Then—it must have been just as I dozed off—someone slung up a window with a crash. You can imagine the row it made in that dead silence. I leaped out of bed and looked out at my own window. Couldn't see anything—except a light from someone else's room shining down on the terrace. I dashed into the corridor, and mother rushed out of her room, and Guy came out of his, which was lit up. He was pulling on a dressing-gown. He said, 'You two stay here,' and bolted downstairs——"
"So, of course, you didn't stay there," said Tolefree.
"Naturally. I just went back for a dressing-gown and slippers, and bolted down after him. He'd opened the front door and gone out. I looked about for a minute, couldn't see him; then he came along the terrace. 'Thought I told you to stay put up there,' said he in the grand masculine manner. However, he was good enough to tell me the beggar had got away, and didn't even say it was my fault. And he raised no objection when I followed him into the drawing-room and assisted him to inspect the windows, which were all bolted on the inside."
"Somebody trying to break and enter by night—otherwise burgle?" said Tolefree.
"Well, what do you think? Guy'd been awake, heard a crack and a stumble on the terrace—as if somebody had hit his toe against an uneven stone, listened, heard a scratching noise just beneath his room. Unfortunately his window was open at the top instead of the bottom, and he couldn't see out without pushing it up. It stuck and then sprang suddenly: hence that noise of Judgment Day. And when he could look out, the burglar was legging it for the shrubs along the drive. By the time we'd discovered the drawing-room to be hermetically sealed and all the heirlooms safe, Toms and two of the maids had come down, and we packed them off again before we went up to mother, concluded that there'd be no more hostilities that night, and retired to our respective cradles. I was just in bed when the clock struck one."
Ann told her tale lightly, and Tolefree took it lightly. But the relation of times could not be mistaken. It was just over an hour's walk from Polventor to Tresneven.
"Did Mr. Waverton take a gun to the job?" Tolefree asked.
"No," said Ann; "he'd nothing more lethal with him than a pair of slippers."
"Foolhardy," said Tolefree. "We must persuade him to remember his gun next time."
While we sat there talking about it, Tolefree's call came through. He disappeared into the study and was engaged with London for a long time. Then Ann opened up the dicky of her car, and Angwin and I sat behind her and Tolefree on the drive to Polventor.
There, of course, the adventure of the beech tree had to be served up once more. Ann had not exaggerated the nervousness of Waverton and her mother. Mrs. Carberry begged Tolefree to throw up the inquiry, leave it in the hands of the police, and get out of danger at once. Waverton dotted all her i's and crossed her t's. But he seemed to have a melancholy conviction that Tolefree would do no such thing. He said Tolefree was one of those fellows who were like dogs with bones—never let go till they'd crunched 'em. Tolefree's own litany was exactly as before. If Mrs. Carberry deliberately withdrew her commission, he'd retire as cheerfully as his disappointment allowed, but he hoped she would not.
"I said three days, Mrs. Carberry. Give me four, and if there's no result by that time, I'll clear out."
"That's four more chances for a shot at you in the dark," said Waverton.
"Yes, but you don't know how elusive I can be. And—have you considered this, Mr. Waverton?—that I'm not the only target?"
"How d'you mean?"
"Well, we've started something and it'll go on. Burst in on someone's peace of mind. Thrown doubt on the comfortable doctrine that Sir William Tolliver committed suicide, and that now he's out of sight he'll be out of mind. For the moment, I'm the fly in the ointment, and I've got to get my quietus. But suppose I suddenly fade away, will the revolver artist and tree-climbing specialist be satisfied that Polventor has given him up? It seems unlikely to me."
"I see," said Waverton slowly. "Louise—you'd better—— But I know you won't. Good God!—and this is England! All this creeping about and shooting up—why, it's as bad as the Rand in the old days."
"I was asking Miss Carberry if you carried a gun when you went after your burglar this morning," said Tolefree. "I expect you've had some practice in quick drawing?"
As he said this, Tolefree turned from Waverton to give me a challenging look straight in the eye.
Waverton shook his head.
"No—worse luck! I never had much stomach for shooting. In fact, I only shot once in my life, and then not quick enough, or I'd not have had this."
He pulled up his right sleeve, and displayed a scar eight inches long on the front of his fore-arm.
"Guy!" exclaimed Mrs. Carberry.
"I was a split second behind the other fellow. I've disliked pistols ever since. Still, there's one somewhere in my kit, and it'll be on view to-night, I assure you. But that won't help you, Tolefree, if you're at Tresneven."
"It wouldn't, but I have my own," said Tolefree. "Also, who knows where I may be to-night? But now, let's have a council of war—that is, if you're not going to drum me out of the regiment, Mrs. Carberry?"
"Mother!" Ann exclaimed, "he's laughing at us. You don't really think, do you, Guy, there's anyone in Carnmenellis clever enough to shoot Mr. Tolefree if he decides not to be shot? Open the council of war, Mr. Tolefree. But first tell us—you've finally made up your mind that Uncle Bill's death was not a suicide?"
"Dangerous to jump at conclusions," said Tolefree. "I'd rather say the balance of probability is that someone else shot him. I can see two people who might have done it, but at present I've insufficient evidence of motive if either of them did. Ridgway for one: his conduct was queer, inexplicable, but hardly that of a murderer. There's one thing I must discover about Ridgway. But pass on to Gannett. A poor type. Sneak-thief type. Now, Mr. Waverton—you have it in mind that Gannett was the man who tried to break in here last night?"
"Looks so," said Waverton.
"And that, if so, it was probably Gannett who tried to enter my room an hour or so after? Well, it seems to me quite certain that the man who was responsible for what Miss Carberry calls the shemozzle at Polventor just before one o'clock was the man who climbed Mr. Angwin's beech tree at half-past two. As you so justly observed, Miss Ann, he dislikes me violently, and the only reason for my unpopularity with him is the fact that I've shown so much curiosity about the death of Sir William Tolliver. I think a flawless syllogism could possibly be made out of it, only I haven't time. The conclusion is that this man is the murderer or the employee of the murderer, if, indeed, Sir William was murdered. Angwin, we are on the track of a murderer who is suffering the very extremity of fear, is therefore highly dangerous, and must be trapped without delay."
Who was it?
Tolefree's tone had changed from light to grave. He spoke almost as though he might lay his hands on the murderer at any minute. But it seemed that, though he had constructed the framework of a theory, he had no figures to fill it in.
Gannett? Yes—but if Gannett was a candidate, on the evidence, for that role, so also was Ridgway. And where was Gannett's motive? Tolefree did not think the grievance of his imprisonment a strong enough motive. But was there somebody behind Gannett?
"Who could be behind him?" Mrs. Carberry asked.
"I've been hearing a great deal in the last two days about a Mr. Penhaligon," said Tolefree; "yet I don't seem to realize him. He's Gannett's employer."
"That mutt!" Ann exclaimed. "A silly, vain man and all that—and he didn't like Uncle Bill. Uncle Bill was so contemptuous of him and his little lordling ways! But I suppose he's a gentleman of sorts."
"Ann—I entirely disagree with you," said Mrs. Carberry with a bridling air. "He's not the most primitive instinct of a gentleman. Guy—you know he's not." Waverton hemmed and hawed.
"Well—yes—I suppose. But, Louise, this is another matter—a serious matter. If Penhaligon's going to be dragged into this——"
"Why should we worry? I think you ought to tell Mr. Tolefree. He wants information about Penhaligon."
"But, Louise, it's impossible that Penhaligon could have——"
Waverton wagged a hand.
Three of us looked bepuzzled at the two middle-aged lovers side by side on a settee vaguely disputing about Penhaligon—Waverton in his large, florid way and Mrs. Carberry in a state of flushing indignation at something we did not understand.
"Oh—cut out the argument, you two!" said Ann, in her sharpest voice. "What's the mystery, mother?"
"No mystery at all, Ann, but something very unpleasant that happened last year. Guy—I'm going to tell Mr. Tolefree."
"All right, Louise."
Waverton sighed himself back into a corner of the couch.
"It's about poor Ada Lanherne," Mrs. Carberry began.
Before she came to an end, Tolefree had the vital clue to the Tolliver affair.
For complicated reasons, we had heard nothing so far of Miss Lanherne in the Tolliver case; but the chief reason was that we had obtained our facts from Angwin, and Angwin was abroad at the vital time—the previous September. In that month only the servants inhabited Polventor. Mrs. Carberry and her daughter were in Scotland; Tolliver was in London; Waverton at his home in Penzance. The accident that he had run up to Polventor on and off in August for a day's fishing alone brought Ada Lanherne into the limelight.
She was the daughter of a close friend of Tolliver's, Professor Lanherne, of the chemistry school in London University. A charming girl, brilliant brains, older than Ann, who had arrived at school in her last term, but had just enough acquaintance with her to make of her a heroine. But Miss Lanherne's brilliance was the hectic blooming of a feeble constitution. She became ill after the death of her father, and last year was making a slow convalescence when Tolliver arranged with the tenant of his seaside place at Treneglos to be her host for several weeks. She made what seemed a good recovery, and went away; but failed again, and in June she died in a nursing-home at Exeter.
That was the skeleton of the story.
The first surprise Mrs. Carberry sprung on us was the close friendship of the girl with Ridgway. It seemed absurd, she said, but was in fact quite comprehensible. Ridgway had in his younger days been intimately acquainted with Professor Lanherne and his family, and had known Ada as an infant.
When the story reached this point, I stole a look at Tolefree. If his mind went back, as mine did, to the portrait over Ridgway's desk and the look in Ridgway's tragic eyes, he gave no sign. I said no word. We were all waiting for Penhaligon to come into the picture.
He arrived in an ugly way. Miss Lanherne, growing stronger, making longer and longer walks among the hills and combes. Penhaligon meeting her, dogging her, flirting with her. Seen, to his astonishment, by Waverton. Seen, to his apoplectic rage, by Ridgway. An affair—a sickening affair between a married man nearly old enough to be her father and a girl who, according to Mrs. Carberry, was always above herself, living on her nerves, craving excitement, with a note in her conduct of "Let's eat and drink and be merry, for to-morrow we die!"
And then in some way Tolliver got to hear of it.
"Not from you, Mr. Waverton?" Tolefree remarked.
No, said Waverton; he had only a slight acquaintance with Miss Lanherne. It was Penhaligon who stirred his bile—would have done whoever the girl had been. But since that time Tolliver had lost all his former humorous contempt for Penhaligon, and replaced it with an active dislike, and relations between Polventor and Rosneven had been more strained than ever.
"Sir William was fond of Miss Lanherne?" Tolefree asked.
"As the daughter of an old friend," said Mrs. Carberry, "and a girl who needed sympathy about her health. Yes—very fond of her in that way. Poor Ada! And William hated—well, all that sort of thing."
"I see," said Tolefree.
Penhaligon was fully in the picture.
RIGHT in the picture, undoubtedly....
But I had the vision of a fatuous Don Juan rather than of what I will call an executive of murder. A man of the Gannett type, it seemed to me, would want a stronger personality to hold up his arms. I thought Miss Carberry was of the same opinion, and perhaps Tolefree, though he listened attentively to the story and took it seriously. It had two sequels. First there was a little adventure of my own. Tolefree wanted to spend the rest of the morning in another look at the gorge, and suggested that I should hunt up some excuse for going to see Penhaligon, pump anything I could out of him, and report upon him.
"Can't you get him to witness an affidavit? Or apply for a summons against Angwin? Or something?"
The pretext finally took the form of an affidavit on an entirely fictitious shipping dispute invented ad hoc, which I drew up as best how in Tolliver's library. Meanwhile, Angwin had rung up Rosneven and made an appointment for me at noon. He said Penhaligon was startled (as he well might be) at receiving a request from Tresneven, but the fact that Mr. Angwin's guest had an address in Moorgate Street, E.C., seemed to impress him.
With the pretended affidavit in my pocket, I set out along the Carnmenellis road, and walked up the steep little drive to Rosneven at the appointed time.
I don't know why I had expected something very different of both Rosneven and its owner. Probably because of Angwin's account of an age-old tribal feud revived by a medieval count atavistically born into the twentieth century. And because of those names. Certainly there was a picture in my mind of a dwelling which would deserve the lovely name of Rosneven, and "Penhaligon" seemed to have an onomatopoetic bigness. Whereas, in fact, Rosneven was no medieval stronghold but hardly more than a respectable farm-house, and Penhaligon was a little whipper-snapper of a man with the air of a rural petit-maître and no particular parts that I could discover. Both he and his residence were inadequate to their names, and inappropriate to the gorgeous green romance of the little valley that contained them.
A maid-servant showed me into the dingy room that served Penhaligon for an office, a place with a worn canvas floor-covering, two yellow chairs, and a yellow table with a Testament and Stone's Justices' Manual lying on it. The maid took my card to her master, who presently arrived, brushed past me, and seated himself in the larger of the two chairs.
"Mr. Farrar? Affidavit?" he piped in a high alto, his long black moustache wagging up and down with the syllables, and drawing attention to itself by carrying on one end a noticeable deposit from whatever beverage Mr. Penhaligon had recently dipped it in.
Not a pleasant type, this rustic cockalorum. I felt like picking him up by the ends of his moustache and putting him on the mat. However, it was my job to get at the inside and not to worry about the outside of Mr. Penhaligon.
The farce of the swearing and the signing of the affidavit having been played to its appointed end, I prepared to get on social terms with him. I said I supposed in his office of magistrate he had a lot of this sort of work to do. Quite obviously he hadn't, but it proved a good opening. He preened himself: yes, he never failed in the discharge of his duties as a Justice of the Peace. Not that in these degenerate days the position of a landowner and a magistrate was held in proper esteem. Far from it.
"I don't know whether you read the Spectator, Mr.—er—Farrar"—he cocked an eye at my card—"but if you do perhaps you noticed recently a writer quoting Coke?"
A demon of impropriety seized me for a passing moment.
"Oh!" said I; "has it gone up?"
The blasphemy unexpectedly played into my hands: it gave Mr. Penhaligon just that sense of superiority which he needed to come into full bloom. With tolerant pity he explained:
"Coke—I mean the great lawyer, Coke on Lyttleton, you know?—I quoted him."
"Ah, yes—Coke," said I, "upon Lyttleton. Indeed?"
"Yes—quoted him—in the Spectator. Said, 'The whole Christian world hath not the like office as Justice of the Peace'—Coke said."
If there was in the whole Christian world another Justice of the Peace like this...
"Ah, true," said I. "Seventeenth century—very different atmosphere, more dignity, more consideration for rank and station."
That set him off. I saw the Penhaligon of Miss Carberry's vision. He almost blew up on the subject of rank, birth, breeding, blood—that cheap little swab. Youth in these days, he said, showed no respect for either. It had no manners and fewer morals. The vulgarity of young men and the audacity of young women was only matched by the pretensions of upstarts who called themselves intellectuals...
Three minutes of this...
"But what are we to expect, Mr. Farrar, when there's no sense of solidarity or loyalty among the landed classes themselves?"
Getting warm!
I murmured something about the decline of loyalties and the flattening out of classes. Then I diverted him to Rosneven. A charming valley, a perfectly fascinating and extremely fishy-looking river: I supposed he had extensive riparian rights.
"My land runs with Polventor; we divide the river," said he.
"Polventor? I was hearing something of Polventor. Sir William Tolliver's place, I believe?"
He nodded, frowning.
"I say! It must have been in the valley above here that he—— Did you——? Terrible business for you—such close neighbours—friends, no doubt——"
"It was terrible enough," said Penhaligon. "But Tolliver and I were not friendly. He was not my type," he added loftily.
So he disposed of Tolliver till Judgment Day!...
This jackanapes counted among Miss Carberry's "possibles" as a murderer of Tolliver; but the impression he gave me was that if a man of Tolliver's stamp had barked at him he'd have run a mile. Penhaligon as a murderer was a grotesque impossibility. But I had to remember the talk at Polventor.
"By the way," said I, "Sir William Tolliver was, I think, a friend of a man I used to know—Professor Lanherne, in Gower Street. Did you ever hear of him?"
"Yes—I heard of him."
"Ah, then you'll be able to tell me something I don't quite understand. You doubtless know the quaint photographer's shop in Carnmenellis?"
"Ridgway's?—yes."
"When I called in there yesterday I was surprised to see a very fine photograph of Professor Lanherne's daughter, Ada. Did you know her?—a lovely girl!"
"I met her."
Penhaligon's expansiveness had collapsed. He shut up like a clam.
"Seeing her portrait in that queer place seemed extraordinary to me. I suppose she must have been on a visit to Carnmenellis?"
"She did stay—recovering from an illness, they said—at Treneglos with old Menhennick—he's a tenant of Tolliver's, or was—just a seaside shack a little way down the coast."
"Poor girl," said I, "she didn't last long. Tragic thing—her father's death and then hers—so soon?"
"Yes—and then Tolliver's," said Penhaligon.
Tone and gesture took me aback. The little man almost spat out the words, his face contorted for a mere instant with a spasm of rage. Then, as though he recalled himself to the fact that I was a stranger, he rose and marched brusquely past me to the door as he had marched in.
"Good morning, Mr.—er——" not even troubling to remember the name.
I found myself walking down the drive of Rosneven a minute later. Penhaligon was to me an utterly new specimen of the human race. I had certainly never encountered one quite so futile or less likely to be capable of committing a murder or of concealing the fact if he did. I felt quite sure of one thing, however: that he hated Tolliver; nearly sure of another: that the cause of his hatred was not confined to a difference of opinion about riparian rights.
The second sequel of Mrs. Carberry's story came after lunch, when Ann drove us down to the point on the coast where Tolliver had built his "seaside shack." It was, in fact, a neat little house sunk in a nook of the cliff beyond Treneglos, built of the stone quarried to make the ledge on which it stood, and looking as if it had grown out of the rock. A boldly romantic spot, two hundred feet above the tide, with a zigzag path cut to give access to the sands of a tiny cove. It looked due west over the Atlantic.
Ann said that formerly, when Tolliver had been a great swimmer, this was his favourite week-end place. Before her mother was widowed and came to Polventor to live, he kept a care-and-maintenance party there on board wages, and spent his leisure at Treneglos. But latterly, he had let the place to Menhennick, an old friend who had retired from farming in the back-country after the war.
We left the car inside the gates of a little lodge at the top of the cliff and walked down a winding way to the house. The old gentleman who received us on the platform in front of his cliff castle was to me something new in farmers. I judged him to be over sixty—a tall, spare old man, very dark, with a thick thatch of black hair, a pair of bushy eyebrows under which his black eyes gleamed, a high colour on his cheekbones, a closely cut black beard and a clean-shaven upper lip, as blue as indigo. He wore a brown coat with short tails, of a fashion unknown to me, a bright canary-coloured waistcoat, and tight grey trousers. With his round steel-framed spectacles, he resembled nothing so much as a parrot of great age and ineffable wisdom.
He addressed Ann as "my dear," and Angwin as "Arnold," and received their friends with a grave and reserved courtesy. He inquired whether we would go into the house to take tea, or whether Jenefer should bring it to us, set chairs for the party, closed the two volumes which lay on the wicker table where he had been reading, put away his spectacles, looked round upon us, and finally, having presumably determined that Ann was the pleasantest sight, beamed upon her.
"We came over, Mr. Menhennick," she said, "because these two gentlemen, who're staying with Arnold, are interested in Ada."
Menhennick's glance was jerked round to Tolefree. He did not answer for a perceptible second. Then:
"Ah, yes—Ada. Dear maid! Poor Ada."
"We understood Miss Lanherne was here on a visit last year," said Tolefree. "How long did she stay with you, Mr. Menhennick?"
"Seven weeks and three days," said the old man slowly.
Tolefree, if he felt any surprise at this strange particularity, gave no sign of it.
"A grand holiday in such quarters," said he. "It must have done her a world of good."
"It should have"—with the same deliberation.
"Yes, indeed," Tolefree nodded. "It should have, as you say."
None of us could have imagined two minutes before, not even Tolefree himself, the weird atmosphere into which we were immediately to plunge. He and Menhennick held each other's eyes for a moment. Then Tolefree broke off and looked out over the sea. Turning again, he held out his hand towards Angwin and Miss Carberry as if for their assent, and said:
"No one has mentioned Mr. Farrar and myself to you, I suppose, or the reason why we are staying at Tresneven?"
"Just a moment, sir——"
An ancient dame appeared from the house with a tea-tray. Menhennick removed his books from the table.
"Leave it there, Jenefer. Miss Ann will attend to it."
Ann pulled her chair to the table to pour tea.
"Yes," said Menhennick. "You have been mentioned to me. I have heard that you're at Arnold's for a certain purpose."
He spoke with unfailing deliberation, in a brogue I shall not try to reproduce, and with a curious uplifted singing effect instead of a cadence at the end of his phrases.
"I thought possibly you had. And do you approve of the purpose?" asked Tolefree.
Menhennick bent to the ground and picked up the larger of his two books.
"I was reading just now in this book," said he, "that God shall bring everything into judgment, with every secret thing, whether it be good, or whether it be evil. Yes, sir, I approve of the purpose. Ann, my dear——"
Miss Carberry had the teapot poised in mid-air and, staring at him, was pouring tea into the tray.
"Oh!" she cried. "What a mess!"
Angwin went to her aid.
"Mr. Menhennick," said Tolefree, "when we came here I had not the slightest intention of saying what I'm now going to say. You compel me to speak. I cannot pretend to a man like you to be anything but what I am. Neither of us ever saw Miss Lanherne in the flesh. I was asked by Mrs. Carberry to make some inquiry into the circumstances surrounding the death of Sir William Tolliver, about which she is not satisfied——"
"Ah," said Menhennick.
"Nor is Miss Carberry satisfied."
"Nor am I satisfied, sir."
"We have run into a chain of incidents that leads back to Miss Lanherne's visit to Treneglos last year. If you could help us——"
"Help you?" Menhennick shook his head. "I don't know. I'm an old man, a solitary man, sir, with no experience of the world. If I put myself forward in this, I'm liable to bungle. A mysterious, complicated thing like this——"
"Mr. Menhennick," said Tolefree, leaning forward to him, "you were reading just now the words of a very wise man. Every secret thing, whether it be good or evil—— You believe it?"
"Yes, I believe it. Sooner or later——"
"Very well. Then, if we can assist to bring it to judgment?"
"Ann, my dear——"
"Yes, Mr. Menhennick?" She ceased to busy herself with the tea-things and put a hand on his arm.
"It's all gone through that little head of yours, has it? About bringing it to judgment?"
"Yes, in fact it was I who insisted on it."
"You know what you're saying, Ann? Whatever the consequences——?"
"Yes. I know."
Menhennick leaned back in his chair and the black beard sunk against the yellow waistcoat. He seemed to peer through the bush of his eyebrows at Tolefree.
"I've felt the day would come," said he. "But not so soon. Well—how can I help clever gentlemen like you?"
"This way," said Tolefree. "By answering a few questions I'll put to you—so far as you feel free to answer."
"Aye. Will you ask?"
"Yes. First, when Miss Lanherne came to Treneglos in April last year, it was at the suggestion of Sir William Tolliver?"
"He wrote to me."
"She was recovering from an illness. Polventor being closed, and Mrs. Carberry and her daughter being away, it was a very natural thing for him to suggest. She stayed with you for seven weeks. Spend most of it here about the house?"
"All of it for the first three weeks. Then, when she picked up strength, she'd go walking."
"Any friends of hers in the neighbourhood?"
"Only one particular friend, as Ann knows. It was Ridgway."
"Yes—we have a line on Ridgway, Mr. Menhennick. Queer sort of friendship—such a very lovely girl and such an eccentric man. But quite comprehensible. He'd been a fellow-student with Professor Lanherne at King's College, friendly with his family—known the girl as a little child. She saw a good deal of Ridgway?"
"Yes, quite a lot—in Carnmenellis. And Ridgway would walk out here and sit with her by the hour, just as we're sitting now, talking of her childhood, and her father, and her future."
"Very fond of her?"
"He worshipped her, like an idol."
"Only one particular friend, and that was Ridgway. Any others—acquaintances, say?"
"Yes—several. Mr. Penhaligon, Mr. Waverton, Mr. Baripper——"
"Andrew Baripper!"
Tolefree, not often startled, stiffened as from a galvanic shock.
"Baripper?" he repeated. "I'd no idea—was he in these parts then?"
"He came here," said Menhennick shortly.
Tolefree looked across to the girl.
"Did you know Mr. Baripper had been down here, Miss Carberry?"
But it was quite evident that Ann didn't. She was staring hard at Menhennick. She shook her head.
Tolefree took from his breast-pocket a little notebook and flicked over the pages till he came to an entry.
"Baripper a man of this county?" he asked.
"Born not far inland," said Menhennick.
"Ah—then he'd have connections here?
"Not now. But you needn't ask. He came to see Ada."
Tolefree seemed nonplussed. He looked round as if for enlightenment. Every face was blank save Menhennick's.
"Perhaps," he began, "you'd tell us—the circumstances—if you know——"
"I'll go back," said Menhennick. "It all happened in the last ten days Ada was here, but it began before Baripper came. First I heard of it was from Ridgway. He burst in one afternoon in a terrible rage. Ada had gone out in the morning, to walk up to Polventor hill—took her lunch with her. Seemingly Ridgway was out that way with his camera, taking pictures. Came across Ada and Penhaligon sitting on a boulder, smoking cigarettes. Watched them in his secret way, trailed them down through Rosneven valley, lost them. Came along here. She hadn't got back. I persuaded him to go away: I was afraid he'd lose his head if he saw her then. She came home merry as a lark. I asked her if she'd seen any folks. She told me she'd met Mr. Penhaligon up on the moor, and what a comic character he was. Same thing next day—only Ridgway didn't come here. And next day. This time I walked up over in the afternoon myself, and met Ada and Ridgway coming home. He was black as thunder, and she was flushed and irritated. He went off without saying anything. She told me he was a dear old thing, but rather trying. Two days after, she came back early, and said to me, 'I wish you'd go up and see that those two lunatics don't kill each other.' I went up to the road, and not far away from my gate, I met Mr. Waverton and saw Ridgway striding off on the Carnmenellis road. Mr. Waverton said, 'You'd better keep an eye on that crank Ridgway, Mr. Menhennick, or he'll have the country up in arms.' I asked him what it was all about, and he said, well, it was rather insulting to Miss Lanherne, but he'd heard Ridgway had actually gone to Rosneven and told Mrs. Penhaligon to keep her silly little husband indoors and away from decent young ladies if she didn't want to have his face spoiled."
"If I may interrupt," said Tolefree, "you didn't think Penhaligon was——"
"Very hard to exercise Christian charity about Mr. Penhaligon," Menhennick said. "He's as God made him—a conceited born fool. If a good-looking woman was dying with laughter at him, he'd preen himself like a peacock. A dose of Ridgway—but I'm getting off the track."
"My fault," said Tolefree. "You're coming to Baripper?"
"Presently. I believe Mr. Baripper was in Carnmenellis a week before he came here. But I saw Sir William first."
"Tolliver! How d'you mean?"
"Sir William came—let me see, the Saturday night—two days after Mr. Waverton had spoken to me."
"Did you know of this, Angwin? No—of course, you were away. Did you, Miss Carberry?" Tolefree asked. "Or your mother?"
"Not a word," said Ann. "Sure, Mr. Menhennick? Uncle Bill certainly never let on that he'd been down. Guy never said anything about it—or the servants. Surely——"
"No mistake, Ann," Menhennick declared. "Mr. Waverton wouldn't have known: he went away home in his car the same day he had his tiff with Ridgway. Sir William never went to Polventor. He came straight here in the station taxi the Saturday evening, and he stayed with me till the Monday morning. And it was the Sunday Mr. Baripper happened in on him."
"Tell us," said Tolefree,—"all of it."
"I wish I could, but I can't. I don't know it. I don't see how anyone can tell you except Mr. Baripper, for Sir William and Ada are both dead. You see, Ann—it was no business of mine, was it? I mean, what brought your uncle here in that sudden, secret fashion? And I couldn't ask. He and Ada went out all Saturday evening, came back very late, and he looked solemn and upset, and she was all anyhow—didn't seem too pleased with anything. Sunday morning they were here, talking, very serious, when Mr. Baripper walked in on them. It seemed to me Ada was glad of the interruption and Sir William wasn't. I heard him shout out, 'What the devil are you doing here?' And then I went away quiet, and walked into Carnmenellis to church. Jenefer said they stayed here all the morning. In the afternoon, Sir William went out and left her and Mr. Baripper here. He passed me in the house, and said, 'Shan't be late, Menhennick; I'm going to Rosneven.'"
"Gee!" cried Angwin.
"He was back by six o'clock. Mr. Baripper and Ada had stayed out till it got chilly. She was playing the piano in the parlour when Sir William came in, and Mr. Baripper sitting in the arm-chair listening. Sir William took him outside and they walked up and down here, arguing hard, till suppertime. After supper they went away. I know where they went—to Ridgway's. Ada stayed in all the evening, looking glum. She went to bed before Sir William got home. Monday morning he went off early. He said to me, 'Miss Lanherne will be returning to London on Wednesday, Menhennick,' and thanked me for putting her up. That afternoon Mr. Baripper turned up again. He took Ada out for a walk, and didn't return with her. Tuesday morning she packed her things and said she was going to Carnmenellis to get a car to take her to the station. I said I thought she was to stay another day, and she told me she'd changed her mind. She went off by the midday train. Wednesday morning, Mr. Baripper came with a car to fetch her, and he used some unbiblical language when he found she'd gone."
Menhennick had come to the end of his answer to Tolefree. Its revelations apparently astonished Ann Carberry more than anyone else. She sat by her tea-tray staring at the old fellow with her eyebrows raised. Tolefree broke a silence of a full minute.
"A mysterious, complicated thing, you said, Mr. Menhennick. But you've theorized about it since?"
"Idle thoughts—only for myself," he replied.
"Yes," said Tolefree. "But they mayn't be so idle. Mr. Baripper—should you say he was interested in Miss Lanherne—beyond the ordinary, I mean?"
"I should say," the old man declared emphatically, "he was in love with Ada."
"Baripper!—in love?" Angwin exclaimed.
"Such miracles do happen, even in Capel Court, Angwin," said Tolefree with a chuckle. "The question is, Mr. Menhennick, was she in love with him?"
"I'm no hand at reading a woman's mind," Menhennick replied. "Quite friendly—very friendly."
"You saw that. But Tolliver—should you think Tolliver realized what was doing?"
"You never could tell what Sir William knew and didn't know. He didn't wear his heart on his sleeve—eh, Ann?"
"No one better at concealing his feelings when he didn't want to show them," Ann agreed.
"You were at Polventor the Sunday evening before Sir William's death, Mr. Menhennick," said Tolefree. "So was Mr. Baripper. There was no talk, to your knowledge, about Miss Lanherne?"
"No, the poor girl had been dead some time then."
"Of course. And there aren't any of those idle thoughts you'd like to tell us?"
"None," he answered with great decision.
"But if any other question occurs to me in the next day or two——"
"Certainly," said Menhennick.
We took the neglected tea and our leave.
WE had gone hunting Penhaligon and struck the scent of Baripper. So it seemed to me. More, we had a new aspect of Tolliver which might add to the complications of Tolefree's problem. In the search for character, motive and probability of which Tolefree and Pierce had spoken on Saturday night, he had up to this point, apparently, found only secondary characters, inadequate motives and weak probabilities.
But Ada Lanherne looked like a real clue. She brought in strong characters, one of the most powerful of all motives, and the likeliest probability.
Tolefree's account, when we returned, of the talk with Menhennick staggered both Mrs. Carberry and Waverton. Waverton would not, he told us, have put so much on the Penhaligon affair but for the incident which occurred on the last day of his fishing, when, on his way back, he came across Ridgway and Ada Lanherne in the road at Treneglos. He stopped to speak to them, and got himself involved in a mad scene, Ridgway shouting his suspicions, hectoring the girl, threatening Penhaligon. He had thought of it generally as one more display of Ridgway's lunacy. But if both Tolliver and Baripper had found it worth while to come down from London to take a hand—well, that might put another complexion on it.
"I find it easy," said Tolefree, "to account for Sir William. Not so for Andrew Baripper. Every hour away from London for a man like that costs him pretty stiff. Was it known that he had so strong a fancy for Miss Lanherne?"
"Not to me," said Mrs. Carberry.
"Not to me," added her daughter.
Tolefree waited for some enlargement of these denials. It did not come.
"Miss Lanherne had great beauty. Could not have failed to attract many men. Herself did she show any, shall I say, preference?"
"Ada," said Mrs. Carberry, "was, I understand, a very modern girl, exceedingly independent, highly educated—looked to a career. Advanced, you know——"
"I see," said Tolefree, and left it at that. "Well, we shall get on Baripper's trail somehow, no doubt."
That seemed just a casual banality and not the prophecy it proved to be. We left Angwin at Polventor. Tolefree said he wanted a brisk walk and the jaunt across the moor to Tresneven would aid both of us to digest a Polventor dinner. In fact our position at Polventor was rather wearing—interlopers in a situation that naturally tended to be diatomic, except when sheer business was doing.
Both the diatoms now seemed quite sympathetic about our digestion. Mrs. Carberry did raise a feeble demurrer. She had not lost her sense of responsibility for Tolefree's safety—wondered whether it would be wise for Angwin to drive us back, "in case," as she said. Tolefree reassured her.
"I'll wager you a pair of gloves against one of your Maréchal Neils that our elusive friend won't try to puncture me to-night, Mrs. Carberry," said he. "Wish he would—though it would mean the end of my job."
"Good Lord! You must be tired of life!" cried Angwin.
"Oh, I mean that I should hand you your solution and be off by the first train to-morrow. And I haven't seen half as much of Cornwall yet as I want to."
Waverton tut-tutted at this levity.
"My dear fellow," said he, "I've seen so many men banking on their luck——"
All the same, they were undoubtedly relieved by Tolefree's confidence.
Ten o'clock on a late July evening. The sun had set just before nine. There was light enough to show the road across the rise and the outlines of the hills. As we passed through the gateway of Polventor, Tolefree was discussing Baripper, the new element which had come so suddenly into his problem.
"Suddenly, but subtly," said I.
"That's so, Farrar," said he. "Subtly's the word. You've twigged it? And how? My friend, there's no fathoming the female mind. What did the old Frenchman say? Women are never without some arrière-pensée."
"But," I reminded him, "Menhennick's tale really surprised the young one: I was looking at her."
"No doubt. Astonished that facts leaped up so soon to back her intuition. But keep it in mind, Farrar: how did we ever come to tumble across Menhennick? Only through them. Those two!—they weren't going to be stalled off from hinting at something they felt in their bones to be true simply because a mere man like Waverton thought it dam' silly. Now—Baripper: what's he doing in this galley? The great Andrew, one of the minor deities of Capel Court—chasing a minx like the late Miss Ada Lanherne?"
"Minx?"
"Well—perhaps I do her injustice. A modern young woman with enough of the minx in her to get a kick out of a flirtation with a prize ass like Penhaligon, and also to convert an old sobersides like Tolliver into her galley-slave. We'll consider the case of Tolliver later on. But Baripper? What's he? Forty-five?"
"Don't know. Forty to fiftyish. But that's all the more reason——"
"Perhaps you're right. And there's his millions. But somehow that fine old Puritan—didn't he look as if he'd stepped right out the Arminian Magazine?—he rather impressed me. If Baripper was really struck by lightning, and he found anything he thought fishy——"
Tolefree's reflections tailed off.
At this point we were passing parallel with the verge of the Tolgerth gorge, on our left a quarter of a mile away. The rock peaks made a jagged black outline against the sky.
"That's where Waverton was standing when he heard the shot," said Tolefree. "I'd like to go and see what it looks like now. Take us a quarter of an hour longer. Are you game?"
"Of course. Why?"
"An eye-measurement, that's all."
Ten minutes afterwards I was wondering whether Tolefree had a cat's eye and really could see things concealed from me, or whether he had private information and failed to keep good faith. In fact, both ideas were wrong. But it seemed almost impossible that one of them should not be right.
We turned off the road into a grassy track meandering between clumps of gorse and heather, making for the rocks. Perhaps a hundred yards from the opening at the head of the path down to the river, he gave me a violent shove which sent me headlong to the ground, and fell beside me into a bunch of bracken.
"Sh—sh!" he hissed.
I smothered what Mr. Menhennick would have called the unbiblical language that surged into my throat.
"Keep your head down," Tolefree whispered. "He's there."
Himself he wriggled forward a few feet among the stiff stems of the ferns and peered from the edge of the clump. I followed suit. From here the V-shaped cleft in the rampart was visible. A shadow passed across it, melted into the deeper shadow of the rocks.
It seemed as though, despite Tolefree's confident wager, the meeting with his elusive friend was about to take place. Had he seen us? Had he perhaps witnessed our departure from the house and trailed us at a safe distance? Would there presently be a streak of fire from that mass of shadow? Unlikely that in such a light, even if he had marked us down, he could do any damage with a pistol shot at such a range. But I felt Tolefree moving, saw him prop his right wrist on his left, and guessed that his eye was cocked along the sight of his revolver.
And then, almost at once, the streak of fire appeared. I blinked!...
But no sound came, and the streak did not disappear. It wavered about, lit up the rocks in the little pass, and finally dropped out of sight.
"Ye gods!" muttered Tolefree.
A torchlight—someone finding his way down to the river by torchlight. A poacher? I had read of men who carried lights to dazzle salmon and spears to kill them. Not that there were likely to be salmon in that short and torrential river...
"What's the distance? Tolefree whispered. "A hundred? Less. Can you sprint to cover in, say, twenty seconds?"
"Some poacher, I guess," said I, in the same tone.
"Maybe. Perhaps friend Gannett?"
Gannett hadn't occurred to me.
"Worth while, Tolefree?"
"Worth everything!" he answered. "Ready? One big bolt—for the nearest rock. As little noise as you can."
He was up and started. Our quick footsteps were almost soundless. In less than twenty seconds we were among the rocks on the left of the opening, and there hardly distinguishable to one another.
Tolefree pressed me back; himself stole farther into the jumble of boulders. I could just make out his head and shoulders as he peeped over the edge of the cliff, at about the point where Waverton must have looked down into the gorge. He returned.
"He's not gone down," he said in my ear. "I hear him over there—at the head of the path. May be stalking us. I'm going to inch along. Follow if you can. We'll get him."
That was for me a slow and stumbling progress, with nervous explosions in every limb whenever a foot slipped—and there were many slips. But the rattle of the river below sounded loud enough here to cloak all small sounds. Tolefree went steadily on. We rose by degrees to the left-hand peak of the V. Tolefree went down on all fours, climbed to the edge and was still. In a painful minute I was beside him, lifted my head—and was still too.
Beneath us the little pass wound through the rocks to the edge of the ravine. On it a circle of light moved slowly along the ground, pausing every yard or so. Occasionally it was occluded by the figure of the man who directed it, bending, peering. As we watched, he quartered the whole of the ground to the point where the path turned down towards the river. Then he straightened himself, lifted his left arm, threw the light on a wristwatch, and for an instant it flashed across his face.
Unmistakable his bold, dark, clean-shaven face and the horn-rimmed spectacles he always wore, familiar to every reader of the fashionable picture papers—Mr. Andrew Baripper, the magnate of Capel Court.
I held my breath.
Baripper, manifestly unconscious of any presence, switched off his torch, and immediately became only a deeper shadow among shadows. He stood for a moment or two, then struck a match and lit a cigarette. The match shot to the ground, went out; the glowing cigarette-end bobbed by and out of sight; then all the trace of Andrew Baripper left to us was the scent of his tobacco.
Tolefree allowed two or three minutes to pass without moving. Then he raised himself and clambered to the edge of the rocks.
"All clear, Farrar," he called.
I joined him. A tiny shower of sparks as he flipped the end of his cigarette betokened Baripper already some distance from us towards the road. For a little while we detected his moving figure. Then the darkening landscape swallowed him up.
By mute consent we slithered down by the nearest way from rocks to turf and resumed our walk to Tresneven.
"You know," said Tolefree, "that's the pattest illustration I've ever seen of the warning that if you talk of an angel you'll see his wings."
"Capel Court would be tickled to death if it heard you," I told him. "But, candidly, Tolefree, you don't mean to say this is a pure coincidence?"
"What else, then?"
"Why," said I, "if we'd gone along the road without coming across here to get an eye-measurement in the dark——"
Tolefree walked on a while in silence.
"I'd an idea," he said, "that we might find some person in the neighbourhood, Farrar. But it wasn't Baripper I expected. Though, mind you, I'm not astonished. Not at all. Baripper's staying with the vicar. Been there since Saturday night. No reason why he shouldn't be out on a beautiful evening looking for something he can't find."
"What?"
"Ah, well—I'm not a crystal-reader. But you saw yourself."
"I saw he was searching."
"Quite so. He must want something rather badly, for in the ordinary way I'd have pictured him at this moment replete, after a fat dinner, smoking a fat cigar in the padre's best arm-chair, laying down the law on the prospects of the grouse-moors in a fortnight's time or the probable price of dollars tomorrow afternoon. Baripper's presence in these latitudes needs explanation, undoubtedly. We'll try round to-morrow."
Angwin could make nothing of it when he returned to Tresneven, found us sitting with our pipes in his study, and heard the yarn. He got more and more nervous about Tolefree. But Tolefree urged him not to worry.
"I'll have a bet with you if you like—just to double my stake with Mrs. Carberry. A box of cigars to a packet of fags that I'm in no danger whatever and get through without a scratch. Come, now!"
"Well, I'm infernally glad you're so certain, Tolefree. I do worry a bit. But it isn't what's on my mind now. There's a something——"
"About Baripper?"
"No—at least, I suppose not. It's about that girl, Ada Lanherne. You know, she didn't mean anything to me. I never saw her, being abroad last year when she came down here. But I was talking about it with Ann. And then I remembered a thing I forgot to tell you. And it makes a beastly complication. I hadn't thought of it before. And Ann—it knocked her sideways after what she heard from old Menhennick this afternoon."
Angwin spoke with a jerky hesitation: clearly something difficult and unpleasant.
"Well," said Tolefree, "if you think we ought to know—I mean, if it has any bearing on the—ah—commission, so to speak——"
"Seems to me it may have. Anyhow, I'll get it off my chest. So far as I recollect, when I told you about the funeral, and how we came back to the house, and Briscoe read Tolliver's will, I didn't go into details."
"I can tell you exactly what you said: that the will was five years old, and had one codicil made last year. With the exception of personal gifts to people like yourself and Waverton and the parson, some legacies to institutions, and a fund of ten thousand pounds to be invested for Miss Carberry, he left the whole of his estate to his sister, Mrs. Carberry. I think that was all, Farrar?"
"Yes," said I; "that's a summary."
"No doubt it seemed all to me two days ago. But to-day—it seems as if I may have left out the vital thing. The codicil—in the codicil Tolliver bequeathed a thousand pounds to Ada Lanherne, 'orphan daughter of my trusted colleague the late Francis Lanherne, professor of chemistry in the University of London'—something like that. Then, Briscoe said, after the girl died Tolliver wrote that he would take an early opportunity of cancelling the codicil and making some other slight alterations in the will. But he never did."
"Well," said Tolefree, "that's not extraordinary. And in so big an estate a thousand pounds wasn't a thing to get excited about. I don't think it was unnatural that you should forget it. Why does it worry you?"
Angwin fidgeted.
"I told you it was a beastly complication... Tolliver, you know."
But Tolefree did not know.
"If Tolliver came down last summer—said nothing about it to his sister—it might look——"
"I see," said Tolefree, as Angwin stuck in the middle of his sentence. "The idea is that Tolliver had more than a friendly interest in Miss Lanherne? And that Ridgway knew it? And told him the girl was carrying on with Penhaligon? And—well, where do we get then?"
"Yes—where? I don't know about carrying on with Penhaligon. You haven't mentioned the point where Ann and I stick. I mean, Ada going off like that on the Tuesday morning when Baripper was expecting to take her away on the Wednesday. Something funny about that. Don't it suggest that Tolliver—damn it all, Tolefree! I can't get it out. The dates—you see?"
"Dates? You mean dates of Miss Lanherne's visit?—end of August, beginning of September. Haven't got you."
"She died on the 1st June," said Angwin, looking away.
Tolefree took his pipe from his teeth and knocked out the cob. He gave Angwin a long stare.
"Ah!" said he, "a glimmer—just a glimmer. The notion is that after all Tolliver may have committed suicide in—well, say, in a fit of remorse? That it?"
"Yes, damn it!" Angwin fumed. "Guess what a hellish job it was to talk out this with Ann—all innuendo—both of us afraid of it."
"No doubt," said Tolefree. "Most embarrassing. But I suspect that Miss Carberry knew a little more than she'd say to you: for example, that she'd talked it over with her mother."
"I dare say," said Angwin gloomily.
Tolefree shot me a glance, as though to say, "What did I tell you about the wiles of the feminine intellect?"
"It don't strike me," he observed, "that this is bang in the middle of the Tolliver tradition, so to speak, this sort of thing."
"No, it's not. About as like Tolliver as kicking a man in the stomach."
Angwin was relieving pent-up feelings by violence of language.
"But we'd better face it out, hadn't we? I told you Tolliver's bad fit began after he reached Polventor—a day or two after the girl's death. He seemed to get over it suddenly—all in a day, that Sunday before he died. I thought about it a lot all that time while we were assuming that he'd shot himself. It looked to me as if he'd been chewing something over for a fortnight, and on Sunday had, all on the hop, made up his mind about something—sort of found a solution. And to-night Ann remembered that Baripper arrived at Polventor on the Saturday."
"So you're linking all this up—Baripper with the rest? I don't think there's a very water-tight connection," Tolefree said.
"Well, I hope to God there isn't!"
"You're overlooking many things—especially Ridgway's photographs. Keep your eye on them. The germ of this idea about the sudden solution was born in your mind, Angwin, before we knew anything about what really happened on the river that morning. I'll put you out of your misery. Take another wager, my dear fellow. Bet you a bottle of Veuve Clicquot to a glass of beer that Tolliver didn't commit suicide and that I'll prove it."
Tolefree smiled upon him.
"You're a tonic!" cried Angwin.
"There are two men within a few miles of us now," said Tolefree, "who know how Tolliver died; one who thinks he knows, hopes he knows and isn't quite sure; and one who suspects the truth: and he'll be a bit farther on when I've had a very necessary talk with that pillar of the gold standard, Mr. Andrew Baripper." Tolefree got up and yawned. "So I prescribe for all of us at present that we should sleep quietly in our beds, call round in the morning and reassure the people at Polventor, and then look up Mr. Andrew Baripper—if he happens to be still within hail."
WE adopted Tolefree's prescription.
Nothing disturbed the quietness of Tresneven that night. Next morning it was I who drove them over to Polventor. Toms was in the drive again, and opened the gate for us.
"Morning, Toms," Tolefree called out to him. "Found any?"
"Sorry sir. Only mast—not a kernel to be had. Much too late."
"Ah well, thanks all the same, Toms. You might have another look." I drove on. "Toms was looking for some belated beech-nuts for me," he explained. "I had a fancy to make one grow in a pot at Cannon Street; only beech tree in the city of London you know."
"That's a batchy idea, Tolefree," said I.
"Dare say. I often get 'em," he replied, as we drew up at the house.
The purpose of this call was to drop Angwin so that he might put Miss Carberry at ease; but we found the two seniors discussing the same doubts and in a dismal taking about it. Mrs. Carberry had been loath to believe that her brother could possibly be involved in an intrigue so sordid; but Waverton, though he said little, evidently did not share her sense of impossibility. The necessity to tell them of the Baripper affair of the night before launched Tolefree on a rapid repetition of his talk with us. The air cleared. He and I went off to Carnmenellis, leaving the enamoured pairs in much better spirits.
But before we left, Tolefree sprung a surprise on us all. Fortunately I was sufficiently inured to his suddenness to express no surprise myself.
"Sorry I shall have to leave you for a day, Mrs. Carberry," said he as we took our leave. "Urgent affair of a few hours. I'll be back by Friday at the latest—possibly Thursday night."
"Oh, of course—if you must," she answered, a little bleakly. "I was hoping—you raised hopes——"
"Four days, I said, didn't I?" Tolefree smiled. "Friday will be the fourth. Yes—I think in spite of everything I can expect to keep my promise."
"I never met so confident a man!" said Waverton, and looked as if he meant cocksure.
"Oh, well, you know, I can't stake my life on it," Tolefree admitted. "But—another pair of gloves if you like, Mrs. Carberry, or I'll take you up on a new neck-tie, Mr. Waverton."
And on this light-minded note he waved himself away.
A curious thing that the gilded worldling who might be turning the money mill in London should spend even one day in a one-eyed village with a country parson—or it would have been highly curious in the absence of some strong motive. The gilded worldling was, I confess, my conception of Baripper—and it sprang from nothing but a kind of prejudice against the kind of man I supposed him to be; I knew him only by sight and by the newspaper accounts of his doings and his wealth.
Tolefree, it appeared, was better primed.
"Impetuous as ever, Farrar!" he laughed. "General indictments—too easy. Baripper interests me. I'm simply loving the idea of seeing him in the odour of sanctity. But before we get there—let's fix a programme. My sudden decision to take a day's holiday——"
"Mere camouflage, of course," said I.
"Well, I want the idea to be thoroughly propagated that the interfering busybody, Tolefree, has relieved the neighbourhood of his intrusive presence for a little while, and I'm particularly anxious that if any questions are asked at Polventor they shall be answered with conviction. I shall also announce my departure to Mr. Baripper, and again at Tresneven by and by. So that the legend may be well established, you know. But I'll arrange it with you later on. Had we better park here? Marrack says the vicarage is close handy."
We had arrived on the quay. The vicarage proved to be a hundred yards up the hill, alongside a mission chapel—a grey little house with a tiny garden overlooking the roofs of the waterside houses and the harbour.
Before we were well through the gateway we saw the object of our quest: Mr. Andrew Baripper's dark eyes in his large, bold face, looked at us through the round portholes of his spectacles as he sat on a bench in the sunshine beside a spare man in a grey suit with the hall-mark of a clerical collar. Mr. Baripper looked anything but a gilded worldling in his dark blue blazer and grey flannel bags: he could have been dressed like that for seven dollars fifty, as Tolefree afterwards remarked. He smoked a big pipe and looked utterly content—till we came within range of recognition, and then he extracted the pipe from his teeth and his black eyebrows arched up in the same geometrical figure as the rims of his glasses. No one ever registered astonishment more perfectly.
We ascended three steps and passed along a narrow path at the side of the toy lawn. The spare man got up and took three steps to meet us, saying in a pleasant tone:
"Good morning?"
A question and a greeting all in one.
"Mr. Dimott?" said Tolefree. "We owe you apologies for coming unheralded. But I expect that's nothing new to a parish parson."
Mr. Dimott's smile agreed.
"Fact is, we heard Mr. Baripper was staying with you, and I perceive that the rumour is well founded."
Dimott stepped aside as though to disclose our quarry. Being ten feet away, Baripper had heard every word. He rose, booming:
"And what the devil brings you to this part of the world, Tolefree? Mercy, padre! It just slipped out."
Tolefree shook hands.
"You don't know Farrar? He loses money on ships—in Moorgate Street."
"Poor devil!" said Baripper, holding out a hand to me. "Now, padre, these two fellows are Tolefree, who runs an insurance swindle in some back street near St. Paul's, and Farrar—as you've heard. This is the Reverend Claud Dimott, vicar of Carnmenellis, artium magister and all the rest of it. Lovely morning, Tolefree. May we all take a pew, padre?"
Tolefree and I joined them on the bench.
"Now then, Tolefree, deliver the goods. What's it all about? Who d'you think wants one of your rotten insurances down here? And does Farrar believe there's any goof in Carnmenellis ready to buy a ship?"
"Strictly pleasure, Mr. Baripper," said Tolefree. "Farrar and I are on holiday. Staying with Mr. Angwin at Tresneven, Know him?"
"As well as you do, I expect. And that's only just. I saw him at Tolliver's the day before he died, and again at the funeral. Sweet on little Ann, eh?... well, well, fancy the ingenious and philosophical Tolefree leaving the insurance business to go to wrack and ruin while he lounges in the sun at Carnmenellis. Amazing!"
"I might retort on the ingenuous and indispensable Mr. Baripper leaving the pound sterling to inflate itself in Threadneedle Street while he discusses theology in a Cornish garden," said Tolefree.
"You might. And you'd be just as right. We weren't discussing theology, were we, Dimott? Tolefree, can I give him a truthful biography of you?"
Tolefree turned on the bench to meet Baripper's owlish gaze. Then he said:
"You can try."
"Well, Dimott, this chap's a perambulating imposture, well known in the wicked metropolis, which puts up with him because he's useful and a terror to other evil-doers. He's got a dingy little office in Watling Street, where he keeps one boy and two insurance almanacs. He lives on the roof of Cannon Street Station——"
"You said truthful. I do not live on the roof of the station."
Dimott might well feel the puzzled amusement he showed.
"Well, as near as nothing," said Baripper. "By the way, does Farrar know all about you, Tolefree?"
"Everything. He's my father-confessor."
"What an earful he must get every night! But in that case he'll confirm me when I tell Dimott that you spend your days in secret and unmentionable occupations and your nights in trying to prove by the signal lights on the Southern Railway that Einstein's a mutt."
"Photographically truthful," said I.
"But perhaps," Baripper pursued, "what can't be shouted at the corner of Queen Victoria Street may be breathed in a quiet garden at Carnmenellis?"
"Obviously," said Tolefree. "Confidences to a clergyman? Why not?"
"Confidences?" Baripper echoed.
"Confidences," Tolefree repeated.
"Then, padre, this fellow's the cutest detective in the Square Mile—diabolical."
"That's hardly truthful," Tolefree protested. "You know I don't pretend to be a detective, Mr. Baripper."
"No—you pretend to be an insurance agent. Well, Dimott, I'll tell you, letting him have his own way about names, poor Tolliver had the highest opinion of this fellow, and with good cause."
"Tolliver?" exclaimed Dimott, the smile fading off his face.
The introduction of Tolliver's name in this way was what finally gave a grave turn to a frivolous conversation. Impossible not to admire the aplomb of a man who could sit next to Tolefree on that garden bench and fence with him as Baripper did, with never a close touch on either side.
"Tolefree did Tolliver a great service—perhaps saved him a mint of money," said Baripper. "And now, no doubt, Tolefree's come down just to see what sort of country Tolliver's was—and perhaps visit his friend's grave in your windy old churchyard, Dimott."
"Yes," said Tolefree; "and to have a little in memoriam conversation with Tolliver's friends and neighbours."
"Ah, I thought as much. Well, Dimott here was one of Tolliver's friends."
"I've heard of the address Mr. Dimott gave at Tolliver's funeral. It made a deep impression on one hearer, anyhow," Tolefree said.
The vicar stirred on my right, murmured something about having had a great respect for Sir William Tolliver.
"Most people had. He was a remarkable man. Most honourable man. The strictest integrity—anyone in London would have said Sir William Tolliver stood for everything that was upright and good..."
It sounded as if Tolefree might go on with these inanities for an hour; but Baripper broke in:
"Good God, Tolefree! Are you in training as a stump missionary? Hope you don't imagine Dimott's interested in this kind of mortuary platitude?"
"Sorry, Mr. Baripper. I suppose I was just thinking aloud——"
"Tcha!" said Baripper. "That would be something new."
"I mean, thinking that probably Mr. Dimott, who knew Tolliver well, would endorse the high esteem in which he was held throughout the city of London."
"Tcha!" Baripper ejaculated again. "Didn't I say Dimott was a close friend of Tolliver?"
"And therefore," Tolefree continued in his smoothest tones, "he would agree that Tolliver could never consciously have done a dishonourable thing."
"I'm sure he was incapable of any dishonourable conduct," said the puzzled vicar.
"And who the deuce says he ever did anything dishonourable?" asked Baripper.
"In London," Tolefree went on, "Tolliver was considered an exceptionally sane man. Cool, level-headed, judicious, rational, humane——"
"Tcha!" said Baripper.
"And I assume that he had the same reputation in Carnmenellis."
"Certainly, but——"
Tolefree waited for a supplement; but the vicar fell silent.
"I could understand," said Tolefree, "that if either of two things had happened—if Tolliver had done some dishonourable thing and in the sequel feared discovery, or was hag-ridden by remorse, or if Tolliver had been an unbalanced and excitable man who might suddenly go off his head—I could understand in either event that Tolliver might commit suicide. As we are all agreed that neither was true, I cannot understand why Tolliver committed suicide. Can you, Mr. Dimott?"
The vicar leaned forward to take a look at Baripper.
"I fear," he said, "I have assumed a sudden aberration——"
"But aberrations do not occur without causes," Tolefree persisted. "I see that you also cannot understand why Tolliver committed suicide—a man of great consideration, deep in a tremendous undertaking, passionately interested, good health, large wealth, a family devoted if small, a host of friends, twenty years or more of splendid activity before him. The fact is, Mr. Dimott, that I do not believe Tolliver committed suicide."
"Ah!" said the vicar to Baripper, and "Ah!" said Baripper to the vicar. They both shifted their eyes to Tolefree.
"Go on, Dimott—tell him," Baripper growled at last.
"It's what you'd probably call a coincidence," said Dimott, "that Mr. Baripper and I were here talking in that very sense when you came. We felt that, however strong the evidence of suicide might be, it was psychologically impossible that Sir William should kill himself."
"Which probably explains why Capel Court mourns the absence of Mr. Baripper at a time when the exchanges are running a temperature of 104," Tolefree said.
"You've got it, Tolefree. And it also explains why your boy's kicking his heels in Watling Street with nothing to do while you sniff the ozone at Carnmenellis."
"I admit nothing."
"Naturally. But when you come in I go out," said Baripper.
"Not immediately, I hope?"
"There's a train at twelve-thirty. I can just catch it. Othello, his occupation gone, will quit the stage."
"I hope not, Mr. Baripper," said Tolefree. "At least, not to-day. I have myself to leave to-night, and Farrar's lending me his car to drive to London. I expect to be back to-morrow night or Friday morning. Can't you stay till then?"
"What's the good?"
"I assure you it will be of the highest importance. Mr. Dimott, urge him to stay."
"Of course," said Dimott.
"But why, Tolefree?
"To help. Your presence here on Friday—I assure you again——"
"But how can I help? I don't know the first thing about your job."
"Will you answer me a few questions. And if they don't suggest how important it is for you to stop—well, I give in."
From that point onward the fencers faced each other and forgot all about the parson and me.
"Carry on," said Baripper.
"In the first place, then, did you know a girl named Ada Lanherne?"
"Ah! so that's the line?" (Baripper stiffening, sitting up.) "Yes, I knew Ada Lanherne. She was the daughter of a man Tolliver and I liked very much—Francis Lanherne."
"I believe she was a remarkably beautiful young woman?"
"You believe the truth."
"I expect you know, or know of, an eccentric man, Ridgway, who lives in Carnmenellis?"
"Yes, I know Ridgway. Everyone in this countryside knows him."
"He'd been at King's College with Francis Lanherne, I think, and also knew his daughter?"
"Undoubtedly."
"Ridgway was extremely fond of the girl—I mean in a queer, fatherly fashion, wasn't he?"
"Yes, he made a lot of fuss of her after her father died."
"In fact, I've understood that he worshipped the very ground she trod."
"That's a romantic way of putting it, but Ridgway was devoted to her—he is now to her memory."
"Yes. And Tolliver—he was devoted to her also?"
"Tolliver's friendship for her father was—well, simply fierce. She had no money to speak of. Tolliver was——"
"Generous, solicitous—all we should expect Tolliver to be. I understand she would have had a substantial legacy under his will if she hadn't died first. Well—you know Mr. Penhaligon, too?"
"Oh, yes, I know that imbecile!" (Baripper's lips curling back.)
"He was fond of Miss Lanherne also, wasn't he?"
"Now, look here, Tolefree! You're trying pretty deep, you know. Penhaligon's a married man, a blithering nuisance, a puffed-up, rotten mass of conceit——"
"All right, Mr. Baripper. I've a fairly comic picture of Penhaligon in my mind, and I'm not suggesting any more than this: that his conceit or whatever it was caused him to peacock around Miss Lanherne—that you didn't like it, Ridgway hated it, Tolliver was furious about it."
"Well—and then?"
"And then that's all about Penhaligon. I'll come to a critical moment. Beginning of last September. Miss Lanherne was here convalescing after an illness. You came to see her. I hate to put a delicate question——"
"You do!" said Baripper, "like a child hates candies. Put it."
"Your own reactions to Miss Lanherne——"
Baripper drew back with the air of a certain angry dignity.
"Nothing's indelicate for you, Tolefree!"
"I think you do me an injustice, Mr. Baripper. But that's all the answer I want."
"It's a damned impertinence, but I don't resent it," Baripper declared resentfully. "I can tell you—the padre knows all about it—I was desperately in love with her, and she wasn't with me. There you have it. I thought I could persuade her—came down here to try. One day I found Tolliver on the spot——"
"Yes? Tolliver?"—as Baripper paused.
"Tolliver. Certainly. He was—well, strange—almost hostile. Don't know what he suspected. In a rage about Penhaligon. About me. About anything. A Sunday, it was. He went off by himself in the afternoon—you knew Miss Lanherne was staying at Treneglos?"
Tolefree nodded.
"Well—that afternoon I tried my luck. Nothing doing. There was another man, it seemed. She wouldn't say who. But I couldn't very well miss the significance of it, could I? Very nice to me, but nothing else. Then Tolliver came back. Said he'd been to read the Riot Act to Penhaligon about philandering with Ada. Behaved like a thundercloud. I cleared out." So Baripper jerkily made an end of his love story. "Never saw her again."
"Nor heard of her again?" Tolefree asked.
"Yes, I did hear of her. But I'm not going to tell you what, Tolefree."
"No matter. She died some six or seven weeks ago. A fortnight or so afterwards, Tolliver died. Do you now think it advisable to accept Mr. Dimott's hospitality till Friday?"
Baripper frowned over his glasses for a moment.
"I think I see what you mean, Tolefree. I'm sure you're wrong."
"I'm just as sure that you don't see what I mean, Mr. Baripper. Better stay."
"Hang it! You've got me put, haven't you? All right."
"Then answer just a few more questions. Where were you at a quarter to ten last Sunday night?"
"Here at Carnmenellis—at least, quarter to ten? I believe I was out walking."
"I thought you might be. And at two o'clock on Tuesday morning?"
"In bed—here at Dimott's."
"And at ten last night?"
"Out walking. What time did I turn up, Dimott?"
"About half-past eleven, I think," said the vicar.
"Why this curiosity about my movements, Tolefree?"
"Oh, just confirming alibis, that's all," he laughed. "I've nearly done. I'd like to take you back to the day of Tolliver's death. Most of the guests at Polventor had gone before the thing happened, but you were staying till the afternoon train, weren't you, and therefore found yourself right in the middle of it? Perhaps if I knew exactly what you did——"
"You'd see whether I'd an alibi or not? Well, I'm damned!"
"Taking me at the foot of the letter like that!" Tolefree complained, with his familiar grin. "I only want to complete some mental combinations. However—if you'd rather not—you see?"
"Tolefree I—you're too dam' clever by half. It don't matter to you whether a man says yes or no: you've got him either way. Thank heaven you're not on the money market! Exactly what I did? I had breakfast, saw Tolliver and Waverton go off fishing, and then——"
"Went for a walk, no doubt," said Tolefree. "But where? And did you meet anyone? And what time did you return?"
"It won't help your combinations the least bit," said Baripper. "I walked down the drive towards the Carnmenellis road, along that road past the gates of Rosneven, and perhaps a mile beyond. Then I turned back. Hadn't seen a human being the whole way so far as I remember. On the way back I did see just one person—close to Rosneven—a sort of gamekeeper fellow with a gun under his arm, snooping along by the hedge. Noticed him because he came out through the hedge into the road just as I turned a corner, and hopped back again. I can't say what time I got to Polventor, but they were just bringing Tolliver's body in."
"Combination perfect," said Tolefree. "You pass the Third Degree. Now you can put me through it if you like."
But the duel was over. Baripper declined the offer. He said he thought he saw what Tolefree was driving at, and felt sure he was on a false scent.
"Friday," said Tolefree. "Wait till Friday, and we'll know whether you're right or wrong. But I'll tell you this, Mr. Baripper: I guess who killed Tolliver and why. I guessed it before, by instinct and by circumstantial evidence. You'll be glad to know that after this pleasant talk I'm doubly confident. Most valuable. See you Friday—you'll not let Capel Court call you back before?" He rose. "Many thanks for your tolerance, Hope to meet you again."
We walked down to the car, leaving Baripper on the bench, and a sorely disturbed vicar at his gate.
"Poker face that eminent financier's got!"
I thought a poker face was an impassive face, and Baripper's was anything but that: however, I knew little of poker.
"No—not impassive," Tolefree assured me; "expressive—of the emotions that aren't there. Farrar, that's one of the two men who know how Tolliver died."
"I'm not inquisitive," I told him, "but your guess——"
"Why don't I come across with it to you? My dear fellow!—if only I could trust you to keep a poker face! But that's just what I can't. And if you guess yourself, for heaven's sake forget it."
Before we returned to Polventor, Tolefree paid another call on Marrack, to tell him of his coming journey to London and ask about the tailing-up of Gannett.
"Nothing out of the way," was Marrack's report. Gannett had seen and talked with no one but the villagers, except on the Monday night when Brimmell tracked him to Polventor and saw him have a short and apparently not too amicable conversation with Waverton, whom he waylaid.
"Ah," said Tolefree, "we know about that, eh, Farrar? Gannett went up to Polventor to complain of my conduct, Mr. Marrack—wanted to know whether they were responsible for it."
"I guessed something like that," the Inspector remarked. "But there's something about Gannett I don't quite understand. He's unusually flush of money, so Brimmell tells me. I'm going to ask him what rich uncle's left him a fortune."
"Ah!" said Tolefree. "That's most interesting. You don't think——?"
"Well—who can tell? I see your point, Mr. Tolefree. But I wouldn't bank on it if I were you. That little sneak-thief would rob his own mother's grave. Brimmell will smell out the rich uncle if we give him time."
A blackmailer! But whom was he blackmailing? Tolefree asked no more questions—seemed content to leave it to Brimmell. He impressed Marrack with the circumstances of his approaching departure, and we took ourselves off.
Then Tolefree developed the plan that started me on so exceedingly unpleasant a mission. He wanted everyone in the region to believe that he had left it. That would be the impression left with Baripper, and with Marrack. In the natural order of things it would become the impression of all Carnmenellis within an hour or two. It would also be the impression of the people at Polventor and even of Angwin and his mother, since he did not trust their ability to keep poker faces.
But Tolefree's friend Farrar would in fact drive off alone, and not to London, but to another destination which Tolefree would give him.
"I don't need to keep a poker face with you, Tolefree," said I. "So just a little less of the mystery stuff, if you don't mind."
"Well!—I didn't think I could ever pull your leg, Farrar," he chuckled. "All straightforward: a run as far as Exeter, and a little inquiry there. But that's not the crux. About five minutes or thereabouts after you've started—shall we say you're going to be attacked on the road, my friend, unless I'm a Dutchman. And that, Farrar, is the last place where the murderer of Tolliver steps off till he steps of into the air later on."
WE took lunch at Polventor.
Tolefree fixed his programme with them, undertaking to be back not later than next evening. His business in London, he surmised, would occupy him a couple of hours in the morning only. He proposed to borrow my car, drive to Plymouth, leave it there, and take the midnight train, which ran sleepers. If he could catch the twelve-thirty back from London next day, he would be with us before dark.
"Bit strenuous, won't it be?" Waverton asked. "And going alone. You face some risks, Tolefree—don't forget. I think you're far too rash."
Tolefree laughed that off. "I think I can guarantee to come back whole, and on time," said he.
The yarn he had pitched to Baripper and at Polventor, and to Marrack so that it might be spread by Brimmell painted with a hundred tongues, was all very well for Tolefree, but not quite so well for me, as I reminded him when at Tresneven that evening we were making arrangements for the journey.
"I'd better make a new will before I start, Tolefree," said I.
"Want to leave me a ship? If so, don't, Farrar. I simply can't afford it. No risk, I assure you. I had to put it about that I was going alone. Ever do any coarse fishing? You know how you bait a likely place. Well—that's it. Our pot-shotting friend's a remarkably astute and self-concealing man, but I've got him, Farrar! I want him to convict himself. It'll save a lot of trouble. Sequel to a love story. Here's how——"
Not till two days after did I learn how Tolefree had convinced himself that certain events must almost inevitably follow upon his seeding this false report of his movements. During the afternoon, while I sat on the lawn at Tresneven and entertained old Mrs. Angwin with stories of adventures encountered in our trip across America, he "prowled," as he said, around the neighbourhood—up through the wooded combe the way we had come when we nearly ran down Ridgway, on to the main road, and back by woodland paths.
Angwin telephoned that he was staying there to dine with the Carberrys and that he would come over for me if I cared to sleep the night at Polventor. As that was decidedly not in the book of words, I excused myself on the score that I wanted to go over the car before Tolefree started on his journey.
At dinner Tolefree exerted himself to delight the old lady. She retired early as usual. The maids melted away. The coast was clear.
In my room, while I prepared for the drive, Tolefree laid out his scheme. As he had never driven a car in his life, I had been obliged to offer, in the presence of Mrs. Angwin and the servants, to go with him a mile or two on the pretence that I should like the walk back. But no one at Tresneven showed any curiosity about our movements: we were left entirely to our own devices. The plan was for Tolefree to alight from the car at a point on the road which he had already fixed. He had "prowled" in the afternoon in order to estimate the place at which the attack of which he felt so certain would be made. He thought he had it within a hundred yards. This was what made him so sure: looking at the matter from the point of view of the assailant, if the intrusive Tolefree were to be put out of business before he closed his net round the murderer of Tolliver; four conditions must be observed:
First, to-night must positively be the night.
Second, Tolefree must shuffle off this mortal coil out of sight and hearing of Tresneven.
Third, the scene of his taking off must not be anywhere near the main road, where it would be too soon discovered.
Fourth, the place must provide a perfect ambush and an infallible certainty that his executioner could get away instantly and unobserved.
Between Tresneven and the main road, as Tolefree had remarked during his inspection, only one region fulfilled all these conditions. The road from the house through the wooded combe ascended gradually for a few hundred yards, and then struck the steep pitch where we had come upon Ridgway. The trees crowded thickly there, but the rise was within sight and hearing of the house. Beyond it, the road flattened again, to take a last severe gradient just before it came out on the open moor and ran to the main highway. At this ascent, on both hands rose the sides of a rock cutting a few feet high and the woods were dense, offering the perfect ambush and the ideal get-away.
"That's where he'll shoot at you, most likely, Farrar," said Tolefree.
"Thanks," said I. "And when I'm shot——?"
"You'll just carry on as before. I shall be there, Farrar. I've taken steps to divert his bullet or bullets, and you can proceed with your programme while I pursue mine."
This account of the preliminaries of Tolefree's trap must, I realize, seem fantastic. It looks insane to me now. But such was the ascendancy of his positiveness that it did not look insane at the moment—because, of course, I did not believe there would be any shooting, but thought Tolefree's trap must be infallible, or he would not have put up the scheme.
It worked out so differently! The best plans of even the cleverest people have such a knack of coming to grief.
We got away from Tresneven, as I have indicated, without observation, or at any rate without comment. It was ten o'clock—deep dusk in the open, complete darkness in the combe. "Lights as usual" was Tolefree's order. I climbed the first hill in bottom gear, got into second for the lesser grade, and went half a mile. He was to leave me half-way up the next ascent. Keeping the engine running hard to make as much noise as possible, I was to wait three minutes while he disappeared into the woods and made his dispositions. He pulled out a torch and his revolver, and prepared to drop off as soon as I stopped.
"At that next twist, Farrar," said he. "If you hear any firing, take no notice. Go straight on—non-stop to Exeter. Give me a ring in the morning at Tresneven if you—damn!"
Tolefree's exclamation and the first shot came together.
I had slowed down, nearing the corner. The car was almost standing. From the off side of the road—my side—a blinding flash leapt at me, as it seemed not more than a few feet away and just ahead. The wheel switched violently round—a jerk of the nerves—and my foot foozled the clutch. The car stopped.
Immediately another crash followed another flash.
Tolefree was already out of the car on his side.
"Get away!" he said. "For God's sake get away!"
"Not likely!" I cried out.
"Damn you—get away! You'll ruin the whole thing. I'm perfectly safe. Get on!"
He shut the door and disappeared. A moment's hesitation, with no clear thought in it: I restarted the engine, moved on up the hill.
I could only suppose that the gunman had waited in ambush to observe the effect of his shots, and was not sure whether he had disabled the driver or not. For no sooner was the car in motion again than a third explosion blazed out. I winced but hung on. The car gathered speed....
The three shots were all.
I reached the top of the hill, came out on to the open down, and saw the sandy road stretching towards the London highway. I pulled up—to consider the extraordinary problem set for me by Tolefree's conduct.
Should I follow the natural instinct to stand by and look out for a chance of helping Tolefree? Or should I follow the instructions given me by Tolefree himself?
I confess that, never having been shot at in my life before except by big guns at sea, I was trembling with an excited sense of nervous terror—worse in the reaction than in the actual experience. I found myself panting and tingling, and there was a nasty singing in my ears. That a desperate man had fired three times and done no damage—so far as I could judge he had not even hit the car—was hardly less than a miracle. I could think of only one explanation—that he had wrongly chosen both his moment and his position. He probably had to conceal himself among the trees to avoid being shown up by the headlights, and then the headlights themselves had blinded his aim. They were powerful lights, and every motorist knows that it is impossible to see even the outlines of a car behind such lights, or even to judge their exact distance.
But about that problem?...
In the end I looked at my watch. A quarter after ten. I gave myself five minutes. If by twenty past I had heard no more firing, it would be plain that Tolefree's ruse, even though it had gone off half-cock, had worked: by that time he would be stalking his man—I should not find him and if I did could be of no service to him.
The country remained dead silent in a starlit summer night. At twenty past ten I moved on...
The main road trended inland and upwards until the wild country was left behind. When I dropped into the valley by Launceston at eleven, I passed through empty streets with only occasional lights in the houses. Thereafter the villages and little towns on the northern side of the great mass of Dartmoor all slept. I ran into the suburbs of Exeter at one o'clock, and ten minutes later, on the advice of a friendly policeman, pulled up outside the garage of an hotel in the Cathedral Close. A sleepy night porter showed me to a room under the shadow of heavy Norman towers.
My first care next morning was to ring up Tolefree at Tresneven. A little shiver of relief: his own cheery voice came through.
"Hello, Farrar! Still alive? You'll have heaps of time to make another will."
"How did you get on?"
"According to plan. Won't tell you on the wire: it may be leaking."
"See him?" I asked.
"Well—actually no, but near enough."
"Did he see you?"
"Not so much as an eyebrow. What d'you take me for?"
"But how have you explained yourself at Tresneven?"
"Easy. Found I couldn't manage an unfamiliar car well enough to catch the train, so you went on to do my business for me."
"That'll hardly wash at Polventor," I suggested.
"It won't want to now: we arrive, Farrar! Get your stuff as early as you can and rush back. Be here by lunch-time if you can. Now—ring off. Good-bye."
The "stuff" I was to get at Exeter could not, however, be obtained very early. The office of the Registrar of Births and Deaths did not open till ten o'clock. At that hour I was on the doorstep. Five minutes afterwards I was inspecting the Register of Deaths for the month of June. A healthy month, June, in the city of Exeter. Only two deaths were recorded on the day that interested me. I roughly copied the entries into my note-book:
"Nos. 372 and 373 in the sub-district of Exeter East. Died at 210 Westernhay, 1st June, 1932, Ada Lanherne, female, aged 24, research chemist: cause of death, parturition; —— Lanherne, male, aged one hour: cause of death, syncope. Both certificates signed by Alfred Furnes, M.D., and countersigned by F. H. Pyncheon, Registrar."
And there, thought I, as I closed the book, lay the foundation and origin of the Tolliver tragedy.
But a little more had to be done. Westernhay was a pleasant retreat outside the city walls—a double row of sedate old brick houses of Queen Anne's day, a long lawn edged with gardens stretching between. And No. 210 Westernhay, one of the larger of the houses, bore a brass plate on its gate: "Westernhay Nursing Home."
I presented my card to a mob-capped maid and asked her to give it to the Matron. Presently she received me in her office. A woman as sedate as her establishment, but sympathetic.
"I don't know whether I'm in order," said I. "I was interested in a patient of yours, who died on the 1st June. I have only just heard about it. I was wondering——"
"Yes?"—as I paused.
"Whether if I'd been aware that she was here and in danger I could have done anything for her—I mean, by visiting, or cheering her up. I imagine she was a rather lonely young woman?"
"You're talking of—whom?"
"Ada Lanherne."
The Matron eyed me curiously.
"You're interested in her? As a relative?"
"Oh, no—purely as a friend of some of her friends. They were deeply distressed by her death."
"Yes? They hardly showed it, did they?"
This woman was moved. Something in the fate of Ada Lanherne stirred her out of her matronly composure.
"Well," said I, "you see—I wanted to know a little of the circumstances."
"So deeply distressed that not one of them came near her while she was ill. Just one visit from a clerk to make financial arrangements. And when she died not one of them attended her funeral. It's a little late, Mr.—Farrar."
"I'm not surprised at anything that happened after her death," said I. "There were reasons—another death. Perhaps you know?"
"Sir William Tolliver? Yes, I understand that. He seemed to be the only friend she had: he sent her here—paid for everything. But, Mr. Farrar, even if her husband was dead, Mrs. Lanherne must have had other relatives, and—upon my soul, I never could comprehend it! I never had such a case in all my experience. This poor young woman, in a dreadful state of health when she came, unlikely to survive the birth of her child, was left alone by everyone. Not a person came or made an inquiry. She faced it all out alone. She died alone. She was buried by strangers."
"Terrible," said I.
"You are the first person except one who has ever asked a question about her."
"Oh? Then there was one?"
"Yes. He came here after the funeral—had only just heard of her death. A strange, wild man. He seemed a little mad."
"A tall, gaunt man, with a ragged beard, looking like a tramp and talking like a gentleman?"
"Ah! You know him, then?"
"Yes," said I.
"He was a relative?"
"No—a friend of her father's, who had known her as a child, and had a sort of fierce affection for her."
"Well, Mr. Farrar, that person and yourself are the only two who have ever concerned themselves about poor Mrs. Lanherne."
"The formalities—after her death, I mean? Registration and so on?"
"The same clerk was sent from Sir William Tolliver's office in London to arrange it with the doctor who attended her. A clerk!"
The clerk, or the idea of this fashion of disposing of her patient, drove her to the summit of indignation. But the fact sent my thoughts flying back to Polventor. A clerk, who would give to doctor and registrar the information about Ada Lanherne as it was recorded in the Register—the aberrations of Tolliver's temper during those mournful days——
"Mrs. Lanherne herself"—I adopted the form—"did the neglect distress her?" I asked.
"No, I can't honestly say it did. An unusual young woman. You know she was strikingly beautiful?"
"I've seen her portrait."
"Ah, well. A young woman of character—brilliant education. Extraordinarily powerful mind in a feeble body. You know, Mr. Farrar, she should never have been married. It was—well, it was a tragedy. I imagine she foresaw tragedy—a reckless temperament, sort of fatalism, determined to get something out of a short life and a bewildering loveliness. But I'm gossiping."
A competent, observant woman, the Matron. If she had known of my subterfuges——! But when I bowed myself out into the pleasant street, and fetched my car, and took the westward road again, I carried with me something more than the documentary evidence of Ada Lanherne's tragedy: an explanation of it in her own character and doom. I had the knowledge which, no doubt, accounted for those vagaries of the feminine mind which Tolefree detected in Mrs. Carberry and her daughter. A poignant picture—Ada Lanherne, an inner voice proclaiming to her, "You've only a short time to live; then why not live?" Ada Lanherne recklessly flinging her beauty into the kitty...
DRIVING hard, I did the sixty miles in two hours—and it was hard driving in such country. I turned into the side road to Tresneven at one o'clock.
To my surprise and disquietude, I found Angwin and Miss Carberry at the house, but no Tolefree.
The young people had excellent reason for their manifest annoyance—more than one reason. It appeared that Tolefree's very sketchy account of his own presence when he was supposed to be in London and my absence when I was supposed to be at Tresneven had more or less satisfied Angwin the night before on his return from Polventor; but this morning Tolefree had put up some quite unconvincing yarn about having stopped me en route and ordered me back—and Angwin had resented what he thought a needless mystification. His resentment doubled when Tolefree vanished again all the morning and Angwin found a scribbled note in his study asking him to send me on in the car to Carnmenellis as soon as possible after my arrival.
Angwin felt that, after all the preliminary confidences, he was being left out in the cold at the critical moment.
Ann Carberry's peevishness took a different turn. She was short with her lover, even more strangely silent than during that unpleasant luncheon-party at Polventor.
I got between the nut-crackers, of course. As there was no invitation from Tolefree to either of them, I did not venture to suggest that they should go with me. I drove off after swallowing a few mouthfuls, and went alone.
Tolefree was walking up the hill from Carnmenellis to meet me. He looked grave as he stepped into the car, asked me to draw into the roadside and tell him the story of my inquiries. He heard me through without comment, except a little ejaculation over the visit of the clerk from Tolliver's office. When I had done, he said the facts were much as he had expected. But——
"Those women, Farrar! O most delicate fiend!—who is't can read a woman?" I exclaimed.
"Only that I'm guessing, like Cymbeline. How much of all this did those women know before they started grubbing under the tragedy of Tolliver? All of it? And if they did, why did they call me in? However, as Waverton says, there's no going back now. I've had the deuce and all of a job to placate the people at Polventor and our young friend Angwin over the little deception last night."
"You haven't placated Angwin," said I. "He's about as friendly as the tiger with the toothache. And I really don't myself see, Tolefree, why—not quite why—you didn't let 'em all in on it."
"No? Well—I talked to you yesterday about poker face. That's why. Very few people can keep a poker face—certainly neither of them, except maybe young Ann. And she—well, there's Angwin. We've got a highly accomplished person to deal with, and he'll have to be bluffed into what is it?—a show-down. Whoever gets hurt, I'm going through with it in my own way."
"What happened last night?"
"You pretty nearly spoilt it by hanging on. If he hadn't been puzzled and stayed for a third shot I'd have missed him. As it was, I got all the information I wanted."
Not for me to sue for favours from Tolefree. Probably some such idea was eloquent in my expression as I sat with hands on the wheel and head turned towards him. It drew out his first smile for the day.
"No, Farrar," he said, "I'm not telling you at present—for the excellent reason that I don't trust your features in a touch-and-go affair like this. Let's get on down to the village. We're going to have a little chat with Ridgway first."
It took place in Ridgway's studio, with the lovely face of Ada Lanherne looking down on us from the wall.
The forlorn figure seemed more grotesque, the grey face more wretched than before. He had seen us from his window, waited for us, took us up the narrow stairs, pointed to chairs, seated himself, all without a word. There was fatalism in his air.
Tolefree regarded him thoughtfully. He returned the stare with unblinking eyes.
"Mr. Ridgway," said Tolefree quietly, "I want you now to tell me all you know about the death of Sir William Tolliver."
"All I know... Know nothing.... Told you all I know."
"Better, wouldn't it, for you to tell me than for me to tell you?"
A deeper cloud fell on Ridgway's face at this. His eyes under the bushed brows looked apprehension at Tolefree. But he said nothing.
Tolefree sighed.
"Very well. If you must suffer—first, you've said nothing about her," and he pointed to the portrait above the desk.
Ridgway looked up, and the old expression of anguish twisted his features.
"Ada Lanherne," said Tolefree. "Almost your godchild, wasn't she? You loved that girl beyond the common. She was the reason why Tolliver died, Mr. Ridgway. You know how he died. Now, will you tell me?"
"No!" It was a shout. Then he relapsed into his mumbled, ejaculatory way of speaking. "Can't tell you... Don't know."
"You went to the woods that morning with your camera. You saw what you didn't expect to see. You saw Gannett. You took a photograph of Gannett, and another of Tolliver just before his death. The camera was not the only thing you used that morning. You had a gun with you. And you fired it, Ridgway! Now will you tell me?"
Ridgway sagged back in his chair without answering the question.
"Why did you fire it?"
No reply.
"I know why you fired it, Ridgway. You fired it to avenge, as you thought, the death of Ada Lanherne. Now will you tell me?"
He remained dumb.
"You're a foolish man. Better own up. You won't tell me because you fired that shot."
Ridgway had a spasm, as a man might be struck by a galvanic current. He sat up, half started out off his chair, but sank back again, wordless. He was a pitiful sight.
"I know the story of Ada Lanherne, Ridgway. I know how she died and why. I know that you were the only person on earth who cared enough for her to discover where they had buried her and put a flower on her grave. I want to help you. I don't know that I wouldn't myself have shot the man who brought her to that pass—shot him like a dog. But you won't help me——"
"No! Damn you!" Ridgway started, jumped to his feet and raged. "Who are you... profaning the holy places? Get out!... Leave me alone with my dead... and my vengeance."
Mad!—mad as Hanwell. He loomed over us with a menacing arm stretched out, his beard trembling, his eyes blazing.
"Calm yourself, Mr. Ridgway," said Tolefree. "Come, Farrar."
His skinny hand followed us around as we moved to the doorway. I looked back from the bottom of the stairway to see the bony fingers still pointing.
"Poor devil!" said Tolefree as we crossed the quay.
"Why enrage him, Tolefree?" I asked. Ridgway's torment had affected me unpleasantly. "You don't really think he killed Tolliver?"
"Eh? No—I certainly don't. But he does, Farrar!"
I stopped in the middle of the roadway, petrified by surprise.
"Yes—undoubtedly he thinks he killed Tolliver. Undoubtedly he fired a shot from that old gun of his—probably the first and only one he ever fired in his life—and he's fool enough to imagine that his marksmanship at what shall we say?—forty yards? was good enough not to be more than three yards wide. But it's quite certain that he didn't hit Tolliver. The bullet that killed Tolliver simply couldn't have been fired out of Ridgway's old blunderbuss. He was the man who hit the tree."
"Then why in the name of heaven, Tolefree——" I began.
"Why don't I put him out of his misery?"
"Exactly."
I knew Tolefree well enough to suppose that he would not grill a man like Ridgway without a reason, but the process seemed the very refinement of cruelty.
"I don't for the moment because I daren't," said he. "You'll have to trust me. To take Ridgway into my confidence now would just muck up everything. And I assure you, Farrar, it would destroy Ridgway himself. Better for him to suffer a little more now than go through hell later on. Let's leave the poor devil alone—with his dead and his vengeance—like any melodrama, eh?—just leave him alone for a few hours."
"No doubt you know best," said I.
We reached the edge of the quay and looked down on one of the half-dozen fishermen of Carnmenellis painting the unshipped rudder of his boat a bright green. Tolefree began to talk about light and colour: it was his way of putting down further questions about Ridgway.
"I'd expected a longer session over there." He nodded towards the studio. "Asked Baripper to meet us here at three. Let's stroll up that way."
We turned towards the hill.
"I wonder," said I, "how Baripper would react to those entries in the Register if he could see them?"
"If——! Why, hang it, man, he certainly knows all about them, does Mr. Baripper. I'd wager my last shilling on it. Why do you think Baripper's been here these five days prowling around—haunting the scene of Tolliver's death? But here's Baripper himself, and hold your tongue on the subject for heaven's sake!"
Baripper, in his blue coat and flannel bags, his spectacles shining in the sun, came down the hill and joined us. He nodded; held out his hand to me.
"Well, Tolefree, have you fixed it?"
"Marrack promised, Mr. Baripper. I expect he'll be as good as his word. Farrar (he's only just got here, Mr. Baripper), we're going to have another talk with Gannett in the presence of Mr. Baripper."
We turned back in the direction of the village street. Baripper walked between us. He said to me:
"Complacent lot of policemen here, Mr. Farrar—committing all sorts of irregularities for the sake of Tolefree's beautiful eyes."
Baripper's facetious malice produced a facetious indignation in Tolefree.
"Irregularities, Mr. Baripper! Oh, no. I always get on admirably with police just because I never ask them to step outside the bounds of convention."
"Tolefree, you're a sententious fraud! Don't you try to start anything with me."
Probably there was, in fact, no departure from strict letter of those elaborate regulations known as The Judges' Rules. The sullen Gannett, whom we found in Marrack's office, had merely been invited to go there for a word with Mr. Tolefree. But an invitation from Marrack to a man with Gannett's record——!
"I've told Gannett, gentlemen," said Marrack, "that he needn't come here if he didn't like to. That's so, Gannett? You're here of your own free will?"
The down-looking fellow seemed not quite so abject as he had been.
"That's all right, Mr. Marrack," said he.
"Good. And now I tell you, Gannett, that you needn't open your mouth if you want to keep it shut. I'm not going to ask you any questions. You can talk to Mr. Tolefree or not, as you please. And you can open the door and walk out any moment. That understood?"
"Yes, sir."
Tolefree smiled dangerously at him.
"Just a friendly talk, Gannett," said he. "First about a young lady. Carry your mind back to last September. Just after you'd left Polventor and gone to Rosneven, wasn't it? So Mr. Marrack tells me, anyhow. Well, there was a young lady, Miss Ada Lanherne, staying at Treneglos with Mr. Menhennick. Did you ever see her?"
Gannett intimated with a grunt that he had seen her.
"She used to walk a good deal on the Rosneven land and up on the moors. I suppose 'twas there you saw her."
"Yes," said Gannett.
"Now," said Tolefree sweetly, "I'm not asking you to play Paul Pry on your employer, and I'm not going to suggest that you would dream of doing such a thing." (Marrack made an inarticulate noise: Gannett threw him a glance of hatred.) "Not for a moment," said Tolefree. "But perhaps if there were several meetings between Miss Lanherne and Mr. Penhaligon you couldn't have missed noticing it. Don't give Mr. Penhaligon away if you don't want to——"
"Penhaligon!" said Gannett. "I don't give a damn for Penhaligon! He's no employer of mine."
Tolefree whistled at this declaration, which Gannett had made as vicious as his little tenor voice would permit.
"I thought he was——"
"He was, but he's not now. I left yesterday."
"Ah—well, that's news," said Tolefree. "If you cared to say whether you left at your own request or his——"
"I left myself. Fed up with Penhaligon," Gannett declared.
"That's awkward. Perhaps I'd better not press the question, Gannett. He might think it looked like spite if you said anything."
"Spite! What do I care what the old devil thinks? A cock-my-nose poor fool like that? If you want to know—yes, he did crawl round after that young woman, the dirty tyke! I saw 'em lots of times."
"Where?"
"In the woods—out on the moor. Anywhere that his old woman couldn't spot him. Leastways, till Tolliver came to Rosneven one Sunday and told off the little snipe with his wife looking on. I heard about that from the servants. Then he didn't go petticoat-chasing any more."
"Ah," said Tolefree. "Sort of marital anti-climax? Well, never mind about Mr. Penhaligon. It's Miss Lanherne I'm interested in. What should you say, Gannett, as a man of the world?—that she met him by arrangement?"
"No, I shouldn't! I said he crawled round after her—and that's what he did. Just tracked her walking, and came upon her sudden-like. She was a lively piece, that girl—treated him as if he was a performing cockroach, and he was."
"You know, Gannett," said Tolefree thoughtfully, "that doesn't sound very convincing. If she didn't want to meet Mr. Penhaligon, she could easily have avoided him, couldn't she?—walked another way?"
"Maybe; but I reckon he'd have found her wherever she walked."
"And you never saw Miss Lanherne meet any other person besides Mr. Penhaligon?"
"No, I didn't," said Gannett.
"Then I think that's all about her. Now, Gannett, would you like to have another little talk about what happened in the wood the morning Sir William died?"
"Struth!—you think yourself dam' clever, don't you?"
This was an unprecedented Gannett, suddenly become truculent. Marrack made more inarticulate noises, which Gannett seemed to interpret.
"All very well, Mr. Marrack," he said. "But you know he's got no right——"
"You quite misunderstand me, Gannett," Tolefree broke in. "I'm not claiming any right. I just asked you if you'd like to have a chat about that. If you don't, you needn't. If you do, Mr. Marrack won't listen—officially. Tell you why I asked. I feel quite sure you know exactly how Sir William died, only you won't tell me. I'm positive you saw him die."
"Good God!"
We all turned at Baripper's exclamation: he was looking intently at Gannett through his owlish spectacles.
"Positive!" Tolefree repeated.
"I didn't!" said Gannett. "I know nothing about it. I told you before."
Tolefree got up and stood over him, pointing a finger.
"Well—I can't make you talk if you won't. I'll just tell you why you should. You never heard of the Accessories and Abettors Act, I expect. But—Mr. Marrack, correct me if I'm wrong—you'll find that though it's not an offence to witness a crime without interfering, it's a serious offence to go on afterwards as if no crime had been committed. You were seen in the wood opposite Sir William Tolliver about the time he was killed. You acted suspiciously afterwards."
"How did I act suspiciously?"
Gannett was much less truculent.
"You were afraid, Gannett."
"What was I afraid of?"
"You didn't want anyone to know you'd been in the wood just then. You hated to be seen about there."
"Nothing of the sort," said Gannett. "Penhaligon knew I was there. He took me there."
"Ah, yes—Mr. Penhaligon. But I wasn't suggesting you feared Mr. Penhaligon. Why should you, indeed? You wouldn't want to be jumping about over hedges to hide yourself from Mr. Penhaligon."
"Nothing of the sort," said Gannett. He was now in a panic.
"Was this the man, Mr. Baripper?" Tolefree asked.
"Unquestionably, Tolefree," said Baripper.
Tolefree stood back against Marrack's table, looking Gannett in the eyes. We all stared at him. His glance shifted round from one to the other. A telephone bell struck into the silence. Marrack picked up the receiver.
"Yes?" said he. "Oh, yes, Mr. Penhaligon.... Certainly... Almost at once... A moment, sir, will you?"
He put his hand over the transmitter.
"How long, Mr. Tolefree? He's waiting."
"Immediately," said Tolefree.
"Are you there, Mr. Penhaligon?... we will be there in three minutes."
Marrack put up the receiver and made a wry face. Tolefree turned again to Gannett, who had sat with his mouth hung open during the telephone talk, looking suspiciously upon the group. Now he jumped up.
"Nothing doing, Gannett?" said Tolefree.
The man took a stride to the door.
"No—and be damned to you!"
He rushed out of the office.
"Delightful personality," Tolefree observed.
"You let him go?" Baripper seemed astonished.
"Oh," said Marrack, "we'll know where Gannett goes and all he does. Nobody can so much as change his collar in Carnmenellis and get away with it, Mr. Baripper."
"Delightful place," said Baripper.
Marrack looked to Tolefree with a lift of the eyebrows.
"Won't do to keep him waiting," said he.
"No, I suppose not. Let's start. Mr. Baripper, I'm much obliged to you for identifying the hurdle-jumper. See you again later. Now we're going along to put the great Penhaligon through it."
"Penhaligon? Are you stringing him? I sympathize with him, Tolefree. Can't imagine why you want to string Penhaligon."
"No? I thought you might. But all in good time," said Tolefree. "My regards to the vicar."
Baripper nodded to the Inspector and strolled away.
"Mind, Mr. Tolefree," said Marrack, "I'm not in this—except to introduce you. I'm not supposed to know anything you're going to say."
"Quite understood, Mr. Marrack. I'll bet he soon forgets all about you."
"You'll find him sticky, Tolefree," I warned him.
"Not half so sticky as he'll find me! I know the type."
And Tolefree showed that he did. He had the measure of Penhaligon inside a minute. But in that minute a ludicrous Penhaligonesque farce was played.
Marrack led us along the quay to the little hotel, the Carnmenellis Arms. We followed him into the lobby, where a gaping and flurried landlord met us.
"Mr. Penhaligon here?" asked Marrack.
"Up in the court-room, Mr. Marrack."
"He would be," Marrack muttered; "on his high horse."
He went on, ascended a flight of stairs with us at his heels, knocked on a double door at the end of an upper passage and entered.
A long room, kind of assembly hall, with some dusty stage scenery piled in a corner. A certain arrangement of furniture betrayed its use as an occasional court-room. A table across the top, with a row of chairs behind it, and in the middle a superior chair with a canopy decorated by the royal arms; and seated in the superior chair under the canopy, looking like a small boy occupying a large throne, Penhaligon.
"Good afternoon, Mr. Penhaligon," said Marrack.
"Afternoon, Marrack"—with an air of now-what's-all-this-about? Then he saw me. "Hello!—who are these people? I've seen one of them before. You, sir—more affidavits? Marrack!—you haven't brought me all this way to witness affidavits?" Penhaligon puffed himself out to the Inspector. "You can't treat the bench like this, you know, Marrack!"
"I was about to introduce Mr. Tolefree, of London," said Marrack. "No doubt he'll explain what he wants with you."
"Wants with me!" He glowered at the Inspector and at us in turn. "What can a person like this want with me? What right has he got to want anything, Marrack?"
"That's for him to tell you, sir. He gave me to understand that his business was urgent."
Penhaligon snorted.
"You, sir!—you Mr. Tolefree of London—London is a big place. Give me an address and a reason for occupying my time."
He puffed himself out at Tolefree, inviting a prod in the stomach, so to speak. He got it.
"My address in London is Watling Street, but it has nothing to do with the matter," said Tolefree. "My business concerns Rosneven and the person who resides there. I wish to make a statement to you and to ask you some questions, which you can answer or not, just as you like. As nobody has offered us chairs, Farrar—be seated, will you?"
Tolefree set the example. He turned his back on a snort of double strength, found a chair, pulled it up to the table and sat down opposite the throne.
"Mr. Marrack," he said, "it might be awkward for you to be present at this interview. I understand this gentleman is a magistrate in your division. I therefore suggest that you leave us."
Marrack nodded and slipped out as Penhaligon recovered from his incipient fit and shouted, "Marrack! Come back!"
Marrack did not come back.
"Of all the impertinent scoundrels——!"
Not Marrack, but Tolefree.
"Of all the insolence—what the devil do you mean by it? Confound you, sir!—I'll have you committed for contempt of court!"
"Most appropriate," said Tolefree, leaning on his elbows and looking as if he meant it. "No truer charge could be brought. Only, this isn't a court. It's a public-house. At this moment of time, you're not a magistrate: you're just Mr. Penhaligon, of Rosneven. I have a statement to make which closely concerns you."
"Damn you, sir! I'll not listen to a word,"
"Oh, yes you will—lots of words. And it will be wise to listen attentively."
Penhaligon shuffled off his throne and picked up his gloves from the table.
"Going?" said Tolefree. "Better not. I want to talk to you about the death of your late enemy, Sir William Tolliver."
Penhaligon found his hat on one of the inferior chairs, and moved along the side of the table.
"The murder of your enemy, Sir William Tolliver."
Penhaligon stopped along the table.
"Ah! that's better. Yes, I said murder," Tolefree added.
"Murder? You're mad! That explains it," said Penhaligon. "I'll fetch a doctor and have you certified."
"Do—when you've told me where you were at the moment when Sir William Tolliver was murdered," said Tolefree.
"Mad as a March hare!" said Penhaligon.
"Farrar," said Tolefree, "this is the gentleman who quarrelled with Sir William about riparian rights, and the morning he was killed posted an armed keeper on the river close to Sir William's boundary."
"So I've heard, Tolefree," said I.
Penhaligon moved back to the throne, dropped his gloves and sat down.
"Are you by any chance suggesting that I——"
"Suggesting nothing. But—you see? I said you'd hear a good many words."
"Who the devil are you, sir?"
"Moderate your language when you address me, if you please. Sir William Tolliver's friends have commissioned me to discover the truth about his death. You can give me information. And you'd better."
"A private detective! Like your infernal cheek——"
"Farrar," said Tolefree, "isn't he truly insufferable? How did the Lord Chancellor ever put him on the bench?"
I thought Penhaligon would explode. Tolefree went on before he could catch his breath:
"Listen to me, Mr. Penhaligon. Come off the high horse, will you? This is serious. Sir William Tolliver was well known to me, and he trusted me. Sir William Tolliver was murdered—even Marrack suspects it now. Somebody murdered him, and I mean to find out how. You decline to help. Well!—I should have thought common wariness would have shown you that you can't afford it. But as it hasn't, I tell you now—you can't afford it, Mr. Penhaligon."
"I can afford to ring the bell and call the landlord to throw you out. You threaten me, sir?—me!"
"Not at all," said Tolefree. "But you are threatened—with all sorts of unpleasantness if you keep up this absurd pretence. My dear sir, can't you understand that I take no more stock in Mr. Penhaligon of Rosneven than in Jones, Brown or Robinson? I am not indebted to Mr. Penhaligon for anything—not even for ordinary courtesy. I don't care two hoots for him or his position or his opinions or his wrath. His silly proposal to throw me out of a public-house where I have as much right to be as himself leaves me quite cold. Good heavens, man I—if you have hitherto thought Tolliver committed suicide and I now tell you he was murdered, doesn't that shake up your ideas a bit?"
It seemed, at any rate, to have penetrated Penhaligon's consciousness that Tolefree had him in an awkward corner—or maybe his curiosity was overcoming his sense of indignity. He began to discuss instead of exclaiming.
"How do I know that you're even what you say you are?" he said.
"Ask Marrack. He'll tell you. Or the vicar. Or ring up Polventor. Anything you like. Only listen to reason. Come, Mr. Penhaligon—I wouldn't waste my time or yours for two minutes if I weren't at a critical point that your information can probably settle. Tell you what: I'll apologize for my gross rudeness if you'll come down to earth and answer a question or two."
"I know nothing about it," said Penhaligon. "What questions?"
"I don't undertake to answer them."
"Undertake to listen, and I think you'll answer." Tolefree roared as mildly as a sucking dove now. "You can answer without prejudice. This isn't a law court and I'm not the police. We're two persons exchanging views and knowledge."
"Then go on."
"Well, you'll agree that if I'm right and Sir William Tolliver was murdered, the verdict at the inquest must be quashed and the murderer found and——"
"That's police business," Penhaligon interrupted.
"It will be—very soon, I expect. At present I collect facts to confirm a theory. Now, Mr. Penhaligon, I asked where you were when Tolliver died. A very short time before, you were within a few yards of the spot. That's so?"
"I was there once that morning, but as to the time——"
"Well, it doesn't matter. You were there. You posted your man Gannett to watch Tolliver's fishing and see that he didn't fish in your water. No"—as Penhaligon began to blow again—"I don't trouble about riparian law: dare say you were well within your rights. I come to the first point: did you see Tolliver arrive at the pool?"
"Certainly not!"
"You'd moved off before, then. Did you see anyone else at the pool or near by?"
"Only Gannett."
"Did you hear the shot?"
"I was some distance away. I thought, as a matter of fact, that I heard two shots, but put it down to echoes."
"Where did you go when you left Gannett? This isn't idle curiosity. It's important," said Tolefree with a certain eagerness.
"Down the river to the stepping-stones——"
"How far's that?"
"About half a mile."
"And then?"
"Up through the woods to the road, and home."
"You saw no one?"
"No one."
"Could you say what time you reached Rosneven?"
"About eleven—or just before."
"With no idea that anything had gone wrong down on the river?"
"None whatever."
"About the shot——?"
"Nothing unusual to hear a shot. Might have been anyone shooting, either on Rosneven or Polventor, or farther away."
"How long would it have taken you to walk from the pool the way you did to your house?"
"Quarter of an hour—perhaps twenty minutes."
"Well, that settles the first point, Farrar?"
"It seems to," said I, without in the least knowing what it did settle.
"The second is this: last September a young lady, Miss Ada Lanherne, was staying at Treneglos with Mr. Menhennick. She walked about the district a good deal when she had recovered from an illness. Did you see anything of her?"
Penhaligon had submitted—grudgingly enough, but he had submitted—to Tolefree's questions about the morning of Tolliver's death. When the inquiry was switched off to Miss Lanherne, he bristled up again.
"What can that possibly have to do with the case?" he said. "I decline to say anything about Miss Lanherne."
"I beg you," said Tolefree. "It has every thing to do with the case. In my opinion Miss Lanherne's visit to Treneglos was the originating cause of Tolliver's murder. I can't say more than that: it's an opinion."
"Even if Tolliver was murdered, and even if Miss Lanherne's visit had some relation to his murder, the fact that I saw Miss Lanherne, if I did see her, cannot possibly have anything to do with the case."
"Believe me," Tolefree insisted, "every circumstance of that visit is relevant. I'm trying to make it as easy for you as I can."
He picked up a pen from the tray in front of the throne and drew patterns on the blotting paper.
"I'll ask you only one question," said he; "but I must state what I know before I put it. I know, Mr. Penhaligon, that on several occasions you and Miss Lanherne did meet—walked together and talked. Nothing in that——"
"Nothing but a lot of confounded paul-prying! That was what you were after, with your precious affidavit, was it?"
He fired the question fiercely at me.
"Not at all," said I. "You read the affidavit——"
But Tolefree waved all this away.
"Nothing in it, Mr. Penhaligon," said he. "Here's my question: during that time did you ever see Miss Lanherne in the company of any other person? Or did she mention meetings with any other person?"
"She never spoke of anyone but Tolliver, and not much of him after I'd indicated that I didn't like the subject. I never saw her with anyone but old Menhennick and Ridgway. I believe Ridgway was acquainted with her father."
Tolefree sighed.
"Then, Farrar, that disposes of the second point, I think?"
"It does," said I.
"And we can thank Mr. Penhaligon for his kindness and courtesy and take our leave."
Tolefree could not resist that Parthian shot.
"THE stuffy ass! The pompous little mountebank!..."
Tolefree produced several other choice characterizations of Mr. Penhaligon as we drove back to Tresneven. He proclaimed them at intervals, apparently after cogitation upon the pithiest form of words. Epitomized, his judgment on Mr. Penhaligon declared that eminent squire to be certainly a fool and probably a liar, but anyhow a thing of no consequence. Nevertheless it was evident that Tolefree had not extracted from him the information for which he hoped.
In the drive at Tresneven we came upon a big car, and on the lawn found Angwin and Miss Carberry playing about with a golf-ball, while her mother and Waverton sat with old Mrs. Angwin under the beech tree, looking on. Having repaired our toilets, we joined the party and shared in their badinage while a maid served tea—since to mention the Tolliver case in the presence of Mrs. Angwin was not permissible: she still looked upon us as two pleasant if rather inexplicable friends of her Arnold.
The Polventor people found their opportunity when the old lady excused herself to go off about some domestic affairs. Then said Waverton, dragging his chair alongside us:
"Well, Tolefree—can you tell us anything? I'm getting confoundedly nervous."
Waverton expressed Mrs. Carberry's feeling as well as his own, if not Ann's too. They were not only nervous. They were afraid. It was in the air—the premonition that Tolefree was about to drag skeletons out of cupboards which they would rather keep closed. I realized that the feeling was growing stronger. They resented the trick Tolefree had played them about his pretended journey. He realized it, too.
"I quite understand," said Tolefree. "Yes—I've no end of things to tell you. But I'm going to be absolutely candid: I don't think you want to hear them."
"Just what does that mean?" asked Mrs. Carberry.
"That some of the things I have to tell may be unpleasant for you. We must face up to that, you know, Mr. Waverton. And I hate to be unpleasant. It's for you to say whether I go on to the final discovery and chance what I find on the way. I'm quite willing to pull out now if you like and leave the field to Mr. Marrack—who's still inclined to stick to his theory, by the way."
Waverton hesitated, looked at Mrs. Carberry; she looked back at him. Ann broke in:
"But, Mr. Tolefree, you don't believe Marrack's theory is a possible theory, do you?"
Tolefree shook his head.
"You believe that Uncle Bill was murdered, don't you?"
"Undoubtedly. As surely as if I'd seen him die."
"Then," said Ann, "I'm for going on. We must go on. There's nothing else to do. Mr. Tolefree—you think you can find who did it?"
"I do," said Tolefree.
"But the suspense—it's terrible," Mrs. Carberry moaned. "Are you near?"
"So near," Tolefree answered gravely, "that last night I was within a few yards of him. In fact he had another pot-shot at me."
"Good God!" cried Angwin.
"What!—again? Oh, give it up, Mr. Tolefree," said Mrs. Carberry. "Guy!—we must give it up. I could never forgive myself if anything happened—never!"
"I said it ought to have been left to the police," Waverton grumbled. "It's all so dam'd informal and risky—pardon me, Louise——"
"Don't be anxious about me," Tolefree urged them, smiling. "I told you I could look after myself, and here I am, sound as a bell, not a scratch. That's not the question. Look at it and decide from your own point of view. Whether you care to face all the possible revelations."
They did not like. They were quite ready to seize upon Tolefree's personal danger as a pretext for dropping it. Once more, Ann:
"Mother!—Guy!—we just can't give it up! Impossible. If Mr. Tolefree's willing to go on, you must let him."
"Anyway," said Waverton, "we might hear what Tolefree has to say, d'you think, Louise? And then, if—well, you can decide after."
Mrs. Carberry sighed a reluctant approval. Tolefree looked straight at her.
"I shall begin with the crucial unpleasantness, Mrs. Carberry," said he. "Then, if you disapprove, you can stop me at once. I trace the cause of Sir William's death back to last September, when Miss Lanherne was staying at Treneglos and Sir William came down here to see her."
Mrs. Carberry frowned and made no answer.
"Well, you see—it's as I expected. You don't want to pursue the matter by the only road that leads anywhere. So this is where I make my offer to get off. You go back to Polventor and forget my existence. Farrar and I accept Mr. Angwin's hospitality for one night more and then melt away."
Waverton intervened.
"Gone a little too far for that, hasn't it? I'm afraid we'd better grin and bear it, Louise. Go on, Tolefree."
"Well, you know best," said Tolefree.
He went on. He told the story of Ada Lanherne.
He revealed the double reason of the escapade of last night: first, his moral certainty that if he put about the story that he was starting on a journey at night there would be a third attempt to "make him take the count"; next, what he said was the need for camouflaging the visit to Exeter and the inquiries there.
As to the journey (he explained) by letting me personate him and take the risk of a shot in the dark he had hoped to come upon his assailant unawares. But first his assailant struck too soon, and then was too smart for him, too well acquainted with the woods. After the last shot, when I had driven on, he did force his way through the trees within a few yards of the man; but in that intense darkness recognition was impossible—he was nothing but a fleeting shadow among shadows, and after three minutes pursuit became hopeless.
As to the revelations of the nursing-home and the Registry Office at Exeter—but he supposed everyone at Polventor knew all about the final tragedy of Ada Lanherne?
They did, but only in a sketchy way. The fate of Ada Lanherne had been a cloud over their imagination—something scandalous to be hidden. Tolliver was concerned about it, but vague and reluctant: talk of it made him testy. This came out in little bursts—half-finished sentences, mostly from Mrs. Carberry.
"Did you ever hear exactly how Miss Lanherne died?" asked Tolefree quietly.
It seemed that they never actually knew, but made inferences that came near enough to the truth—inferences drawn from all the secrecy and from Tolliver's petulance. Of the girl herself... a brilliant girl, Ann said, frightfully highbrow, immensely lovely, but with a kind of hard brightness, fatalistic...
"Well," Tolefree said, "that's the picture I get of her, made up of little bits of induction—from Ridgway, from Menhennick, from the account Farrar brought back to-day—sort of âme damnée. That was your notion too, Farrar?"
"Yes," I said, "Miss Carberry has hit it—fatalism: a sense of doom and a resolve to fight for some sort of happiness to the bitter end."
"The bitter end," Tolefree went on, "was death in labour, and her child died almost before it had lived. You perceive that if, as I think, the tragedy of Ada Lanherne led to the tragedy of Sir William Tolliver, some circumstances cannot be kept secret—for instance, that Sir William arranged for her reception in the nursing-home, that he paid all the expenses and discharged the cost of the funeral, and that for all anyone knows at Exeter the two bodies buried in the cemetery there are those of Mrs. Lanherne, a widow, and her infant son."
"Monstrous!" cried Ann. "I don't believe it. Uncle Bill never would——"
"I think, Mr. Waverton, it would be obviously better to forget it all and let me fade out," said Tolefree.
Waverton, as ever, looked to Mrs. Carberry. Ann burst out again:
"No! You can't! I don't mean that. What I mean is that the idea of Uncle Bill being anything but a decent man's all wrong. Such a generous man—helping a girl because she was down, concealing her secret. And then, all this—it's monstrous! But you must go on, Mr. Tolefree—you must! Have it all out, and then we'll see who's right about him. Arnold!—say a word. You don't believe all this?"
She shook Angwin's sleeve. Her adorer woke up from the trance in which he had listened to the talk, and said the inevitable:
"I agree with Ann. She's right."
"I'm inclined to agree with her too," said Waverton. "I'm afraid I do, Louise," as Mrs. Carberry gave him an anxious glance. "But it seems to me, Tolefree, that if there was anything in all this—well, wouldn't it rather be circumstantial evidence for suicide?"
"It might be circumstantial evidence," Tolefree replied. "But such evidence doesn't stand against actual physical evidence."
"We haven't heard of any, have we?"
"Yes. We have. I can tell you what 'tis. But—pardon me if I repeat myself: the consequences of producing it may be highly painful."
Waverton pondered this.
"I'm trying to see what the consequences must be. If Tolliver was mixed up in this Lanherne affair, and if he didn't commit suicide, and if, as you say, the Lanherne affair's the cause of his death, then—is it a theory of vengeance?"
"Who can say till we lay hands on the murderer?"
Waverton got up and stood in front of Mrs. Carberry in the overmastering way I disliked so fiercely; but I now had to admit to myself that there was no more real reason for the feeling than was adduced by Tom Brown for his detestation of Dr. Fell. Waverton was very much in earnest.
"Louise," he said, "I think we've got to go through with it now, whatever happens. If Tolefree has physical evidence—you know, even supposing he drops the business, somebody else may find it. At least, I suppose so, Tolefree?"
"Quite likely," Tolefree agreed.
"And then, having been told of this, if we do nothing—aren't we implicated in some way? What do they call it?—accessories after the fact?"
"Oh, well," said Tolefree, "that's police jargon. And we're not the police. Legally, Tolliver is a suicide. But all that's confused and remote. Decide from your own point of view, as I said just now."
Waverton went back to his chair.
"I'm for going on," he said.
"And I," said Tolefree, "that's police jargon."
Mrs. Carberry resigned herself. "Very well," she sighed; "but—poor William!"
Tolefree went on again. Mrs. Angwin came out on the terrace, saw us in a close circle under the beech tree, and returned into the house, waving a hand to her son.
First, Tolefree asked Waverton a question. When, on his fishing-trip in September, he met Ridgway at Treneglos, did Ridgway say anything of a visit from Tolliver? No, said Waverton; Ridgway was full of Penhaligon, and he put nothing on that, thinking Ridgway almost unaccountable for his actions; but he did tell Menhennick to keep an eye on him. There was one other point, Tolefree said—about Baripper. Did Waverton on that occasion hear anything of Baripper's presence in the neighbourhood? Waverton heard nothing.
Thereupon Tolefree laid out the case as it stood at the moment in a series of propositions with the evidence he had to support them. Five pairs of eyes watched him intently as he ticked off the points on his fingers:
(1) That Tolliver did not commit suicide. The circumstantial improbability of a suicide had been well stated by Ann: suicide was not in Tolliver's make-up. But no need to worry about probabilities. For suicide was a physical impossibility.
"Impossibility?" Waverton exclaimed. "Surely no one can say definitely that it was impossible?"
"Yes," said Tolefree; "I can. The bullet which killed Tolliver could have been fired from Tolliver's own revolver—that is to say, it was a bullet of the same calibre as his. But as a matter of fact it was not."
"How——?" Waverton's astonishment left the question in the air.
"Oh, it's quite simple," said Tolefree. "I obtained both the revolver and the bullet and submitted them to the experts at Scotland Yard who go in for photometric examination. They can say definitely by the markings it bears whether any given bullet has passed through any given barrel. This bullet had not passed through this barrel."
"Amazing!" said Waverton. "A tremendous coincidence—for there must have been two shots—that is, supposing the one empty shell in Tolliver's gun was discharged then?"
"I think it was," said Tolefree, "and I'll tell you why." He went on with his points.
(2) That Tolliver was murdered by a person with an overpowering motive for killing him.
The circumstantial evidence for this was the same as in the first point; Tolliver's character and reputation being such that only a mighty, even a resistless emotion would account for the crime. The physical evidence was an accumulation of facts.
Tolefree put the facts in a category:
(a) That though Waverton and Angwin and Ann, who were all on the scene within a few minutes, believed that Tolliver had died alone and unseen, his death was witnessed by at least two people, and probably by three. There was Ridgway and there was Gannett. Penhaligon denied that he was near at the time, but that remained to be proved.
(b) That not one shot but three were fired.
(c) That the conduct of several people who were probably aware of this indicated their knowledge or suspicion of a crime.
(d) That while Tolefree was investigating the case, three efforts were made to put a stop to his activities in the most conclusive of all ways.
It was curious that Mrs. Carberry and Waverton at once fastened upon Ridgway—or it seemed so to me, though I suppose it was not really unnatural, in view of his eccentricities. Tolefree disillusioned them at once.
"Ridgway was not the man, though he did fire one of the three shots," he said. "The extraordinary fact is that he himself believes that he shot Tolliver—and there you have the reason why it's so hard to get at the truth."
"He fired—he believes he killed—and yet you say he didn't——"
Waverton's amazement was shared by the others.
"How can you possibly know, Mr. Tolefree?" asked Mrs. Carberry.
"Admitted—it's extremely strange," Tolefree replied. "Because, if that overpowering motive was vengeance, and if Ridgway believed Tolliver to have wronged the girl he worshipped—well——"
"I don't want to butt in, Tolefree," said Angwin, "but have you considered it all round? You remember what I told you... by Jove, Waverton! you were there too!"
"When?"
"That morning when old Ridgway and I overtook you and Tolliver, and he tried to collar Tolliver for a private talk, and, when Tolliver refused, Ridgway told him—what was it?—that he'd regret it as long as he lived?"
"Yes, I remember," said Waverton. "But that?—I imagined that Tolliver thought it was just Ridgway's old bee in his bonnet—some stuff about chemistry, or alchemy—that Ridgway wanted to make a fortune for him and he was just chucking away his chance."
"Still," Angwin insisted, "Tolliver may have been wrong. Suppose Ridgway wanted to talk to him about the girl?"
"Well, of course——"
"But," said Tolefree, "we needn't spend time on it. Ridgway may have been full of the Lanherne business or of something else that day. I give a guess that it was Miss Lanherne. I feel certain that when he hid in the woods on the morning of the murder, he was there for revenge. But that's neither here nor there now, because Ridgway certainly didn't kill Tolliver, and the physical evidence is the same as before: the bullet that killed Tolliver wasn't fired from Ridgway's old gun, and couldn't have been fired from it."
"The third shot, then? Who fired it?" Waverton demanded.
"I don't know—but I shall," Tolefree declared, "if as the result of this consultation you decide to go on to the end. I rather hope you will, in a way," he smiled, "for it was the same person who tried for me."
"And you've got a line on him, Tolefree?"
"Not what the police would call a line. But I hope to discover immediately a conclusive piece of evidence, that's all. If I were the police, with police powers, I'd wring it out of Gannett, for he knows. But I've no powers, and I can't threaten. I'll have to get it myself."
"Gannett! Do you mean he knows? He saw—this?"
"Certainly. He's a nasty bit of human mechanism, Gannett. He saw—and his knowledge is a private gold mine to him, or at any rate a private brewery. We know he hated Tolliver—and he had the luck, the inconceivable luck, to see another man execute his own vengeance! He's now proceeding to blackmail his victim. Gannett's very flush these days. He's got no more use for Penhaligon—thrown him over; says what he thinks of him. Believes he's made for life: unlimited beer and no more work."
"The foul dog!" exclaimed Waverton.
"Yes, isn't he? But I don't think the easy beer will hold out long. He'll have to squeal in due course." Tolefree paused a moment and glanced round the circle. "Now you'll be surprised," he said. "There's another person knows a lot more than he's willing to admit, and that's Mr. Andrew Baripper."
"Baripper!"
That was a chorus.
"You can't mean, Mr. Tolefree——" Mrs. Carberry's scepticism about Tolefree's meaning petered out in an exclamation.
"Don't rush to conclusions," he begged. "But consider Baripper. No one seems to have thought of asking him where he was at the time of the murder. He was out walking, and he returned afterwards——"
"Just as they were taking Tolliver's body into the house," said Angwin.
Waverton nodded.
"But it's an established fact that during the walk he had met or seen Gannett."
"Gosh!" cried Angwin. "And he said nothing about it!"
"He didn't. But he may very likely ask, why should he? You see, Angwin, no one else knew then what we know now. Gannett wasn't in the swim. But cast your memory back to Treneglos and September, and Baripper's visit to Miss Lanherne. And then—well, you don't know this, but I can tell you: Baripper's been here for some days, prowling about the gorge by night with a torch—looking for something."
"Baripper!"
All their bewilderment was in that echoed name.
"Looking for what?" said Ann.
"Ah, if we knew, Miss Carberry! But, speaking generally, looking for evidence."
"Evidence? Ah—I see!" cried Waverton. "Evidence may be removed if it can be discovered. But—Baripper!"
Tolefree's mouth twisted for an instant into a smile.
"How little we know of each other!" said he. "To find Baripper leaving the golden pavements of the City to wander by night up and down that wild place—along the river-bank, up the path to the cliff, through the track among the rocks, prying all over the ground with a searchlight—seeking, and seeking. Someone dropped something: Baripper wants to find it. I believe you never saw a soul in the neighbourhood that morning?"
"No," said Waverton, frowning in an effort at recollection. "Tolliver and I went down and parted on the river-bank. I came back to look for my fly-book, saw it just as Arnold and Ann showed up. No—not a soul."
"Well—there you are," said Tolefree. "There's a bit of evidence that's badly wanted. That's clear, isn't it? And it will be tried for again. It's probably the exact thing that will make the case click. Now, I think I've shown you all the cards. You see what going on may involve, Mrs. Carberry. It's up to you."
Mrs. Carberry shuddered.
"Dreadful!" she muttered.
"You can't help yourself, Louise," said Waverton.
"Of course not, mother," said Ann.
Tolefree waited a moment. No one spoke.
"Then," said he, "to-morrow is Friday. If you will receive me at Polventor to-morrow morning, I will tell you who shot Sir William Tolliver—and you can do what you like about it."
"STILL keeping a jolly fine poker face, Farrar," said Tolefree.
"Fulsome compliment," I growled. "Why, you haven't even dealt me a hand yet!"
"Not so. A truly delicate bouquet. No one would guess from your expression that you could ever register curiosity about anything! But we'll soon ease the strain..."
Mrs. Angwin had dined with us; we'd talked scenery and weather and gardening with her (astonishing how much Tolefree knew about gardening, seeing that he rarely saw any other plants than the shrubs on the south side of St. Paul's!); listened with sympathetic murmurs to her eulogies of Arnold and with knowing smiles to her apologies for his absence. She had excused herself soon after, vanished to her room; we were in Angwin's study, waiting for the dusk to fall.
Tolefree displayed an unaccustomed restlessness this evening—wandered about the room, surprised me by picking up the telephone-book, looking out a number and calling it.
"Is that Polventor?... I want to speak to Mr. Toms... Oh, that you, Toms? Tolefree speaking.... Just this: have you found a beech-nut yet?... Not one, really?... Nothing but empty husks?... Well, well. All right, Toms. Keep your eyes skinned... By the way, haven't seen anything of Mr. Baripper this evening, I suppose?... Oh, yes, staying in the village; I thought he might have been around your way... Well, good night, Toms."
"Of all the tomfooleries, Tolefree," said I, "this beech-nut business——"
"Ah—just a little private joke between me and Toms, based on my abysmal ignorance of the habits of the beech tree. Anyhow, I wanted a disarming introduction to the real question—kind of grace before meat."
He wandered again. He opened a book-case, took out a volume or two, fluttered the leaves, put it back. Finally he came round the table and sat swinging a leg from it as he filled his pipe.
"Farrar, you're the best scout in the world," said he.
"You mean I'm a long-suffering and amiable duffer," said I. "But nothing could provoke me into asking you a question now, Tolefree. It won't come off."
"Exactly. I dare say you've reached the same conclusion as I have—that we'd have done much better to take a holiday in the Highlands or on the Norfolk Broads, and left this weird country severely alone."
"Holiday seems an excessive description of it, so far," I admitted.
"Yet it's an experience. What is it?—Aetas, usus semper aliquid apportet novi? For instance, you've learnt the value of a poker face. Every poker-player should read up the neo-physiognomists from Bell to Darwin, identify the seventh nerve and get it under control. A most fascinating study—and generally neglected, fortunately for me."
"What's the seventh nerve?"
"Controls the facial muscles. It's my talisman, Farrar. Lucky for me I didn't live in good Queen Elizabeth's days."
"Why? You'd have been a nuisance to the gentle grafters of the time," I suggested.
"Ah, but in that time the gentle grafters had a short way with people like me. You don't study enough old treatises on necromancy. I must rub this up with Ridgway. Any person who then feigned to have knowledge of physiognomy or like fantastical imaginations was ordered to be stripped naked from the middle upwards and openly whipped till his body be bloody."
"And I believe," said I, "that if a poor broken shipbroker had begged his bread from door to door he'd have had his ears cut off. So I'm even with you. But where does all this tend, Tolefree?"
He lit his pipe and puffed a cloud.
"Oh, I was just thinking that there's nothing new under the sun—at least, since Aristotle."
"I suppose Aristotle knew all about radio and television and the gold standard," said I.
"No doubt. So much of Aristotle has been lost. But not his treatise on physiognomy. I think we're going to have a very curious experience, Farrar."
"Since you're here I don't doubt it," I assented. "But I hope there won't be any more point-blank shooting in it."
"Kamerad!" he exclaimed. "But I'm serious. A very curious experience indeed. I'm going to prove an apparently water-tight impossibility by evidence as yet unseen. I'm going to make Tolliver's elusive murderer convict himself. And the only reason why I shall succeed if I do succeed is that very fantastical imagination which in the sixteenth century would have earned for me a raw back."
"And you expect me still to keep a poker face!"
"For a little while, Farrar—a very little while. To-night's the night, Farrar!"
He was certainly a bit excited for Tolefree—with what good reason soon appeared. Not that he foresaw the experience which lay in front of us. In fact, he didn't: he was out on the trail of that final bit of what he called "physical evidence"—the thing Baripper wanted to find.
"Did you bring anything with rubber soles?" he asked. I had in my luggage a pair of shoes with crêpe soles. "Get 'em on, Farrar. We're going to shadow the great financier Baripper in his sylvan haunt. By the way, you didn't know he was there again last night, searching? And not finding?"
"You saw him? After that——"
"Yes, I saw him after that noisy little episode in the road. Thought I'd like to take a few more eye-measurements, so I went along—and sure enough he was there."
Undoubtedly Tolefree was right. If I had known that before we had our chat with Baripper in the afternoon, my poker face would surely have broken down. But he!—toying with Baripper like a cat with a mouse.... I looked queerly at his genial, smiling face.
We set out at a quarter to ten across the darkening moor, after he had got a key from the maid, said we might be late, and Mr. Angwin, when he returned from Polventor, wasn't to wait up for us. A little breeze from the sea stirred the heather, and strengthened as we rose higher. Stronger the better, said Tolefree; it would deaden any sound we made.
It took us half an hour to reach the bridge over the Tolgerth river. By then it was dark. Ten minutes later we were stealing along in the shadow of the rock barrier, invisible almost to ourselves. We seemed to be quite alone. Nothing showed in all the landscape but a light at distant Polventor. We reached the little pass, went quickly and noiselessly by it. Tolefree led me in among the rocks by the same way as two nights before, and I clambered after him cautiously till he stopped at our previous observation point, overlooking the path down into the gorge.
All below was perfect gloom: even the path itself was invisible. But no one could show a light anywhere between us and the river without casting a tell-tale reflection on some rock or bush. For a few minutes we lay on our faces listening rather than watching. Nothing came to our ears but the steady gentle hiss of the wind and the rattle of the stream. A night vigil in such circumstances is trying. I threw my thoughts off it, speculated on the chance that Tolefree had miscalculated. But he was generally right. And Baripper, coming from Carnmenellis, would, like us, have waited for darkness, so that the time——
It was a footstep... A sort of stumble. I dared not put a question to Tolefree, who lay as still as death.
Yes—and another stumble—and then a gleam of light on the rocks at the first elbow of the zig-zag.... He was coming up.
The next minute he was there. I could not see him, but the spot-light from his torch came into view, flitting along the ground in a widening and narrowing circle. It approached very slowly, but at last came on to the section of the path beneath us, always on the ground, searching to and fro. Then I saw the vague shadow of the man behind it. He was right under our eyes, some twenty feet below us, his figure foreshortened, stooping and rising.
He came to a pause. I held my breath. The circle of light rested on the turf at his feet. He took something from his pocket, bent down, seemed to press the something into the ground. In a moment of absent-mindedness I lifted myself on my hands to get a better view—and my crêpe sole shifted or detached a fragment of granite which rattled down with a little sound.
The man started up, switched of his torch. Immediately a yellow blaze blinded me; an explosion deafened my ears as I ducked.
The echoes of the shot died away and I heard thudding footsteps.
Tolefree's hand was on my arm.
"Keep down!" he whispered.
An eternity passed.
"Farrar," said Tolefree in my ear, "wait here ten minutes. If he doesn't come back and I don't either, start off for Tresneven. If I'm not there in an hour from now, ring up the vicar and ask if Baripper's home. If he's not, ring Marrack and tell him to wait up for me. Got all that?"
Tolefree passed me the key of Tresneven and was gone, slipping away silently. I was left with the darkness and a sense of my own bungling inefficiency. If I had only repressed that beastly curiosity, or even kept that foot still!... Baripper seemed at the last moment to have made a discovery—probably the very thing Tolefree wanted to know—and I had literally kicked it away. Impossible now (I doubted whether it would have been advisable anyhow) to go down and look for it myself, even if Baripper had not secured it before the crash came. For I had no light.
The ten minutes passed. I gave good measure. Nothing happened. No one came. I crawled back to the edge of the barrier and set off to walk to Tresneven.
No need to use the key. Angwin came running down the drive to meet me.
"Thank God, Farrar!" he exclaimed; "but where's Tolefree?"
"Oh, he's snooping around somewhere," said I.
"But—tell me, man! where? And when d'you see him last?"
"Oh, no time ago. You're all hot and bothered about something, aren't you? What's wrong?"
"Wrong! I've been simply sweating fear for the last half-hour or more. Are you sure he's all right?"
"Absolutely. Why?"
"Well, if you are——"
We went into the house. In his room, Angwin poured himself a peg of neat whisky.
"You know, Farrar—I'd the very deuce of a fright. I walked back from Polventor—got in half an hour ago. Just as I was about a mile from home, this side of the river, I heard a shot."
"Ah!" said I.
"You, too? Was Tolefree with you?"
"Yes, Angwin."
"Well—when I got home, and found all dark and you two out—you can guess what I imagined."
"My dear fellow, of course! Must have given you a jolt." I made it sympathetic.
"Where've you two been?" he asked. "Have a drink, will you? Gosh, I am relieved! Where were you when that shot was fired? Who fired it?..."
Keep a poker face, Farrar: we're still shy of that bit of evidence! I could almost hear Tolefree saying it.
"Thanks—just a little more soda. We were out walking on the moor. We heard the shot. Then Tolefree left me for an hour to explore. He'll probably be in before twelve."
Angwin flung himself down in a chair.
"Wish the dam' thing was all over!" he exclaimed. "It's getting on all our nerves. Mrs. Carberry and Waverton are like two melancholy storks, and even little Ann's like a sore-headed boy. This business about Tolliver—you know, Farrar, I can't believe it now! 'Pon my life, I can't. I knew Tolliver too well."
"It's a pity that ghost's walking," said I. "I can assure you Tolefree didn't want to raise it. But when it got up——"
"Yes, I know. And Baripper!—good Lord! He's out of my line of country, but he'd have been the last man I should have guessed at."
"Aren't you rather jumping to it about Baripper?" said I. "You remember, Tolefree wasn't explicit, was he?"
"Oh, I don't jump to it: it jumps at me," Angwin answered.
He plainly meant to sit it out and wait for Tolefree. I was going to be in a quandary if Tolefree didn't return and I had to put through those telephone calls. We sat sipping a drink, smoking a cigarette, throwing occasional remarks at each other while the time crept on. A tinkle from the clock under the glass case marked midnight. I put off the solution of my problem for a minute or two, then for five minutes. I was cogitating upon some form of words to explain to Angwin why I hadn't been frank with him when the telephone itself solved the problem for me by breaking into the séance with a long ring.
Angwin leaped at it.
"Eh?" said he. "Yes, he's here... for you, Farrar."
It was Tolefree. Where was he? At Dimott's.
"Dimott's!" I ejaculated.
Yes, he was at Dimott's, and would stay there to-night. He was awaiting Baripper's return. Then it would be too late to get back to Tresneven. He would see me or ring me in the morning.
"Did you get it, Tolefree?"
"Yes, I went back and got it. And it was exactly what I expected. But don't say more over the wire. Go to bed. My apologies to Angwin."
"All right. Good-bye," said I, and put up the instrument to find Angwin staring at me with bolting eyes.
"Tolefree?" he asked hoarsely. "At Dimott's?"
I nodded.
"Is Baripper there?"
"No; Tolefree's waiting for him. He's found what he wanted."
"You mean that—evidence? Oh, my God!"
FRIDAY morning. Waiting for Tolefree...
In the drawing-room at Polventor, a group of nervously excited people affecting calmness. Mrs. Carberry, pale-faced, silent, on a settee in the middle of the room. Waverton astraddle a chair facing her. Angwin, who had driven me over when we received Tolefree's message to meet him at Polventor, lounging in a window-seat looking up like an adoring but anxious dog at Ann, who stood tapping gently on the glass and gazing out over the terrace...
A summer morning, all glorious without. Waverton doing his best, with a description of the climate of Johannesburg, to support the pretence that the beauty of the morning was really a subject of absorbing importance. Mrs. Carberry saying, "Yes, Guy," and fidgeting.
Angwin adoring... Ann tapping... I felt as if I had taken a drug
"Here he is!"
Ann's clear voice broke in. She ceased tapping, left the window. A motor-car's brakes squealed. Toms threw open the drawing-room door:
"Mr. Tolefree, ma'am."
Tolefree looked uncommonly grave as he walked across the room to shake hands with Mrs. Carberry and Ann, and nodded round to the rest of us.
"Mrs. Carberry," said he, "my job is finished; I've come to make my final report."
She signalled him to a seat, her pallor deepening. Tolefree pulled a small chair up to a table between two windows and dropped a little newspaper-covered parcel upon it.
"Even now," he said, "I'm quite willing to throw up the commission and go back to London if you say the word, for I'm afraid what I've got to say will be most distressing to you."
"How can you throw it up?"
Ann's face was almost as pale as her mother's, but her little jaw set firmly.
"Quite easily," Tolefree answered. "Your mother asked me to make an inquiry. She can countermand it. I'm not the police. I've told the police nothing of what I've found. So—if your mother wishes, the thing can end here and now."
"No!" said Ann. "It can't! Mother's not the only person concerned. If you know who killed my uncle, Mr. Tolefree, I demand to know too."
Panting—taut-strung, on wires, little Ann. Tolefree's eyes engaged her closely: they gazed at each other for a long moment.
"Miss Carberry," said he, "whatever the decision, I shall always think of you as the bravest girl I ever saw. There's a chance to draw back."
"Go on!"
She spoke sharply, as almost resenting Tolefree's speech.
"Whatever comes out, Ann?" her mother said.
"Yes—whatever comes out."
She stood with her back to the window, her arms straight down and her fists clenched. Mrs. Carberry sighed.
"I suppose you'd better go on, Mr. Tolefree."
He seemed to weigh the meaning of this reluctant permission.
"Before I come to the point where you won't be able to turn back," he said slowly, "I wonder if I can indicate somehow the nature of the things that must come out? Then you can, if you think well, stop me anywhere in the story. How will that be?"
"Very well," she said.
"Then," Tolefree began, "I'll start with the assumption that I know nothing, either of the visit of Miss Lanherne last year, or of the possible relations between her and Sir William Tolliver. Just as it seemed to me at the beginning. I come down, unaware of anything in the case but what the newspapers have told everyone about the inquest and the verdict. I have just the superficial facts without the atmosphere. The first person I encounter is Ridgway, of whose very existence I am ignorant. The first thing I learn about Ridgway, in the first ten seconds after I see him, is that he walks about with a revolver on his hip, and in the first ten minutes, when Mr. Angwin has explained him to me a little, I conclude that he has already been informed of me. That conclusion is strengthened when a few hours after I became the target for a pistol shot."
Tolefree paused.
"I'm quite wrong in both those hasty conclusions," he continued. "As you all know, Ridgway, whatever his intentions, counted for nothing in the death of Tolliver. And there was no reason why he should shoot at me, for in fact he knew nothing about me. I could not then have guessed at the other man in the neighbourhood who, knowing of my visit, was most anxious either to frighten me out of it or to give me my quietus if he couldn't."
A little gasp from Waverton.
"Well, of course, Mr. Waverton," said Tolefree, "as soon as I saw how the land lay with Ridgway, I began to look about for that man, and found him. But, as you must see, even before I had found him, with this intimation that I was an unwanted interloper, I couldn't resist the natural inference: someone meant that the comfortable theory that Tolliver committed suicide should not be disturbed. How could I resist that inference?"
"No—I suppose not," sad Waverton.
"Then, also, my first talk with Miss Carberry had made me certain. She backed up her intuition with a character-sketch of her uncle which left no doubt at all. So that when next morning I went over the ground and came here to see you all, I knew that I had in fact a murder to investigate. A clever and a most callous murder. Done by a man who thought he had a perfect alibi. And it was perfect—too perfect. Its very perfection has led me to him."
Tolefree paused again. We hung on his words.
"Strange how luck alternately favoured and disfavoured him! He could never have dreamed of the luck—it was inconceivable—that, just as he was about to shoot, Ridgway would shoot and Tolliver would reply, and that Ridgway would go away believing he had killed Tolliver. Or of the equally miraculous luck that Tolliver would be standing at a place where his body would fall, or could easily be pushed, into the river, with his pistol beside him. Or of the still more incredible luck that all three shots would come so close together as to be mistaken by Penhaligon, who was down in the valley, for the reverberations of one. He could set about preparing the evidence of his alibi with a clear conscience—save the mark!
"But then the luck turned. He did not know until the alibi was theoretically perfect that he'd been seen by both Ridgway and Gannett. Oh, no," as Waverton uttered an exclamation, "I don't mean that either of them saw him shoot. But they saw enough to destroy the alibi. That is to say that if they saw him from their positions at any time within five minutes before or after the shooting, the alibi was gone."
"It's extraordinary, Tolefree," said Angwin. "I don't doubt you've worked it out. But, you see, neither Ridgway nor Gannett said a word. I don't understand why."
The point must have been in everyone's mind.
"Unless," Waverton remarked, "Tolefree's induced them to speak."
Tolefree shook his head.
"No. Neither has spoken. It's pure inference. Ridgway's conduct can only be accounted for by the supposition that he thought his shot had killed Tolliver, whereas we know it did not. Gannett is obviously blackmailing on the strength of his secret. I've not tried to force Ridgway's hand: he's so incalculable that he would certainly have scared my bird away the moment he had an inkling of the truth. I've tried hard with Gannett, but he's a tough scoundrel. The police could force him, no doubt—but, Mrs. Carberry, because of the great delicacy of all this"—he waved a hand around—"I've not brought the police into it, but allowed Marrack to go on thinking himself right. So that it's all a matter of inference. You'll find it inexorable, but if the police are to come in, it's you who must call them in, Mrs. Carberry."
She looked helplessly to Waverton. He frowned.
"Well—pure inference, Tolefree," said he, "I don't know. But let's hear what it is."
"All right. Consider what must have happened down there," Tolefree resumed. "You leave Tolliver at the bottom of the zigzag path. He goes downstream ten minutes' walk. In another ten minutes or so he is killed. I don't suppose he sees who killed him. But we know it couldn't have been Ridgway, and it wasn't Gannett, who carried only a shot-gun. Therefore the murderer was armed with a revolver, and must have lain in wait for Tolliver, or trailed him, with the deliberate intention of killing him."
Mrs. Carberry shuddered and cried out.
"Such a murder," said Tolefree, "must have an intensely powerful motive. Where do we look for it? Three sets of motives carry strong impulses to crime. Perhaps the greatest is the set of passions—love, hatred, jealousy, vengeance. Who wanted Tolliver's money? And who feared Tolliver? When we discussed the possibilities, Miss Ann, and lit on Ridgway and Gannett and Penhaligon, I thought Penhaligon's idiotic feud with your uncle hardly a motive at all, Gannett's sullen hatred not enough for this. Ridgway? When the facts came out about Miss Lanherne, both Farrar and I had seen him deeply moved. Vengeance might have stirred a man of that kind to anything: in fact it did. But he was not the murderer. I had to infer a murderer who was neither of those three, and when I had inferred him, to discover a leak in his alibi...
"I could divine his motive, even imagine his method. But to prove that he was guilty—that needed some tangible piece of evidence, something the police could handle. Mr. Baripper!—he gave it to me. Mr. Baripper searching the gorge!—it shed a sudden light. Timing the movements of all the people who might be involved was difficult so long after the crime. But putting all the information together, I saw that one fact could not be reconciled with the timing anyhow."
He picked up the parcel; dropped it.
"It was the time of the shot itself. You and Miss Carberry heard it, Angwin, and your time showed that it could not have been fired before eleven o'clock. Penhaligon heard it, and he gives watertight evidence that it could not have been fired after ten-fifty, for he was in his house half a mile away at eleven. I perceived that Mr. Baripper was searching for the one piece of evidence which would reconcile those two irreconcilables."
The light which had dawned on Tolefree when the beam of his torch flashed across Baripper's features now began to dawn upon me.
"By the way, if I may interrupt the argument for a moment, Mrs. Carberry, I should like to ring for Toms," said Tolefree. He touched a bell-push on the wall above the table. We all looked in silence at the door till Toms pushed it open.
"May I?" Tolefree asked. "Toms, Mr. Baripper should be here by now. When he comes, show him straight in here."
"Mr. Baripper's waiting in the study, sir," said Toms.
"Then bring him along now. By the way, Toms, did you find a sound nut for me?"
"Sorry, sir; not one."
The intrusion of this ludicrous theme at such a moment smote everyone with amazement. But when Toms had gone out, Tolefree explained.
"You'll pardon my apparent levity, Mrs. Carberry. But till you've decided this grave matter it's just as well to keep up a light touch with the servants."
And before anyone could comment on Tolefree's peculiar sense of humour, Baripper was in the room. A cold air seemed to come in with him. He could not have failed to observe its effect upon us. But he appeared to be complete master of himself. He bowed slightly to the ladies, said, "How do, Tolefree? Shall I sit here?" and planted himself at a little distance from the group.
Not the free-and-easy Baripper of Carnmenellis, in the old blazer and the flannel bags. A keen, somewhat supercilious Baripper, in a dark blue suit, his dark hair smooth, his dark eyebrows arched, his dark eyes shining behind the horn-rimmed glasses.
"We were discussing the circumstances of the death of Sir William Tolliver, Mr. Baripper," said Tolefree. "I have already told you some of the difficulties that I find in accepting the official account of it."
"Yes," said Baripper. "And I have told you that I also find difficulties."
His tone was even, round, steady. He might have been talking about the price of Converted Stock.
"True, you have. The point at which we had arrived when you came in was this. I had said that I believe Tolliver was murdered by a person with a powerful motive for desiring his death, but I had not yet revealed my reasons for fastening the murder on that person."
Baripper did not blink an eyelid.
"I had explained that the question of an accusation was a question for the police, that my job was to complete an inquiry and leave the decision as to any action upon it to Mrs. Carberry, who gave me my commission. You agree?"
"Perfectly," said Baripper.
"Then, as your name has been mentioned in the case, Mr. Baripper, I propose to explain the critical point in it which we have now reached. I was saying that the chief difficulty in my mind was to reconcile the times involved in the evidence. According to Mr. Waverton, Miss Carberry and Mr. Angwin, the shot was fired not before eleven, and according to Mr. Penhaligon, who also heard it, not later than ten minutes to eleven. Both things cannot be true."
"Obviously not," said Baripper.
"And the truth can only be established by some piece of evidence which will definitely show whether either of them is right or both are wrong."
"That's a truism, too," said Baripper.
"I'll venture upon another, Mr. Baripper: that it would be to the advantage of the murderer to remove or obliterate that evidence."
"It would."
"Would you like to say whether you were looking for it on three nights this week in the gorge by the light of an electric torch?"
A catch in the breath of everyone—except Baripper, who said, coldly:
"Whatever I looked for, I found nothing."
"No," said Tolefree. "Because you were disturbed. Well, I found it, Mr. Baripper."
"Indeed?"
"Yes. But before I tell you about that, will you say here what you said to me: that you proposed marriage to Miss Lanherne last September, and that she refused you?"
"Certainly. You've said it."
"Did you learn that Miss Lanherne's death occurred in certain tragic circumstances?"
"Yes, I did."
"From whom?"
"From Tolliver."
"And can I assume that you were pretty angry with the man who was the cause of Miss Lanherne's indifference to you—and in a sense of her death?"
"You can," said Baripper. "Angry is a mild way of putting it. I thought the dog ought to be——"
"Perhaps," Tolefree interrupted him, "it would be wiser not to go on, Mr. Baripper."
He turned from Baripper to us.
"I can tell you, Mr. Waverton, what will reconcile the irreconcilable. The shot you heard when you were looking for your fly-book was not the shot that killed Tolliver. That was fired some minutes before, when Penhaligon heard it."
"Good God!" said Waverton. "You know that? For certain?"
"Yes—I'm sure of it beyond the shadow of a doubt. I have the evidence in my pocket."
All our eyes wavered between Tolefree and Baripper, who sat rigidly still.
"Without a doubt," Tolefree repeated. "And now, Mrs. Carberry, it rests with you. Am I to go on? I warn you that the consequences will be serious."
"Oh, it's dreadful!" she moaned. "I don't know what to say."
"You do, mother!" Ann cried out. "There's only one thing to say. Mr. Tolefree—go on!"
The poor woman buried her face in Waverton's sleeve.
"I suppose you must," came in a muffled voice.
"I'm sorry, but I think you're right," said Tolefree. "The man who killed Sir William Tolliver is in this room."
It could hardly have been unexpected by anyone. Yet the thing came like a knife-thrust to me, and I looked at a circle of horrified faces.
Waverton raised Mrs. Carberry's head from his arm, and got up.
"In that case, Tolefree," he said, "I suppose I'd better go and call the police?"
"It would be well," Tolefree agreed. "Will you take Mrs. Carberry and Miss Ann away with you? Farrar and Angwin and I will stay here."
"Tolefree!" said Baripper, in a hard voice, "you're playing a dangerous game."
"I take my own risk, Mr. Baripper," said Tolefree. "You'll remain with us?"
They passed out, Waverton holding the door for the two women. And this was the man of whom three or four days before I had nursed such unholy suspicions!...
The four of us were left. Tolefree's look rested on Baripper, still seated a little apart from us.
"What next, Tolefree?" said Baripper.
"WHAT next, Tolefree?"
The same metallic voice—as though Baripper were reprimanding him. So a schoolmaster might have addressed a stubborn pupil, or a sarcastic sergeant-major his recruit. What next, indeed!
Angwin, with a look like awe in his face, stared at the trim figure sitting apart; probably my own expression was not much different. But Tolefree eyed him sadly.
"I don't know what next, Mr. Baripper. You heard what Waverton said——"
"Preposterous!" Baripper was very near barking.
"You think so? Well, I'm not so sure. Maybe. Would you care to go and call the police yourself?"
"Don't talk dam' nonsense, Tolefree!"
Tolefree felt in his waistcoat pocket, took out a scrap of metal and weighed it in his hand.
"There's the evidence," said he, and put it on the table. A little elongated piece of lead.
Baripper rose and bent over it.
"Yes," he said.
"And this is yours, Mr. Baripper." He passed on the newspaper parcel. Baripper took it, stripped off the paper, handled a small garden trowel. "You left it behind. I found it useful. Thanks."
"Dimott's," said Baripper. "Better keep it. The police may want it."
"They may, but I think that rather depends on what you do. Doesn't it?"
"How the devil can it depend on me?" Baripper growled, and went back to his chair.
All this went on in a conversational way, except when Baripper's voice, raised a tone or two, betrayed his agitation.
"I asked you—what next?" he said. "What are you going to do, Tolefree? Do we sit here till——"
"Doing nothing more, Mr. Baripper. I've finished by job. Now it's up to them. But if you ask me for my opinion, I don't think they'll call the police."
"I should jolly well think they won't!" Baripper exclaimed. "Hanged if I understand you, Tolefree."
"No? Well, I dare say you don't. You've had your mind on vengeance for a week, and much wrath clouds the understanding. Iracundia non vult regi, you know. You've been seeing red, and you think the sky's on fire for everyone. But it's not for me, Mr. Baripper. I'm not thinking of tragedies past. They're done with. I'm thinking of Mrs. Carberry and her daughter."
"Yes, yes—but——"
"Mr. Baripper," Tolefree burst in upon him, "you forget Angwin. He's here—and he's probably completely in the dark. It would be considerate——"
"Good heavens! D'you mean you haven't told him?"
"What opportunity have I had of telling him?"
"Then for God's sake tell him now. Look at him! What are you thinking, Angwin? Dam'd if I don't believe you're thinking I killed Tolliver!"
Angwin gasped, tried to speak, and failed.
"And there's Farrar, too," said Tolefree.
"Oh, Farrar?—he's in your confidence."
"Not an inch," Tolefree declared. "Don't you understand, Mr. Baripper, that I dared not breathe a suspicion to anyone—anyone?" he repeated. "Farrar made me sweat on Monday night. Lord knows how, but somehow or other he hit on the truth. Sheer inspiration—not a shred of evidence. But I had to get proof, and till last night I hadn't got it. Even the slightest premature hint in Farrar's manner—you see? the whole thing would have collapsed. I had to fob Farrar off, keep him busy. But last night——"
Tolefree picked up the bullet; it clicked sharply as he dropped it.
A dead silence followed, Angwin staring at Tolefree with horrified eyes. My own feelings—a little pride over my intuition and half of annoyance at Tolefree's lack of confidence and his cavalier treatment of me—was unimportant then. More to end the strain for Angwin than to get one back on Tolefree, I said:
"Anyhow, there's no more need for poker faces now, is there?"
Tolefree sighed.
"No—but I hate the thought of the blow to that poor woman! Mr. Angwin—you've realized by now what this painful scene meant? That it was——"
"Guy? Good God! And he's with Ann and her mother!"
Angwin started up. Tolefree put a hand out to restrain him.
"Let them go," said he.
"Tolefree!" cried Baripper, "you're wrong! It won't do."
"If Mr. Angwin takes my advice, he will wait," said Tolefree quietly. Angwin fell back into his chair. "I can't prevent him from doing anything he wishes—or you either, Mr. Baripper. You can go and call the police if you like. But if you do, and Waverton's arrested—you saw what happened between those two just now, even while she thought you were the murderer. Let things take their course. If Waverton attempts to bolt—well, easy enough to get him. But he won't. I'd stake anything on it. He's played his big gamble and lost. I guess I know my man."
Baripper shrugged his shoulders; the room slumped into silence. It was Angwin who broke it.
"Guy Waverton?... Poor Louise!..." Then he started up again. "Tolefree, it's incredible! Are you sure... some damnable mistake?"
"Unfortunately only too sure," said Tolefree, with a headshake. "You saw him just now? Remember, he knew perfectly well I was accusing him."
"Oh!—poor Louise!" Angwin muttered.
"He knew it was all over the moment I called in Mr. Baripper. Last night, he fired point-blank at Mr. Baripper, meaning to kill him——"
"What!" I cried; "that shot?—Waverton?"
"Yes. What did you think?"
I felt too ashamed to admit what I really had thought—that we disturbed Baripper and that he fired at us; I said I thought—well it hardly mattered now.
"I feared something of the sort when Mr. Baripper turned up," said Tolefree. "He was an irrelevance—a nuisance at that moment. But to explain why and how, I'd have to go back over the whole wretched story."
"You must, Tolefree!" Angwin exclaimed. "Even now I can't believe it! Waverton—I can't believe it."
"I wish it weren't true, Mr. Angwin, for your sake and Miss Ann's. But I've had no doubt about it from the first."
"You mean—you've known all along? But you treated Waverton—oh, well, you know how. To treat a man like that if you knew he was a murderer!——"
Tolefree took up the trowel from the table and turned it over between his fingers.
"Does it matter now? He's virtually confessed. I'd like to have spared you. But if you must have it——"
"I can't see that he's confessed, and I've got to be convinced," said Angwin.
"Well, Mr. Baripper doesn't want any convincing. I should judge that he came to the same conclusion as I did, quite independently of me, but for the same reasons."
"Fraternis animis," said Baripper with the shade of a smile. "Yes. I never believed the suicide yarn any more than Ann Carberry did. I was casting about for an explanation from the first moment. Unlike you, Tolefree, I knew my man. So I make no claims. But there it is: you and I had the same idea."
I can hardly hope to convey the sense of doom that filled the pleasant room that sunny morning while Tolefree hastily recounted his calculations and their results. I imagine all of us had half our minds on what was happening or going to happen beyond the door where Waverton and the women had gone.
It was really simple, Tolefree said.
"To fix on the man who killed Tolliver, I had only to discover on Monday morning who had taken a shot at me on Sunday night. Ridgway? A madman might do any mad thing—though you yourself didn't seem to think him quite so mad, Angwin. But long before even I met him Ridgway was out of my calculations. Five minutes after I came into this house on Monday morning, I knew the man who shot at me. Whether he had killed Tolliver or not, that man was Waverton."
"How could you?"
"Physiognomy's rather a hobby of mine, as you know, Mr. Baripper; but I don't suppose it would need much of that for anyone to be aware of a man who had tried to kill him once and still wished him dead. The realization came almost too quickly—for if Waverton conceived the remotest suspicion that I was aware of him, good-bye to any chance of success. He'd only to whisper a doubt of me to Mrs. Carberry and it would be all over. But so long as he thought I was on any trail that would take me nowhere—Ridgway, Gannett, even the absurd Penhaligon or the impossible Baripper—it was his game to play the sedulous assistant, eager to bring a criminal to justice if criminal there were."
"If?" said Baripper. "Did he take that line—if?"
"Yes, now and then. Came back very subtly to the theme of a possible suicide, and a possible motive for it. He's got iron nerves, as you'll see. You remember, Angwin, that we discussed the possibility of a leakage from Polventor—some incautious word that might have given me and my mission away?"
"Yes—and we thought it impossible," said Angwin.
"As it was. Ridgway knew nothing of me on Sunday, when we found him spying round your house, while Waverton, of course, knew everything."
"But, Tolefree, he didn't arrive till Monday morning!"
"Not at Polventor; but he left home on Sunday and Baripper thought he saw him in the afternoon—called on Mrs. Angwin, you remember, and asked if he'd been about. It was undoubtedly on Waverton that Ridgway was spying."
"Yes, I saw him—in the Tresneven woods in the afternoon," said Baripper. "I'd got through to Tolefree's rooms in the morning, meaning to ask him to come down and help me. Heard he'd been employed by the enemy—of course, I didn't know why, or what had happened at Polventor."
"Anyhow, there he was—on the spot in plenty of time for his bit of target practice. Iron nerves.... a dangerous man! Farrar, you now grasp the urgency of the poker face? You couldn't have kept it up if you'd known?"
"Probably not," I admitted.
"Well, Angwin, by the time we went out to look at the gorge that morning, with your narrative in mind, I had come to three determinations:
"First, that Waverton counted for everything in the case, and that his position vis-à-vis Mrs. Carberry would make it very hard to bring home to him.
"Next, that although he seemed to have a perfect alibi he was desperately afraid it might break.
"Further, that if what I saw in Waverton's face and in his conduct was true, the shot you heard could not have been the shot that killed Tolliver, and that if this in turn was true, that shot must be a part of the alibi."
"But who could have fired it?" Angwin cried. "We were in sight of Waverton; we saw him jump up at the sound of the shot—and climb along the rocks till he saw what had happened below. And we heard him yell out that it was Tolliver! I can't believe it even now, Tolefree."
"But it's only too true, Angwin. When you saw him, Waverton was busy establishing his alibi. Looking for the fly-book! And I haven't a doubt agonizing for somebody to come along—because precious time was slipping by. He hailed you joyfully——"
"He did. He shouted out, 'Hello, you two!' Not a bit like a man who'd just done a murder."
"All the same, he had. When you saw him he was stooping. After he shouted to you, he stooped again, looking for that precious fly-book. While he was stooping, you heard the shot."
Tolefree again picked up the bullet from the table and dropped it.
"That was the shot," said he. "He fired it into the turf of the little path. Mr. Baripper—you guessed it?"
"Yes, Tolefree. The same idea occurred to me. But, as I told you, not making any claims about it. If I hadn't known a whole lot more about Waverton than you did, I'd never have guessed it in a thousand years."
"We'll come to that," said Tolefree. "But as for me, I confess I didn't guess it at once. It was what Waverton did after the shot was fired that put his neck in the noose—that climbing along the rocks, and his seeing Tolliver down below."
"How's that?"
"No one seems to have had the curiosity to test Waverton at every point. Indeed, why should anyone have doubted him? Everyone leaped to the suicide theory. As a matter of fact, from no point at all along the top of the gorge can you see the bit of river where Tolliver's body lay."
"What!" cried Angwin.
"I went over every yard of it. There's a view of that fishy pool from the rock beyond the corner where the stream turns west, but nowhere else; and the trees in that little ash coppice absolutely conceal the stickle where Tolliver fell. It was not quite enough in itself for positive certainty; but even as we went down that zigzag to the river, Angwin, it was clear in my mind that Waverton, whether he killed Tolliver or not, well knew he was dead before he hailed you."
Angwin slumped in his chair.
"The rest was a matter of checking up times. Tolliver had walked much farther down the river than Waverton was supposed to have walked up. He'd had time to mount his rod and reel, and was apparently preparing to put on a cast. Time at least twenty minutes. Waverton had ostensibly walked a shorter distance, done nothing to his gear, come back for the fly-book which he probably had in his pocket all the while. Time at most ten minutes. The alibi was breaking, you see. Then came the discovery of a watcher from the other side of the river—Ridgway, which was very suggestive."
"But," said I, "you couldn't have guessed the watcher was Ridgway."
"I guessed a man with a camera—indeed, I saw the flicker of his lens—and calculated Ridgway. It was very suggestive—of what might have happened before. I hadn't then got the hang of it, with Gannett in the scene as well. But naturally Waverton was already well in. He had acted a lie to you; he had tried a shot at me."
"A mere assumption," said Angwin. How reluctant he was to be convinced! "A mere assumption, Tolefree, and as for the lie to us, perhaps, knowing Tolliver was down there——"
His protest tailed off. Tolefree waited a moment; then went on:
"It certainly was an assumption then. But—well, you'll see. I'll go on. Having got Waverton there, as I say, right in the foreground, there were several things to do immediately. To stave off any possibility that he might guess at my thoughts about him, for that purpose I pitched the tale about consulting Marrack and grilling Ridgway and the others. You remember his anxiety about my safety? The nerve of the fellow! Then to get information about him: because at that time I was absolutely stuck for his motive—couldn't see one. But most important of all to prevent him from sending me the same road as Tolliver. So—enter Toms."
"Toms!" Angwin and I exclaimed together.
"Yes, the unobtrusive but essential Toms, who evidently had a considerable affection for Tolliver, and knew all about his habits. You'll recall that I asked Toms to take me up to see Tolliver's room, and the drawer where he kept his pistol—some such trivialities. To get Toms to myself for ten minutes, to take him into my confidence—that was the vital thing."
"Hang it all, Tolefree!" I interjected. "This is pretty good, I think. Angwin and I can't be taken into your confidence because our silly faces are likely to give you away; but Toms——"
"The sort of chicken you hatch shows the quality of the egg, Farrar. You know I don't do anything without a reason, and there was excellent reason for trusting Toms, since Toms was well on the road to my own way of thinking already."
"Toms!" Angwin exploded his incredulity.
"You think it strange?"
"He never gave the slightest sign of any intelligence on the subject whatever," Angwin declared.
"Not to you. Certainly not to Waverton. But, then—the same thing could be said of Miss Carberry."
"Ann? What the devil do you mean?" There was wrath in Angwin's tone. "Ann and I've changed all our thoughts about it times out of number."
"All your deliberate thoughts—formulated thoughts—yes, no doubt," said Tolefree. "But the almost subconscious intimations? The things Toms, a silent looker-on, might see? The things I actually did see? Miss Carberry never said a word to me to suggest the suspicions she was almost afraid to confess to herself. But I sensed them—and Toms had sensed them. The reason why those suspicions were repressed was the same with both of them, and a perfectly splendid reason: it was Mrs. Carberry. You yourself told me, Angwin, of Ann's persistence when you first discussed the reopening of this business. Why did you think she was so determined?"
"Quite natural—she'd been very fond of Tolliver."
"Yes, I know. Still, it seemed to me a little queer that a girl should take that line so obstinately, against the general opinion. But if she had some suspicion, intuition, hint of knowledge—call it what you please—and had to face up to the fearful possibility that her mother might be marrying, well——"
Tolefree raised his elbows. No one spoke.
"I go on. At the top of the stairs I said to Toms, 'I'm not particularly anxious to see Sir William's room, Toms, if you'll get me his gun.' He said, 'Very good, sir.' Then we stood looking in each other's eyes for a long time before I said, 'Think I might see Mr. Waverton's room, Toms?' His answer was queer—but all I wanted. He said, 'I think it might be wise if you did, sir.' I said, 'There's far too much revolver practice going on, Toms. Someone shot at me last night.' And he said, 'Indeed, sir?'—just like that. And added, 'I can't say I'm surprised to hear it.'"
"Gosh!" said Baripper. "And of course he knew all about Waverton's movements!"
"Not then," Tolefree replied. "You must remember that Waverton hadn't turned up at Polventor the night before. No—Toms knew nothing of Waverton's movements then. But he'd done some theorizing with just his general observation of Waverton to go upon. And, as he valeted Waverton, he knew all about his gun. In fact, we'd no sooner got inside the room than he walked to the dressing-table and took it out to show me. And then he said, 'Excuse me, sir,' and went out and came back a minute after with Tolliver's own gun. The passages that took place between me and Toms were all in that style—very little said, just a tacit understanding, based on the fact that he and I had reached the same suspicion. I compared the two revolvers—different makes, but same calibre... Why did Tolliver, who never went about armed, carry his revolver that morning? It puzzled me. Toms had no idea. The light came later. I said, 'I'd much rather there weren't any bullets in this gun, Toms,' and held up Waverton's. It was loaded fully. Several wild notions flitted into my head—such as unloading the gun, stealing the box of cartridges from the drawer, or taking away the complete outfit. Then the real solution came in a flash. I asked Toms where the nearest gunsmith's shop might be. He said Bodmin. I invented an errand to Bodmin for him, and he undertook to go that afternoon, buy a sufficient supply of blank, remove all the loaded shells from gun and box, put blank in their place, and have the whole thing done before dinner. That was my safeguard against Waverton."
"Good Lord! Tolefree," I exclaimed. "And you just laughing in your sleeve while we were all on wires about your danger!"
"Well, my dear Farrar, do you really think I'd have let you sit in that car and be shot at in real earnest?"
"Tolefree!" Baripper said excitedly. "Do I owe my life to you as well?"
"Impossible to tell, Mr. Baripper. No one can say he mightn't have missed you in the dark last night, eh? But, naturally, if I hadn't been sure Waverton's gun was harmless, I'd have created a diversion before you got into danger."
"Phew!" Baripper wiped the moisture from his forehead.
"Toms was great," said Tolefree. "Kept tab on that gun all through, and put me wise about it, though we hardly ever exchanged another word in private. We had a little code—the beech-nuts and beech-mast that seemed to you so frivolous and futile, Farrar. He could tell me all I wanted to know—which was that Waverton had not discovered the cheat and was taking a gun loaded with blank every night when he went for his after-dinner walk. I'd have had him that night when he tried for my bedroom if you hadn't been so careful of my welfare, Farrar. That was a well-planned business, by the way, with the faked burglary at Polventor just in the nick of time to make us all think of any midnight marauder in the world but Waverton himself."
"But Ann——" said Angwin, and stopped.
"Yes—Miss Carberry. I think Miss Carberry saw through it—or suspected. Not that it matters now. Nor the fact that he was too clever for me when I hoped to get him in Tresneven woods on Wednesday. It had to come at last to discovering that bullet in the turf, and as I daren't go there by day and Mr. Baripper set up a sort of pre-emption at night—well! I suppose it was the patch of burnt grass that gave it away to you?"
"Obviously," said Baripper.
"Hard to find," Tolefree declared. "I looked twice for it without any luck."
"When d'you think Waverton began to suspect that it was being looked for?"
"Impossible to say. That habit of going out for a walk after dinner—— May have seen Mr. Baripper's light—or even seen me. He'd probably tried to find it himself: think of his great acting when we talked about the possibility of hidden evidence being taken away! Anyhow, I intended him to be there last night—and he was. I half hoped, even after the scare following his shot, that he'd come back to get it. But that trap didn't work."
Angwin had by this time given up all pretence of doubting Tolefree's solution. He sagged in his chair.
"Guy!" he muttered. "But why? It's like a lunatic's dream."
"To you—yes," said Tolefree. "It would seem like that—something grotesque, unthinkable, motiveless. But to me—no. You looked on Waverton all the time with one blind eye. He was the confidential friend of the house, the fiancé of Mrs. Carberry. You had a fixed idea of him. You looked forward to a closer relation. Why, Angwin, even if he'd not staged that too perfect alibi for you, would you have associated him with a criminal motive? Of course not."
"No, I suppose not," said Angwin.
"Well—see the difference. I've no predispositions towards Waverton. Everyone within a mile is a potential suspect to me as soon as I've determined that Tolliver is not a suicide. I look for clues, and especially for motives. You know, it's often easier to see motive from the outside than from the inside of a case. And Waverton's motive didn't take long to turn up. It came rushing in like daylight when we heard at Menhennick's of the fishing expeditions last September. Bring your mind forward to what happened in that nursing-home last month; imagine Tolliver's reaction to it; and you have a terrible, relentless motive."
He turned to Baripper.
"May I put a delicate question?" he asked. "When Miss Lanherne turned you down, you had the idea she was in love with someone else; but you never thought it was Tolliver?"
"Tolliver? Absurd!" Baripper exclaimed. "Tolliver was just like a second father to her."
"And you didn't then know who the man was?"
"No—not then. Later. You can't ask a thing like that, and she volunteered nothing."
"Later——?"
"Suspicions—conveyed to me privately. There was nothing to be done—only when I saw how the land lay at Polventor when we were here last month, it all cleared up. Even Tolliver's delicacy about his sister's feelings didn't hide the trouble from me. But what a man Tolliver was! He'd have booted out that fellow publicly if it wouldn't have hurt Mrs. Carberry."
"Exactly!" Tolefree exclaimed. "The point I wanted to make, Angwin. Tolliver must have known of the scandal last September—through Ridgway, no doubt, and come down to put the lid on it. Perhaps he thought he'd done so. But he was too late. Now, imagine him when the tragedy in the nursing-home comes to his knowledge. The man responsible for it is in his own house, proposing to marry his own sister. What does he do? He challenges Waverton, gives him marching orders——"
"You can't possibly know."
"Oh, but it's plain enough. That sudden decision of Waverton, announced on the Sunday——"
"Ah!"
"I thought you'd not seen the significance of that, Angwin. I'm pretty sure Tolliver's sudden change of manner on the Sunday was due to the fact that he'd delivered his ultimatum to Waverton; he believed he'd forced Waverton to retire from the field and relieve him of the need for stabbing his sister in the heart by denouncing her lover. They must have had a terrible ten minutes."
Tolefree toyed with the bullet on the table.
"Tolliver was sure that he'd succeeded—sure enough to fix up that last morning's fishing to save appearances. But not sure enough to trust Waverton, or he wouldn't have put that gun in his pocket."
Angwin shuddered.
"I asked Ridgway also to be here this morning," said Tolefree. "Do you mind if we have him in?" He touched the bell-push. "I don't know how much sincerity there is in Waverton's regard for Mrs. Carberry: people are queer. But not much, I should think. I do know that he had a pretty powerful motive for wishing to marry a wealthy woman——"
Toms broke in on him, answering the bell.
"Will you bring Mr. Ridgway, Toms? Thank you."
"I've got Waverton's dossier from the South African ring in the City," Tolefree resumed. "He's headed straight for the bankruptcy court. But I dare say Mr. Baripper could tell us a lot about that."
"I could," said Baripper. "Waverton's reputation in the Circus is—well, not savoury. But is all this worth while now?"
"No—perhaps not."
Then Toms reappeared and ushered in Ridgway, looking like six feet of misery. Angwin rose and shook hands with him: I liked the gesture. Tolefree motioned him to a chair. The old fellow in his comic costume must have cut an incongruous figure in that drawing-room. But it was not the eccentricity of his clothes—it was the sombre excitement of his cadaverous face that struck me then. Quite certainly Tolefree, the humanest of men, had no idea of putting Ridgway through an ordeal; yet ordeal it was, as his twisting, tortured features showed.
Tolefree explained that he had asked him to be at Polventor in order to satisfy Angwin and Baripper on some points in the Tolliver affair.
"Ridgway, all along you've known you killed Tolliver with that shot you fired, though you had no intention of killing him. That right?"
Ridgway's thin frame trembled, and his burning eyes looked into Tolefree's for a full five seconds before he answered:
"No right to ask me that... Why should I answer?"
"Well," said Tolefree, "that's all the answer I want. I've satisfied myself that you didn't kill him. Is that any satisfaction to you?"
The effect of this was electrical. The man first stiffened into rigidity, then started up across the room, and looked down from his lanky height upon Tolefree.
"You mean that?" he cried in hoarse excitement. "Good God! How could you know?"
Tolefree took him by the arm and led him back to his seat, telling him to take it quietly. The nightmare was over, he said. Ridgway could not have killed Tolliver, because the crime had been traced by indisputable proof to another man—the only other man who could have done it. It was Waverton.
"Ah!" Ridgway cried, throwing up his long arms; "God's mills——"
He broke off panting.
"Answer a few questions, will you?—to clear up obscure points."
Ridgway hung limp on his chair, gave staccato replies, or nodded affirmations.
Tolefree first asked him about the visit of Ada Lanherne—as to whether he had not found her a very different proposition from the girl he had known in the old days. "Difficult, I imagine—very modern, a little impatient of restraint——"
"She was ill," said Ridgway.
"Yes—and fatalistic about it. A brilliant, wilful girl? So I should judge. Rather fascinated by Waverton, wasn't she? Good looks—the cavalier—all that sort of thing?"
"Damn him!"
That was the way the duologue went—about Ridgway's communication to Tolliver, and Tolliver's arrival, and how it was all no good, and how the girl went off to Waverton. And how Ridgway saw red when the tragedy of June in the nursing-home came to his ears; how he tried to get speech with Tolliver about it; and how Tolliver, in his state of nerves and worry, fobbed him off.
"I suppose, when you watched the river that morning, you knew Waverton was leaving in the afternoon, and that was your last chance to get him. You needn't answer that——"
"But I will!" cried Ridgway. "You're wrong. You think of me as a man of blood! You're wrong.... quite wrong. I wanted Sir William Tolliver to know what sort of man was going to marry his sister, and he'd never give me a chance to tell him."
"What! Hadn't you told him in September?"
"No—certainly not... knew nothing about it in September. Not till long after Penhaligon—it was Penhaligon that knew. Ada... she'd never say a word..."
A startling flash-light, that, on the visit Tolliver paid to Rosneven, and the sequel in that unheard talk of his with Ada Lanherne afterwards. Tolefree gazed at Ridgway in silence, then said to Baripper:
"Your private communications——?"
"Yes. I'd no intention of mentioning him. But after the girl had flown I went to see Penhaligon. He told me I was barking up the wrong tree, and he named the right one. He'd already hinted it to Tolliver."
"Ah! We'll have to revise our judgment of the little cockalorum, Farrar," said Tolefree.
So it seemed. At least he was able to hold his tongue on delicate matters: not such a fool as he looked.....
Tolefree turned again to Ridgway.
"You weren't lying up for Waverton, then? But no doubt you can tell us what happened, Ridgeway. He came along the path after Tolliver, didn't he?"
"Stalked him," was Ridgway's way of putting it. Waiting on the opposite bank for Tolliver to appear, he had seen them both come down to the water. They parted. He went through the trees following Tolliver's course, meaning to beg him once more for an interview.
"You had a revolver in your pocket," said Tolefree. "Why?"
"Why? God knows... Carried it ever since Ada died... Often been tempted to use it... You don't want... mere curiosity."
The cadaverous face took on for an instant that tortured look it wore on the day we first saw it.
"Ah! Well, I'd scrap it, Mr. Ridgway," said Tolefree. "But no matter now. You followed Tolliver down on the other side of the river. And Waverton?"
Waverton, it seemed, had suddenly been observed "stalking" Tolliver. He could not have taken more than a few steps upstream before he turned.
"And then, I imagine," said Tolefree, "when Tolliver stopped to rig up his tackle, Waverton hid in the angle of the cliff where those ash trees are. And Tolliver heard some movement of yours, and came to that rock to look across the stream, and took out his revolver just as you were trying to get a sight of Waverton. That right?"
"You saw that... in the negative."
"I saw it all but Waverton. I suppose he'd nipped out of sight. I don't understand why you didn't use your gun at once without troubling about the camera."
"Waverton... furtive, slinking and watching. Didn't think then of violence... Thought a picture might convince Tolliver he was a wrong 'un."
"Didn't think of violence?" Tolefree raised his eyebrows. "But you wouldn't have fired that shot if you hadn't seen something violent. What was it? Did Tolliver hear Waverton behind the trees and swing round with his gun still in his hand, and did you see Waverton and let fly at him?"
"He was coming for Sir William," said Ridgway.
"And immediately you fired, Sir William fell, and you thought you'd shot him. Ever fire a revolver before?"
"Never."
"Well, I reckon you'd have missed an elephant at that distance. And you certainly missed Tolliver. But you were probably scared cold, crept away, and left the field clear for Waverton."
And that was, in fact, the simple explanation of the mystery of Tolliver's death and its appearance of suicide. Ridgway said he had seen Waverton come out from behind the trees, approaching Tolliver's back as he stood looking across the river; that Tolliver had turned as he himself fired at Waverton; that he saw Tolliver fall and thought he had killed him.
"Three shots, then!" Baripper exclaimed.
"Yes—the reverberations that Penhaligon heard. Farrar and Angwin know that I've always wanted three shots. We accounted for two—Ridgway's, which went into the bole of an ash tree yards away, and the one that killed Tolliver. It was Tolliver's we couldn't trace. It looked as if he might have fired it across the river. But I expect it'll be found, if ever, among those trees, or in some crevice of the cliff where it went as Tolliver fired wildly in turning to meet his death."
We had reached this point when Angwin jumped at the sound of a car in the drive, and went to the window.
"Waverton!" he exclaimed.
"What!"
Tolefree sprang up, but before he had taken two strides the door swung open and Ann Carberry came in. She closed the door and stood with her back to it, her face pale and drawn.
"Guy couldn't get the police on the phone, Mr. Tolefree," she said.
Tolefree looked at his watch.
"Not in twenty minutes?"
"No. He got impatient—went off to Carnmenellis in his car."
"Oh?" said Tolefree.
"God's curse on you if you let that man——"
Tolefree leaped at Ridgway and muffled him with a hand.
"Another word, Ridgway, and I'll pitch you through the window! Mr. Baripper, will you take him out now?"
Baripper caught him by the arm and led him away unresisting. Ann Carberry, Angwin and I were left with Tolefree.
"Does Arnold know?" she asked.
Tolefree bent his head. She went across and stood by Angwin.
"Of course he didn't telephone?" said Tolefree.
"No. He had to tell mother something.... something, I don't know what. They were alone. She's crying her eyes out now."
"But you——?"
"It's horrible. But I'm glad. To have gone on would have been more horrible still."
"Ann!"
"Yes, Arnold?"
"You've known this——?"
"No, I've known nothing. But I suspected. You know I could never believe Uncle Bill killed himself. I'd heard whispers about poor Ada. Toms told me Guy had been about here last summer. He'd seen him with her. I couldn't tell mother: she wouldn't have believed a word against him. But the idea of letting them marry was too awful. I've not given a hint of any sort, have I, Mr. Tolefree? You discovered it all without a single suggestion from me?"
Tolefree mumbled an answer. Then he said:
"Angwin, will you stay here and look after Miss Carberry and her mother? Farrar and I will get along to Carnmenellis."
We left them there. Toms came to us in the hall.
"Did Mr. Waverton go up to his room before he left, Toms?" asked Tolefree.
"Yes, sir."
"And have you been there since?"
"Yes, sir. He's taken it with him."
"Poor devil!" muttered Tolefree.
We found Baripper in the drive: Ridgway had gone off alone.
"We're driving to Carnmenellis, Mr. Baripper," said Tolefree; "if you'd like to come with us——"
"What are you going to do, Tolefree?"
"Think about Mrs. Carberry," he replied.
"If he's bolted, you'll have to tell Marrack, won't you?"
"We'll jump that stile when we get there. Coming?"
Baripper got into the back seat of the car; Tolefree sat beside me.
"Am I to try to catch him?" I asked.
"You won't catch him, Farrar."
But after a wordless journey of two miles it seemed that we had caught him. At the bottom of the slope leading to the point where the road bordered the estuary, we saw his car standing by the roadside.
"Stop!" said Tolefree.
The car, perhaps three hundred yards away from us, was empty. I noticed a figure stealing along inside the hedge near by. As I brought my car to rest, the figure stilled. A puff of smoke...
"Gosh!" cried Baripper.
The sound of a shot reached us.
Another puff of smoke...
"Poor devil!" said Tolefree.
A second explosion... The figure behind the hedge burst through it, leapt into the road, and hurled something far out over the water. It fell with a splash. The figure entered the car. It started with a roaring engine to attack the hill. At the crest it swerved violently across the road, dashed through the paling, turned a somersault, and was out of our sight...
A mighty crash came to our ears.
My hands on the steering-wheel shook; every nerve in my body quivered. I felt rather than saw Baripper standing leaning over my shoulder.
"Quick, man—quick!" he urged.
"Wait, Farrar!" said Tolefree sharply.
"You can't let him drown," Baripper protested.
"I'd rather be drowned than hanged—and so would he. But here's something coming. Drive on now, Farrar."
A tradesman's van had appeared at the top of the hill and stopped. In a minute I had drawn up close to it...
A terrible accident. A gentleman's car had got out of control, broken through the fence, fallen over the cliff into twenty feet of water. Nothing could be seen of it as the driver of the van and his boy and the three of us looked down. The driver volunteered to return to the village for help—the police, the coastguard, doctor—while we scrambled down to watch if by any chance the gentleman should have struggled free.
Walking back along the road we had come, we found a practicable place and descended to the water's edge. The tide, nearly at the flood, rolled smoothly by in the sunshine. We waited till a bustling in the road above told us that the driver had done his job.
"Well," said Baripper, "what do we know about this?"
"Nothing," said Tolefree.
"You've thought it all out?"
"I continue," said Tolefree, "to think of Mrs. Carberry."
Roy Glashan's Library
Non sibi sed omnibus
Go to Home Page
This work is out of copyright in countries with a copyright
period of 70 years or less, after the year of the author's death.
If it is under copyright in your country of residence,
do not download or redistribute this file.
Original content added by RGL (e.g., introductions, notes,
RGL covers) is proprietary and protected by copyright.